Hammer. Sorry I wasn't here earlier, but I had class early in the mourning and I had to sleep afterwards.
J most of your replay isn't really even a defense, but more so simply an attempt to discredit me.
I got bored and couldn't sleep so I decided to go at Swords' recent post.
You are creating a backdoor with my lynch to make it seem like I'm the best lynch candidate no matter what I flip so you can look better.
Then again, Look at it from my PoV cuz that's what I'm seeing Swordy.
Since when is having a backup lynch constitute as creating a backdoor? Last time I checked, in pretty much every game ever people have had back burner lynches, so why is it the sudden scummy now?
How is this scummy? Lots of words, no answers as to why.
Read downwards. This was a prerequisite of things to come.
Also attempt number 1 to simply discredit my push rather than actually defend against it.
Changed my reads alot? Kay, how's that scummy? You don't care for what I done to them? Well their my reads so why does your opinion really delve into what I think, so tell me how that's scummy? Nothing has happened to make it change, I got 2 PR claims out of SvT group and I came to about thinking Gheb/Joey as town, that's enough grounds to change some reads around.
You tell me you don't like the way I handled Sang, yet again, no explanation as to why.
Read further here:
Are you kidding me? Do I REALLY have to explain why it's scummy to change SO MANY reads at the drop of the hat? If you lack the critical thinking skills to figure that one out on your own, then quite frankly you probably shouldn't be playing mafia.
Well, it's because it makes you look disingenuous. You don't actually care to evaluate your reads, but rather, your simply changing them to fit your self-interest. It makes the entire effort you went through originally seem like a farce, since your changing them with so little.
I don't care for the way you went about because again, there is very little apparent that made you change those reads.
I mean hell, just look at me. After literally being inactive for about half a day (where I've COULDN'T of done anything to change your mind) you all of the sudden had the revelation that I was was scummy after being one of your strongest town reads. Well whoops, I guessed you kinda missed that one completely.
Don't say just "some reads around," because in the course of some 30ish hours you've pretty much flipped your read list on it's head. me/Sang/Joey/Gheb/TM/the 3 inactives. That's more than half the game, J.
You quote me but don't point out where that's scummy. You say your hard pressed to see my change of heart, yet how is that scummy? Swords, explain things please cuz there are no answers here. Why do you think the pick a lynch question was the reason?
Again, are you kidding me? You really can't see why one may think you're scummy for changing a great deal of reads around without explaining it?
Well again, J, I have absolutely no idea where your head is at because of it. How can I tell if your genuinely changing SO MANY reads around if you don't explain it?
Interesting stuff as in, her slot is interesting to me because I may reading her wrong. Her stuff is interesting because it gives me mixed vibes on her posts. Head is one way, heart is another.
Since when does it matter when a gut read keeps me from getting a read on someone?
J, I like to think your above gut. Or at the very least I like to think that you're smart enough not to completely counter-balance a read based off of intuition.
What is it about her that made you wary?
Swords, yet again I'm asking the same question I've asked above. How is this scummy dude? You say a lot of things yet nothing to state why it's scummy in my actions. Why is changing reads scummy? How is "not staying true" seeming as scummy rather than town trying to find the right answers? If you are calling me out on this, why aren't you calling TM who did the same to me? Why are you not backing up your stuff yet making big posts that make it look like you are?
Again trying to discredit me with that last line. Rather than defend your just pointing out flaws you find in the push.
I've already explained this twice, so I won't again. It's true that townie's should be more concerned with what is right then just holding fast to reads, but the way you've gone about it (without explaining your reasoning and instead just inserting it there) is not been evidence of that a all.
You have not explained nor shown how the actions as of late bother you as scummy behaviour. You say that you are on me now because I am scummy and not just anti-town. Show me.
Most people of average intelligence should of been able to figure it out, but there you go.
This is a terrible paragraph in describing your newfounded dislike for TM once a case has popped up on him. The last line in particular sets off alarm bells because it's a WIFOMy point. IN this paragraph you say that you like what Joey was done but you don't give a definite opinion on TM, you just say he's interesting and that you are wafflying a bit.
So what if there was already a case on him? Again, stop trying discredit my pushes with generic "oh someone else did it before so Sword is just sheeping" bullcrap. Everyone is going to have to vote after someone else sometime, so why is what I'm doing special?
If you're basing this around some perception of me that I'm the guy who moves things as town then stop it. There has been both games where I've made cases and and followed behind them.
WRT the last line:
1. No it's not?
2. Making these types of accustions is generally how one scumhunts?
Also yes I'm waffling, because I saw town intent behind his play earlier.
Also strange that earlier in this post you call me out for not calling TM out, although in the same post you quoted where I DID call him out, just not for the very same exact reasons as you.
---
J if you're truly town then I applaud you for putting up a fight until the very end. Besides from that though, I'm honestly not impressed with your play at all besides from that.
Like auspher I don't see anything scum like in his posts, but there has to be something I don't see that they do.
