Harry Potter And the Deathly Mafia - Peeves/Mafia WIN!

[Tom]

by missed, i mean hit a townie

note that i do not think, if there is a vigilante, that they should have to claim. just remember the numbers game tonight and dont tip the scales.

 

[mentosman8]

To respond to mac, I'm surprised they didn't try to make a move on dumbledore/harry too, but I think it may have to do with my character's role in the books making them somewhat paranoid

 

[#HBC | Mac]

tom...

if we mislynch, and two townies die tomorrow. doesn't that leave us with 8 people. For us to lose, 4 of them would have to be mafia. which would mean there were 5 mafia... I doubt that that is the case

though i agree, vig should not randomly shoot. But i personally believe the second kill was the work of an sk.

 

[Tom]

You're right, I did the numbers wrong. I was thinking that with 16 there is a mafia of 4, but forgot to add in the fact that Frozenflame is dead.

So the numbers game is still up for grabs. A vigilante is probably still okay to shoot.

 

[smashman90]

Tom, I think I know a possible location where you can find some gillyweed in here. Can't promise that it'll be there, but it is kinda likely. Try the Herbology Greenhouse. I'm not sure if we can learn spells in this game or not, but you could try looking in the library for a spell to allow to breathe underwater. I know there is the Bubble-Head Charm, which is probably more effective than Gillyweed but again, I'm not sure if we can learn new spells in this game.

 

[Tom]

Yeah, I'm versed enough in the books that I know what the options are, but I was just hoping that someone had stumbled upon some Gillyweed they could privately or publically give to me, or knew a spell to give me gills for tomorrow night.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

mentos, answer toms question.

 

[mentosman8]

Ah missed tom's question as I'm on my phone right now. No, I was not able to go anywhere last night. When I left the great hall I was hit and was unable to leave to go to my intended destination.

 

[Yaya]

As you may of heard, I was in the Girls Washroom, I was planning on heading to the Chamber of Secrets, and to my shock, the door had already been opened, next night I will have the option of continuing in if I wish.

 

[Tom]

I would like to think that Omis was going to investigate Mentosman.

If we are to assume that, then the mafia would want to either roleblock or kill Omis if Mentosman were mafia. Omis died in the night.

Mentosman was roleblocked. But he has been pretty suspicious since Day 1 and the foeglass, and he has been at the forefront since. If he is roleblocked, it clears him. So the mafia wouldn't do it unless they wanted to clear him, as Marshy and I and others made the argument that Niiro was clearable and Yaya was clearable by the roleblock. So a fake roleblock would be logical.

Some of that compounds on what Macman said, but it is true. If I had to choose a lynch right now, it would be Mentosman.

However, we have all day.

 

[Tom]

Also, Omis was naive cop, meaning his investigations on Tom and Yaya were automatically the town-aligned result.

Ronike was regular cop, and I will go back through his posts to see on Day 2 if he dropped us any tells for his Night 1 investigation. Just with cursory thought, he could have investigated Omis, as he was suspicious of him but then dropped the suspicion?

 

[Handorin]

Something smells fishy here...
must be Tom from going to the lake.
and he's hagrid and always smells.

or it's cause I was also crucio'd. I was supposed to be on Omis since he was cop (naive, but we couldnt know)

 

[#HBC | Mac]

well then mentos, any last words?

 

[Omis]

Thanks for the great game everyone.
Go town!

 

[Tom]

Hmm. I'm curious to hear what everyone thinks about mentosman v. handorin crucio situation. I have some thoughts but I would much rather see who else is on the same page.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

has anyone else ever been crucioed and didn't say anything about it?

I don't see why hando would lie about that. Unless somehow when he died the first time, we weren't given his accurate role. And he's actually mafia framing mentos. But I don't see why mafia would even want to frame mentos, he was pretty **** suspicious as it is.

 

[Handorin]

has anyone else ever been crucioed and didn't say anything about it?

I don't see why hando would lie about that. Unless somehow when he died the first time, we weren't given his accurate role. And he's actually mafia framing mentos. But I don't see why mafia would even want to frame mentos, he was pretty **** suspicious as it is.

It wouldnt make sense for me to be a different role. frozen came back the same, and since it was a time turner, we only went back in time. I'm still a doc.

 

[Niiro]

Go town. It is hard to be happy without a soul D:

 

[Tom]

It is interesting to me because there is an obvious logical jump between roleblocking nobody and claiming to have been roleblocked and roleblocking somebody and claiming to have been roleblocked (producing conflicting results, like we have). If Mentosman is mafia, then there was either a failure of communication or they literally thought they would get away with roleblocking our trusted Dumbledore doctor and claiming roleblocked at the same time. See the missing logic there? Why would they do that?

 

[mentosman8]

Well, Ill post my thoughts when I get home from work, I have a couple things to say when I get the chance.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

booo, do em now!

 

[Superstar]

As you may of heard, I was in the Girls Washroom, I was planning on heading to the Chamber of Secrets, and to my shock, the door had already been opened, next night I will have the option of continuing in if I wish.

Well, if you want to turn to stone, be my guest.

I'll clear something up, all the repeated vote unvotes I often made were shows of anger. So when I unvoted voted Smashman a million times, it was because he name AND roleclaimed.

All the players that are alive are:

SIGN UPS
1. junglefever6478
3. .cat//tomato
4. Macman
6. karthik_king
8. 1048576
10. Marshy
11. mentosman8
12. Superstar [whatever you want to believe]
13. smashman90 [I can confirm him]
15. Handorin [confirmed]
16. Yaya

This doesn't look like a "mashup", so Yaya and Tom [nameclaimed big roles] may be innocent. Mentos, well, I don't know, but it seems like a bad idea to point out the Foe glass thing if you're mafia. I know I wouldn't, especially since at that point Mentos did not know Yaya went to the same room [Foe's Glass could have gone all over...],

And yes, Karthik has been completely under the radar.

Early uneducated suspicion list of "feels":
Macman
Karthik
Numbers
Marshy

That is the extent of it. I need to reread to get more ideas, but I couldn't get any sort of read on them. Do what you will.

That gillyweed would be so nice to have...

 

[DtJ Jungle]

As HP, he may have found certain items that can help him kill the Basilisk.

Hopefully, Yaya, you have something to combat the basilisk with, otherwise my advice to you would be to turn back.

As for your list of suspicions, Superstar, Karthik just doesn't play in any game he signs up for. That's why he's under the radar. The other three have been fairly quiet, but I know from experience that Marshy and Macman only talk up when they have something relevant to say.

 

[Tom]

That gillyweed would be so nice to have...

back off its mine :3

 

[karthik_king]

Tom Cat is town I have investigated him

 

[Yaya]

.......

.......

.......

 

[karthik_king]

Oh right I am rita skeeter

 

[DtJ Jungle]

...What? We've had two cops all ready. For some reason I just don't see there being a third. Then again, i don't really know the likelyhood of that. Plus, you haven't been playing at all, you've given us no tells that you even has this power. For some reason, I highly doubt that you have this role, just like I doubt mentos was actually crucio'd.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Ok I got ninja'd by your name claim....So I guess forget the post ^^

 

[Tom]

hahahahahahahaha

oh my goodness

Karthik_king, you need to claim what harry potter character you are.

 

[Tom]

oh, okay.

heh. rita skeeter.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Also to compound on my bigger post, If you've been paying attention, even though Omis showed up a naive doctor, he was still investigated. I find it weird you chose to investigate him again. Especially after the name claim.

 

[Tom]

KK, do you have any other investigations from N0 or N1?

Also, two cops are dead, one was naive and one was regular. This makes me think that if there were a third it would be paranoid, but apparently not because I flipped town for KK. Very confusing :S

 

[#HBC | Mac]

KK, am I town?

 

[karthik_king]

Oh in the gryffindor dorm i found a mirror shard. No idea what its for

 

[#HBC | Mac]

yo, why the hell wud yu investigate tom if he had already been investigated.

 

[karthik_king]

Night 0 i found niiro to be town. (useless now)

Night 1 I forgot to send in who i investigated

 

[karthik_king]

He was? I dont remember seeing that

 

[DtJ Jungle]

If he's an SK claiming to be a doc, isn't it easy to claim all these people now? I know he can't do anything about it, just saying.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Errr I meant cop *facepalm*