Well I have had my own opinion on the Melee Vs Brawl debate for a while, and I've kept it to myself. People saying "Brawlz iz 4 n4rbs 1t t4kes n0 sk177" or something a long those lines I can't stand. I do believe Melee took more skill to be good at, but not as much as some people portray it, brawl just takes a different kind of skill. I play a completely offensive game, I'll shield, roll, and side step of course instead of just being hit, but my main game revolves around offense, and I'm considered to be in the handful of best diddys out there (not trying to brag, honestly). So I completely agree that camping can be beat, and quite easily if people can figure their opponent out.
Thats my opinion towards Melee Vs Brawl and camping, now on to the REAL topic here.
I haven't been keeping up with heavy type of gameplay for a while so excuse me for my ignorance, the last time i heard about heavy brawl was when people were just realizing how it felt like melee.
From what I have read, the whole point in this would be a more exciting game and less boring and slow, correct?
Imagine Brawl to be a game of Chess, and heavy brawl/Melee like a game of football. What would you rather watch? I'd choose football, a game that is almost constantly moving, people getting tackled, hurt, and amazing plays which people in today's society find exiting. The game of chess would be a slow game of wits. You have to be thinking ahead and what your opponent might do next and counter it.
So why do people play chess instead of football sometimes?
1. They're better at the game, and like glory and the feel of being higher ranked than others. Winning is something every human might not want, but it's what every human prefers it's part of being a human, and therefor will get a better feeling of this through something they're good at.
2. They think a slow game of wits, and strategy is fun over and action packed sport.
I'm not saying heavy brawl/melee, by any means, does not take strategy or wits to win. In football they have plays they run, etc that requires this. I'm saying it takes a different kind of thinking to it than heavy brawl/melee and in some cases brawl does take more thinking power behind it. Melee was all about fast fingers and just hitting your opponent with combo after combo, like football is all about muscle and speed with plays behind it. Brawl is all about a strong defense, with some offensive maneuvers thrown in and takes more strategy (in most cases not necessarily all cases), like Chess it requires more thought and strategy.
Basically what I'm saying is that too a lot of people, a slow campy game will always be more exciting than a faster combo wise game, and taking brawl from what it is suppose to be away from these people doesn't sound fair to change it into what it's not suppose to be for others.
In all honesty, I think we should split brawl up between heavy brawl and normal brawl, and have a 4th section here in the SWF (SSB64, SSBM, SSBB, SSBB Heavy) IF POSSIBLE, but obviously this would take a lot of work and will most likely end in an epic disaster.
Sorry if I'm being an idiot here and didn't read something through
But it really sounds like Melee. I wonder if you can do Link's Utilt combo into a Uair now.... I'll go try. 
