If you could add one newcomer to each section of the roster, who would they be?

[Deleted member]

For me it'd be:

: Paper Mario
: Dixie Kong
: Skull Kid
: Sylux
: Bandana Waddle Dee
: Uhh...Slippy?
: Anyone that looks interesting honestly.
: Posphera
: Either Hector or Ephriam
: No idea
: Rex & Pyra
: No idea
: Octoling Echo
Retro reps (): Mach Rider
Light hearted thrid party (): Banjo and Kazooie
Serious third party (): Flynn for Shin Megami Tensei

 

[AIM0001]

- Mega Man X
- Geno
- Marx
- Gengar
- Skull Kid
- Krystal
- Porky
- Ms. PAC-Man (Echo)
- Dixie Kong & Kiddy Kong (Ice Climber esque)
- Shadow The Hedgehog (Echo)
- King Boo
- Ashley

 

[Mariomaniac45213]

Mario - Captain Toad (newcomer)

Zelda - Impa (Sheik echo)

Donkey Kong - Dixie Kong (semi-clone)

Star Fox - Krystal (promotion from assist trophy somehow)

F-Zero - Black Shadow (Captain Falcon/Ganondorf echo)

Pikmin - Louie (Olimar echo)

Wario - Captain Syrup

Metroid - Sylux

Kid Icarus - Medusa (Palutena echo)

Pokemon- Decidueye

Splatoon- DJ Octavio

Earthbound - Porky Minch

Kirby - Bandana Dee

Xenoblade - Rex & Pyra

Punch-Out!! - King Hippo

Fire Emblem - Black Knight (simply to give the series a villain)

New franchises:

ARMS - Spring-Man (with the rest of the characters as alts ala the Koopalings)

Golden Sun - Issac

Chibi-Robo - Chibi-Robo

Rhythm Heaven - Chorus Kids

^ These are the only franchises in Smash that deserve another rep IMO. Looking at this list if all these somehow got in and all the 3rd party characters were somehow removed this would be the PERFECT Nintendo roster. No Nintendo fan would be able to complain about a major-esque franchise/ character being missing from the Roster.

 

[Zinith]

- Captain Toad
- Dixie Kong
- Skull Kid
- Anthony Higgs
(Everyone forgets this one) - Boshi
- Bandana Dee
- Leon
- Sceptile
- Ninten
- Bio-Rex
- Black Knight
- Medusa
- 9-Volt
- Louie
- Tom Nook
- Soda Popinski
- Elma
- DJ Octavio
Retro - Mach Rider
3rd Party - Crash Bandicoot

 

[nirvanafan]

Mario: Waluigi
Zelda: Skull Kid
Pokemon: Meowth
Kirby: Adeline
Metroid: Sylux
Star Fox: Krystal
DK: Dixie Kong
Yoshi: Kamek
Earthbound/Mother: Ninten
F-Zero: Black Shadow
Retro: Takamaru
Fire Emblem: Edelgard
Kid Icarus: Viridi
Wario: Ashley
Pikmin: Louie
Animal Crossing: Tom Nook
Punch-Out: King Hippo
Xenoblade: Rex & Pyra/Mythra
Splatoon: DJ Octavio
New IP: Spring Man
Konami: Bomber Man
Sega: Jack Frost
Capcom: Edward Falcon
Namco: Lloyd
Square: Sora
Light Hearted 3rd Party: Banjo & Kazooie
Serious 3rd Party: Ryu Hayabusa

 

[thirsty-pocket]

Mario
It's a toss up between Toad and Geno. I used to think it'd be Toad with no hesitation, but now I think I'd rather have Geno since he's kinda the poster boy for story based Mario, and I think we need story based Mario ro get a lot more attention and fanfare in this day and age where even the Mario RPGs are losing their story.

Donkey Kong Country
Dixie. Anyone else just feels wrong.


Yoshi
To be honeset Yoshi doesn't need anyone else but if I had to pick? Give me Kamek.


The Legend of Zelda
Give me Pig Ganon in the ALBW style with the trident. If we can have three Link clones, we can have two Ganons, where one Ganon is nothing like Ganondorf... it'd be the first proper representation of the series main antagonist to be sure.

Metroid
I honestly think Ridley and Samus are all we need. But if I picked a new one... I guess Sylux since he's looking to be the next big bad... but behing honest, I don't know much else about the character.

Pokemon
If I could have any character, I'd have another trainer. Maybe Lance, or N, or Giovanni, or Professor Oak, I don't want another protagonist.

Kirby
I don't think Kirby needs another one, but if I had to pick, maybe Marx or Adeline and Ribbon.

Star Fox
Krystal. If I can't have deconfirmed characters though, I'll take Slippy, though I'd hate to get Slippy without Peppy...

F-ZERO
Samurai Goroh for sure should be the next F-Zero character but again, if I can't have him, then Black Shadow.

EarthBound
Porky Minch for sure, but Masked Man is a good secondary choice.

Fire Emblem
I don't like Fire Emblem even a little bit but if I had to have another, can it please not be a swordsman? I don't know much aobut FE, but I do know they've got way more than swordsman.

Kid Icarus
Series antagonist Medusa is the only choice imo. I think she should have gotten in before Palutena if i'm being honest.

Wario Ware
Give Me 9-volt. I want him to use Nintendo toys like the ultra hand, chiritori, Labo, the Hanafuda cards... but also some original stuff like his hoverboard.

Sonic the Hedgehog
Dr. Robotnik. If you ask me, he deserves his spot in the series more than Tails does. Unlike a lot of villains, he's actually extremely active in every game he appears in.


...And everyone else I don't think I could pick a character that I would want.
I also don't want to do a retro pick, because I think it's weird and dumb to classify "retro" as one thing. That feels like classifying Arms, Splatoon, Animal Crossing, Wii Fit, and Pikmin under a "modern rep" umbrella term.

 

[Arcadenik]

Captain Toad
Dixie Kong
Ganon (ALTTP version)
Fusion Suit Samus
Baby Mario & Baby Luigi (team like in Mario & Luigi)
Bandana Waddle Dee
Krystal
Team Rocket Meowth
Porky
Samurai Goroh
N/A
Lyn
N/A
Medusa
Overalls Wario (aka “Wario Land” Wario)
N/A
Tails
Alph (give him Rock Pikmin already!)
N/A
Tom Nook
Mega Man X
N/A
King Hippo
Wandering Heroes (StreetPass Mii Plaza: Find Mii I & II)
Ms. Pac-Man
Rex & Pyra
N/A
Chun-Li
Terra Branford
N/A
Octoling
Alucard (based on Symphony of the Night)

 

[Diddy Kong]

Only gonna do franchises am interessted in. I'll add a dash / whenever the choice doesn't matter much to me.

: Captain Toad / Paper Mario
: Dixie Kong, and she's not allowed to be a Echo
: Impa, with her Hyrule Warriors look and moveset
: Raichu (am a simple man with simple wants)
: Anthony mother****ing Higgs, cause I remember that dude
: Yarn Yoshi
: Slippy Toad (R.I.P. Krystal)
: Bandana Dee
: Porky
: Black Knight Zelgius / Celica / Alm
: Hades

And I basically have no interesst in other franchises getting newcomers. For Xenoblade, I prefer Elma over Rex but that's only from the limited knowledge I have of the franchise (unfortunately).

 

[Mogisthelioma]

: Waluigi
: Funky Kong
: Toon Zelda
: Sylux
: Yarn Yoshi echo
: Bandana Waddle Dee
: Krystal
: We have enough already
: Porky
: Black Shadow echo
: Too many already
: Viridi
: Octoling echo

 

[Standlord]

Captain Toad
Dixie Kong (no echo, just Isabelle treatment)
Ashley
Ganondorf rework Skull Kid
Sylux I guess but I don't care much
Yarn Yoshi semi clone
Medusa (no echo, she doesn't even make sense as an echo for many reasons)
Krystal
DeciduDEOXYS
Tom Nook but only if he could cast furniture and stuff and throw it around, if not, no one
Elma
Lyn
Bandana Waddle Dee
Masked Man
Alucard
Terra
Zero

Retro / Hardware / WTF: Mach Rider with the power globe
New first party: Isaac (and this one should take priority over everyone else at this point)
New third party: Monster Hunter

For the rest I don't care / no one

 

[Rie Sonomura]

- Pauline I guess
- Dixie Kong
- James McCloud
- Buzzwole
- Waddle Dee
- Poochy
- Masked Man
- Impa
- Black Shadow
- Celica
- Medusa
- Mona since Ashley’s an AT
- Brittany
- Disco Kid
- Raiden (Rising incarnation)
- Shadow. Or Tails, I guess
- ELMA, no question. Rex & Pyra can be DLC but I need Elma NOW
- Chun-li
- Tifa
- Isabelle — oh wait (in that case that’s all we need)
All other series are fine as is

 

[SmashBro99]

- Waluigi, my most wanted newcomer.
- Dixie, not a huge fan but I got K. Rool, still think a 4th rep would be cool.
- Krystal would have been awesome. Female, check. Spear fighter? Check. Furry? Check.
- Hawlucha, I wish lol.
- Protoman, echo with some unique stuff.
- Ms. Pac Man echo
- Lyn, Hector, Dorcas (fave), literally any character that doesnt ONLY use a sword, they were so unoriginal here, just going with japans favorite waifus.
- Would have loved Knuckles, I'd be happy with Tails or Robotnik, I don't like Shadow but I'd be down if he was unique like Isabelle.
- Skull Kid, as much as I want Wizard/decloned Ganondorf I'd rather we get a fresh face. Impa is also awesome.
- Not really anyone else from FF7 aside from Sephiroth maybe (not a fan but those two would probably be the 2 best faces for that specific game), but as far as Square, Sora.

Don't care about or not interested in the other series'

Or they didn't have any interesting newcomers imo.

 

[RineYFD]

Mario- Um............. does Geno count......? If not then Paper Mario.
WarioWare: WALUIGI! (If I can't choose characters who are already Assists, then I choose Mona)
Yoshi: Boshi as an echo fighter.
Donkey Kong: Dixie
Legend of Zelda: Skull Kid or Lana.
Kirby: Adeleine and Ribbon. Technically two but they share the same slot. Ribbon's just a part of Ado's moveset like the Duck is to the Duck Hunt Dog.
Pokemon: Infernape from the Diamond, Pearl and Platinum games. It' Goku. But a Pokemon version of him.
Metroid: Um............. I guess Rhodus from Metroid Prime 3.
Earthbound: Ninten. To complete the trilogy circle.
Star Fox: Krystal(Again if I cant choose Assists I go with.............. IDK Slippy?)
F-Zero: Black Shadow.
Kid Icarus: Ah shoot.. I don't know who to pick...... Amazon Pandora, Hades or Viridi? I'll go with Hades since that makes sense.
Xenoblade: Rex and Pyra.
Sonic: TAILS!! IF I HAD THE CHANCE TO ADD HIM IN I'D DO IT IN A HEARTBEAT!!!

 

[MrRoidley]

Mario: Captain Toad (or Geno if you count Toad as deconfirmed)
WarioWare: 9-Volt
Yoshi: Yarn Yoshi (echo)
DK: Dixie (Isabelle treatment)
Zelda: SKULL KID!!!!!!!
Pokémon: Raichu (echo)
Kirby: Adeleine & Ribbon
Star Fox: Slippy (original moveset where he builds weapons and deploys them)
F-Zero: Mighty Gazelle (original moveset)
Earthbound: Ninten (echo)
Fire Emblem: Celica (echo)
Kid Icarus: Hades maybe
Pikmin: Alph finally separate from Olimar
Sonic: Shadow (echo)
Animal Crossing: K.K. Slider
Xenoblade: ELMA!!!!!!!!!!!
Retro: Hmm Mike Jones or someone from Pro Wrestling (either Fighter Hayabusa or Starman or both with one as an echo)
Third party: Phoenix Wright

 

[Champion of Hyrule]

-Waluigi (would count as WarioWare if he was in ANY WARIOWARE GAME!!!)
-Funky Kong
-James McCloud
-Dragonite
-Galacta Knight
-Yarn Yoshi
-Master Belch
-Daruk
-Samurai Gohro
-The Black Knight
-Ashley
-Pandora
-Alph (as separate echo fighter)
-King Hippo
-Ocelot
-Dark Zero Suit Samus???
-Ms. Pac-Man
-Octoling
-Zero
-Dracula

 

[Blackwolf666]

Waluigi
Dixie Kong
Krystal
Ashley
Negative man (fite me)
Lyndis
Big Boss
Ganon
Incineroar
Rex & Pyra
bandana dee
Octoling
Dr Eggman
Protoman

 

[Deleted member]

: Fawful or Dimentio, former would be more realistic.
: I agree with Dixie Kong
: Mipha or some other BotW champions to cover some more iconic Zelda races
: I think I'm good on Metroid for now, will update my opinion once Metroid Prime 4 is out.
: Marx would be a good villain representative for Kirby.
: Andross. And no, he isn't "too big". His cape design could easily be implemented as an interesting and unique character.
: Gardevoir is a good choice imo, since it is a fan favorite.
: Hades would be great in any capacity. Hell, even if he appears as a boss I'll be fine with that.
: I would like to see Tiki, or an axe/lance rep. For the latter perhaps Hector and Ephraim?
: Pokey would be the ideal next addition.
: Miss me with this franchise tbh
: We're covered now that Isabelle was announced. Perhaps an "Animal Villager" with different animal character alts?
: I'd be up for Marina, or Pearl, for some Spa2n representation. Alternatively, yeah, Octoling echos do sound nice.
Retro reps (): I got nothing. Burger Chef perhaps? lol
Light hearted thrid party (): Shantae
Serious third party (): Doomguy

 

[Vanguard227]

Mario: Geno, if he counts. If not, Waluigi
Donkey Kong: Dixie Kong
Legend of Zelda: Skull Kid
Metroid: Sylux
Yoshi: Boshi
Kirby: Bandana Dee
Star Fox: Krystal (She obviously wouldn't still be an AT in the game in this hypothetical scenario)
Pokemon: Decidueye
Mother: Masked Man
F-Zero: Black Shadow
Fire Emblem: Black Knight
Kid Icarus: Hades
Wario Ware: Ashley
Metal Gear: Raiden (Either MGS4, or Rising Revengeance Raiden)
Sonic: Robotnik
Pikmin: Louie
Animal Crossing: Tom Nook
Mega Man: Proto Man
Punch Out!!: Bald Bull
Pac Man: Ms. Pac Man
Xenoblade: Elma
Street Fighter: Ken
Final Fantasy: Kefka
Bayonetta: Jeanne
Splatoon: Octoling
Castlevania: Alucard (same as Krystal)
Retro () : Diskun
Wii () : Sebastian Flute (There's like no one else that would fit in this category, so it's a stretch. XD )

Light hearted third party: Banjo-Kazooie
Serious third party: Nightmare (Soul Calibur)

 

[Oddball]

(the Mario section) - Toad. Not Captain Toad. Regular normal Toad.

(the Mario but not-quite Mario section) Ashley

(the Donkey Kong section) Pauline. (Does she not count as a Dk rep? If not, then DK Jr.)

(the Zelda section) Big blue pig Ganon

(Pokemon section) Team Rocket

(Metroid section) ... umm... this is a tough one. The first one that comes to mind is Justin Bailey Samus, but that would make 4 Samuses in Smash and that feels like too much. My next idea would be the SA-X in heavily mutated form, but again ... that's another Samus. Let's say Mother Brain. We'll figure out how to make it work later.

(Kirby section) ... I'm not really attached to any other Kirby newcomer. Susie maybe. Or Prince Fluff.

(Fire Emblem section) Tharja or Hector. I'll have to flip a coin.

(Earthbound section) Flint.

(Star Fox section) Andross

(Kid Icarus section) Eggplant Wizard

(Mii section. There's three of them. They get a section) Nikki from Swapnote fame)

(Animal Crossing section. This would look better if Isabelle had an icon) ... I have no idea. Mr. Ressitti?

(the Retro Section) Mike Jones

(the really really retro section) Frogger ... but you could probably talk me into Joust Knight if you tried.

(the "Wait. Who did you just say was in the game? Seriously?" section) Captain N the Game Master

(the other Miscellaneous Nintendo characters section) Pious Augustus

(The Capcom section) - Sir Arthur from Ghosts and Goblins

(Konami section) Bomberman!

(the other Miscellaneous Third Party section) Billy Lee from Double Dragon

 

[Crystanium]

: Waluigi
: Dixie Kong
: Impa
: Anthony Higgs
: Gooey or Animal Friends
: Krystal
: Decidueye
: Samurai Goroh or Black Shadow
: Giygas or Porky
: ?
: Medeus
: ?
: Medusa
: Plasm Wraith
: ?
: ?
: Doc
: ?
: Pyra
: ?
: Raiden
: Knuckles
: Proto Man
: Ghost (Palettes are based on Chaser, Ambusher, Fickle, and Feigned Ignorance.)
: Akuma
: Sephiroth
: Jeanne
: Octoling
: Dracula

 

[Battiest Badger]

- Waluigi - I don't need him, but I think he could be interesting. I'd like to see some Mario Strikers inspired moves.
- Cranky Kong
- Mipha
- Marx
- Andross - In all his floaty head glory
- Weavile
- Medusa
- Ashley
- Tails

 

[YoshiandToad]

Notes:
There's no one I wanted from Castlevania so I just expanded it to Konami as a whole, hence Bomberman.
Bubbles crossed over all retros, because honestly there's no real retros I'm rooting for now Duck Hunt(the only one I wanted) is in. Maybe Balloon Fighter but Villager stole his schtick.
9-Volt could easily replace Bubbles for retro references.
Isabelle would have been instead of Nook but since she got confirmed last week, time to pay(ha) Nook his dues.
Nikki is part of the Mii franchise
Louie uses the bugs
Meowth comes with Team Rocket inspired moveset
Captain Toad is best boy, but could easily be swapped for regular Toad. Just get one of those good boys in.

 

[DarthEnderX]

I'd steal slot from all the other categories and put them all in 3P retros!

 

[Kevandre]

- Totes Paper Mario. A full on 64/TTYD inspired Paper Mario. all specials involve partner stuff. Please.

- Dixie Kong. Not a Diddy echo, though I guess like a semi-echo is okay.

- Impa, based on Hyrule Warriors. That was some cool stuff.

- RUNDAS. Ice Climbers and Lucas are woefully lacking in a true ice-based character. Rundas can be that character. Plus, Chris Sabat.

Kamek my bois. Listen. Low mobility in general but fires his playstation button spell at ridiculous range and can teleport and use broom. Perfection

- Sorry Bandana fans. I think he'd be fun but I think MARX would be much more fun.

- Slippy based on this idea

- Incineroar. He chucks fire out of his dong and I really want to see how that'll look in Smash Bros. I'm stoked that he's like the current rumored Pokemon for this reason alone. If not for that I'd absolutely be picking Decidueye.

- Duster. It'd be an odd fit, a second Mother 3 character... and yet... he'd be so different from Ness and Lucas (Though probably stealing rope snake). But staple gun tho

- Black Shadow to give Ganondorf moveset to so he can finally be unique lol

- Ephraim. I think adding him as a lance user would be excellent. I'd be okay with swapping out some of the FE Smash characters to get more unique ones, even though I don't mind the ones we have at all. But I'd like to see a better representation of the series. Give me like Ephraim on lance, Hector on axe, Niles or Virion on bow... Again don't get me wrong I love all our sword users but there's better potential here tbh

- Hades because he's hilarious.

- Can I pick Waluigi? He's not exactly a Wario character but... If not I'd probably go with Ashley just because she'd be unique

- I honestly have no preference here. I guess Louie?

- Tbh two is probably good. Tom Nook is the obvious choice but lemme throw this out there- Blanca. Blanca with a customizable face option in like the Mii customization menu. I'm into it.

- Mike Tyson final smash biting an ear off

- I'm not against Rex/Pyra/Mythra. I'd probably pick them but part of me very much wants Reyn

- I guess an Octoling but - and this is important - one of the skins is Marina

Retro - Mike Jones from Startropics. Let's reboot this series so Nintendo can keep making the classic Zelda style games but with a different series lol. Smash is the way to get that started.

3rd Party - Banjo. Since I can't get Shovel Knight, I'll absolutely go with the bear&bird.

 

[Gothitelle]

- Geno
- Funky Kong
- Birdo
- Ashley
- Midna
- Gandrayda
- Marx
- Slippy Toad
- Gothitelle
- Kumatora
- Blood Falcon
- Lyn
- Medusa
- Alph
- Tom Nook
- Doc Louis
- Kosmos (does Xenosaga count?)
- MGS2 Raiden
- Shadow
- Alucard
- Proto-Man
- Chun-Li
- Jeanne
/ - Ayumi Tachibani
// - Satebo & Parabo

 

[AustarusIV]

- Paper Mario
- Dixie Kong
- Ganon
- Sylux
- Poochy
- Bandana Dee
- Krystal
- Incineroar
- Lyn
- Ashley
- Shadow
- Elma
- Chun Li
- Terra Branford
- Octoling
- Alucard

 

[DemonRhys]

: Paper Mario (Newcomer)
: Dixie Kong (Newcomer or Diddy Kong Echo)
: Impa (Shiek Echo)
: Sylux (Newcomer)
: Kamek (Newcomer)
: Bandana Dee (Newcomer)
: Panther Caroso (Wolf Echo)
: Decidueye (Newcomer)
: Ninten (Ness Echo)
: Black Shadow (Captain Falcon Echo)
: Hector (Newcomer or Ike Echo)
: K. K. Slider (Newcomer)
: Ashley & Red (Newcomer)
: Viridi (Newcomer or Palutena Echo)
: Raiden (Newcomer)
: Tails (Newcomer)
: Louie (Olimar Echo)
: Ms. Pac-Man (Pac-Man Echo)
: Rex & Pyra (Newcomer)
: Alucard (Newcomer
: Ken (Ryu Echo)
: Jeanne (Bayonetta Echo)
: Roll (Newcomer)
: Mii Mage (Newcomer)
: Octoling (Inkling Echo)
: Glass Joe (Little Mac Echo)

 

[Crystanium]

I find it interesting that people mention Octoling. I won't say I'm the first, but I feel like I am, at least on SmashBoards. After I found out about Octolings, I thought they'd be a better choice than DJ Octavio and simpler to create as a semi-clone. Now others are mentioning Octolings.

 

[Fire Emblemier]

- Geno
- Dixie Kong
- Impa
- Honestly after Ridley and Dark Samus, anyone else would be seen as straw grasping imo
- Birdo?
- Bandanna Dee
- Krystal
- *insert someone's favorite pokemon*
- Ninten
- Can barely remember most of the F Zero cast to pick one
- Lyndis
- Medusa
- Ashley
- Louie
- *Insert someone's favorite AC character*
- Mike Tyson
- Elma
- Octoling
- Raiden
- Tails
- Alucard
- Proto-Man
- Chun-Li
- Jeanne
3rd Party - Banjo

 

[Luigifan18]

All I've got is Vaati for Legend of Zelda and Dragonite or Corsola for Pokémon. Oh, and Krystal for Star Fox. And Captain Toad for Mario. And Shadow or Tails for Sonic.

 

[Izanagi97]

For the Metal Gear series, I'd take Raiden.

 

[Iko MattOrr]

- Geno (if it counts as Mario; if not, Waluigi)
- Dixie Kong
- Vaati I forgot: GANON
- Sylux
- Baby Mario & Baby Luigi (duo)
- Adeleine & Ribbon
- Krystal (Peppy and Slippy make more sense but Krystal has more gameplay potential)
- I don't know... probably Meowth, Scizor or Meloetta
- I have no idea
- Black Shadow (With Ganondorf's Smash 4 moveset; Ganondorf decoloned)
(retro) - Balloon Fighter (with Alice as a costume or as an echo)
- I have no idea
- I have no idea (I haven't played Uprising)
- Captain Syrup (Warioland), Ashley or Mona (Wario Ware)
- I have no idea
- Knuckles (even if Tails or Eggman are more important, I think Knuckles would fit better)
- Louie with a semiclone moveset
- Tom Nook or K. K. Slider
- Someone of Zero, Protoman, Bass and Megaman.EXE
(casual/hardware) - Nintendo Labo (cardboard character)
- I have no idea (I haven't played the games)
- Miss Pacman (echo)
- I have no idea (I haven't played the games)
- Mr Bison
- Black Mage/White Mage (from the classics)
- I have no idea
- Octoling
- I have no idea

 

[Michael the Spikester]

: King Boo
: Dixie Kong
: Skull Kid
: Kanden
: Kamek
: Bandana Dee
: General Scales
: N/A
: Porky Minch
: Black Shadow or Bio Rex
: N/A
: Black Knight
: N/A
: Medusa
: Mona
: Raiden
: Vector the Crocodile
: No idea
: N/A
: N/A
: N/A
: N/A
: Glass Joe or King Hippo
: N/A
: N/A
: Rex & Pyra
: N/A
: Akuma
: N/A
: N/A
: Octoling
: N/A

 

[31fps]

: Waluigi
: Funky Kong
: Linkle
Yarn Yoshi as an echo figher?
: Bandana Waddle Dee
: Too many if you ask me
: Porky
: Viridi. That's all I ask
: Same as pokemon (Holy crap)
: Ashley
: DJ Octavio

 

[Putuk]

: Someone from the spinoff RPGs, for some reason, those get next to no content whatsoever in Smash.
: IDK Cranky or Dixie I guess?
: Skull Kid
: Omega Metroid
: Kamek
: Bandanna Dee, but instead of just spear moves, he also uses Parasol moves and draws from the various things Dees have done throughout the series (people who think he'd have a bland moveset arn't thinking it through hard enough)
: Leon (as a Falco echo or semi-clone)
: Guzma & Golisopod
: Giygas (Mewtwo echo)
: please give them anything, they deserve attention
: Someone who's not a sword dude? From what I understand the series has a number of interesting/unique characters, but they always get shafted in favor of the main character, who is always a sword guy.
: I don't really like what they've done with this series and Hades is one of the most baffling (in a bad way) character designs I've ever seen, so I guess Medusa as a Palutna echo?
: Gosh, Warioware has so many funny characters, any of them would be welcome!
: Most of the characters in this series are military guys and Snake covers that quite well. Raiden perhaps?
: Blaze (as a Sonic semi-clone)
: Louie controlling insects
: Tom Nook hits you with a bag of money, killing you instantly.
: Bass as a completely unique character, his smashes involve him sicing Treble at the opponent.
: King Hippo
: Is there anyone really? At best there's Ms. Pac-Man as a skin.
: Nobody 'cuz XC2 panders to gross sweaty pedophiles and forgoes its rights to get newcomers.
: Everyone seems to be into Ken as the echo, but wouldn't Akuma be more visually interesting?
: I'll take ANY Amano-designed character. Cecil, Gilgamesh, Terra, I don't care, I'd just love a not to something pre-Nomura.
: I'm really not that familiar with the series, sorry. Just please someone who is actually fun to play against.
: Octolings seem like a dead ringer, but if there was a way to make DJ Octavio work, that'd be neat.
: Captain N Simon

 

[NintenEdgyMan]

- Dementio
- Skull Kid
- Sylux
- Grovyle
- Dixie
- Maglor
- Grima
- KK Slider
- Giygas
- Black Shadow
- Fiora
- Octoling
- Krystal
- Polar Bear
- Glass Joe
- Louie
- Hades
- Kamek
- Ashley

(Retro)- Mach/Exictebiker moveset fusion
(Light retro)- Geno
(Gray retro)- Monster Hunter
(Dark retro)- Master Cheif

 

[Deleted member]

I'd steal slot from all the other categories and put them all in 3P retros!

Out of all those characters I recognize Mario, Link, Samus, Kirby, Pit, Mega Man, Simon Belmont, Ryu Hayabusa, Bill Rizer, the Black Mage, Rash, and Arthur. Whose everyone else?

 

[DarthEnderX]

Whose everyone else?

Mario [Super Mario Bros.]
Link [Legend of Zelda]
Samus [Metroid]
Mega Man [Mega Man]
Simon [Castlevania]
Pit [Kid Icarus]
Black Mage [Final Fantasy]
Bill Rizer [Contra]
Kirby [Kirby]
Kunio [River City Ransom]
Snake [Metal Gear]
Billy Lee [Double Dragon]
Bub [Bubble Bobble]
Ryu Hayabusa [Ninja Gaiden]
Spencer [Bionic Commando]
Arthur [Ghosts 'n Goblins]
Rash [Battletoads]

I'd also have Erdrick from Dragon Quest on there, but his NES sprite really looks like ****.

 

[scoobymcsnack]

- Waluigi
- Dixie Kong
- Ashley
- Kamek
- Impa
- Sylux
- Bandana Dee
- Slippy Toad
- Incineroar
- Viridi
- Edelgard
- Ninten
- Elma
- Tom Nook (Echo of )
- Octoling (Echo of )
- Black Shadow (Echo of or )
- Louie (Echo of )
- Ayumi Tachibana
(Capcom) - Arthur (Ghosts n' Goblins)
(Sega) - Dr. Eggman
(Namco) - Heihachi
(Konami) - Bomber Man
(Square Enix) - Geno

 

[DBPirate]

Toad or Captain Toad (either one. I don't really care)
Dixie Kong
Skull Kid
Sylux, I suppose. Not that familiar with Metroid
Kamek
Bandana Dee
Slippy
Decidueye or Incineroar
Porky
Black Shadow
Lyn
Viridi
Ashley
Raiden
Tails
Louie
Tom Nook
Ms. Pac-Man
Elma
Ken
Jeanne
Octoling
(Retro) Takamaru
No clue