HERB discussion Thread *NEW STUFF FIRST POST*

[KillerSOS]

Define planking and define banned.

I want it banned don't get me wrong but we need clear rules.

 

[Vilt]

New discussions, some old ones.

Alright. I'm thinking if we do the JLR change the grabs to 80.
Pots will be a five way split.
HERB 2 say what? I was thinking August 8-9 or sometime in Nov.
we need to go over D3's infinite. how to enforce, or maybe change it to kinda the wobbling rule? if so no CG over 140%.

 

[Ragnar0k]

DDD should have to dash before he regrabs.

If for some reason we don't do the japanese ledge grab rule we could do something like more than 5 ledge regrabs done consecutively without getting on the stage with the intention of stalling results in the forfeit of that stock.

 

[Dr Peepee]

JLR went up or down?

Fine with me.

Thought Jubilee was happening this summer? If not, then August 8-9th would be best for me.

I don't like DDD's infinite, but I don't know enough whether to argue for or against it.

 

[Vilt]

No pp. **** just happens where you have to grab the ledge too much so i decided on 80.

and if the jubilee is going down in august then i'll do herb 2 in nov

 

[KillerSOS]

70 is more than enough.... thats 1 every 6 seconds. I was playing Flamingo and he planked and still didn't get 70.

 

[Vilt]

**** it, lets stick to 70

 

[lord karn]

you can do herb2 in august

 

[Vilt]

you sure bro? i don't want HERB 2 to take the place of the best tourney in NC. Jubilee is the ****.

 

[lord karn]

We'll just schedule around herb2. I haven't really thought about when the next jubilee will be yet.

 

[Vilt]

alright well if you come up with a date lemme know.

 

[onlymaskde]

You should post pools.

(Melee)

 

[stingers]

Split the pot 5 ways if you get 100 or more, post pools.

 

[Foxy]

post melee pools, i wanna know what matchups to practice

and if i'm in m2k's pool i'm gonna save money and not come kk?

 

[BEHR]

post melee pools, i wanna know what matchups to practice

and if i'm in m2k's pool i'm gonna save money and not come kk?

Dont be a sweet and sour beetch.

 

[Dr Peepee]

Post any pools you want, sunshine.

 

[stingers]

quick switch foxy to m2ks pool

 

[Collective of Bears]

Post the pools nao.

 

[Dr Peepee]

7. August is cool with me
8 70 is actually possible
9.postpostpost

 

[Foxy]

lol i was just kidding

i'd love to play m2k in pools <3

 

[ph00tbag]

gogogo pools.

 

[Ragnar0k]

pools get.

 

[I am Seth]

**** gay *** infinates. you can go sit on a broom if you do that gay ****.

 

[Ragnar0k]

**** gay *** infinates. you can go sit on a broom if you do that gay ****.

lol QFT.

 

[OmniOstrich]

The small step CG is almost equally as bad. You get +70% on wario from one side of FD to the other, and if you do the grab-release upsmash at the end its +80%. So basically two grabs and thats a death, especially since the usmash is inescapable and will kill at the % wario will be at.

 

[Foxy]

brackets nao

^________________________^

oh and, herb2 in the summer pleese?

 

[BEHR]

brackets nao

^________________________^

oh and, herb2 in the summer pleese?

Herb is obviously going to be in the summer. ._____________.

 

[KillerSOS]

No brackets yet?

Not that I am in Melee lolz

 

[NC-Echo]

The small step CG is almost equally as bad. You get +70% on wario from one side of FD to the other, and if you do the grab-release upsmash at the end its +80%. So basically two grabs and thats a death, especially since the usmash is inescapable and will kill at the % wario will be at.

lol, don't take out small-step that would be dumb.

 

[Dr Peepee]

Come on Bill you gotta support that statement a little. =p

 

[mr.fizwidget]

the only problem i see with the Japanese ledge snap rule is that if you say you cant grab the ledge 70 times in one match then, what you are saying, is that you can grab the ledge 69 times in one match.

For example, if i am playing a rolly spammy lucario guy, and we are both on our last stock, and i gain a slight percentage lead, and i have not previously planked, then this rule allows me to plank for a considerable amount of time and possibly the remainder of the match, as long as i dont go over 70.

 

[Ragnar0k]

Which is why I believe that a rule stating you cannot go over a certain amount of consecutive ledge grabs without getting on stage would be more effective.

 

[I am Seth]

planking is for ***s.

 

[NC-Echo]

1. Yes, but there is nothing wrong with short stepping. @ Peepee: dont get grabbed as Wario at the end of FD.
2. Either way is fine.
3. Looks good
5. 3, I guess. Shouldn't make too much of a difference.
6. yes 5 way at least.
7. Either one.
8 . 70
9. I would recommend against this even though everyone seems to disagree with me. It's only gonna make people *****. Plus some people may back out if they look at their pools and think they can't make it out. Please take this into consideration because I believe its a real possibility.

 

[Vilt]

Post any pools you want, sunshine.

Did you just call me sunshine? o.o Imma kick your ***.

Edit: Bill speaks the truth on that last one.

 

[Dr Peepee]

I was talkin to you or BEHR.

Can you PM me my pool Vilt? XD

 

[Foxy]

mine as well.

it would be super cool, really.

 

[Malk]

do not post pools and do not pm them to people ahead of other people are you ****ing dumb?

 

[Dr Peepee]

Lol I wasn't serious anyways.

That still defeats the purpose or posting pools....but I still wish I could know anyway. =p

 

[stingers]

pp when are you coming on friday