Halloween Party Mafia ~ Over! Who drowned bobbing for apples? Who won Best Costume?

[ranmaru]

Also, I don't find Gheeb scummy, just really dumb.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

If Gheb were to flip scum, who would you focus and why? Same for town flip.

If scum, EBR if he wasn't getting lynched, I'm thinking anyone who put Asdioh on the chopping block other than maybe sang is worth looking into, X1-12 and Sang.

Town flip I'd looks more at Ranmaru and Asdioh.

Acrostic you better post content and vote before the end of the day otherwise I'll reveal the flavour purely so you can get vigged.

Why reveal?

 

[ranmaru]

How does Gheb's possible town flip incriminate me, in your pov RR?

 

[Tandora]

well, okay.

It makes me mad that you are taking this as a reason to vote him. It's not a scumtell. I skimmed. I skim when I replace. It's so SO boring to read things that I'm not involved in.

I would think that it's more likely that a scum-aligned person would pretend to have read in order to get town cred.

There is a huge world of difference from "It's 30+ pages and I was only able to skim to jump into the game as quickly as possible" and "I haven't read and I'm not gonna". Gheb firmly fell into the second category with his opening statement.

Honestly, if a "bad" player had replaced in and made the same exact statements, they would have died that very day.

 

[Tandora]

Also, my body is ready.

VOTE EBR

HAMMER!

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Swiss, ilu. Go win this game for me.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Votecount 3-7

8/15 to lynch.

EBR! [8]: Swiss, Asdioh, Red Ryu, Gova, July, asianaussie, Vult Redux, Tandora
Asdioh [4]: X1-12, Ranmaru, SangfroidWarrior, EBR!
Swiss [1]: Shadow Moth
Ranmaru [1]: Gheb


Not voting: Acrostic

------------------------------------------------------------

[collapse=Vote Log] Swiss > EBR! > Asdioh > EBR!
X1-12 > Asdioh
Gova > EBR!
Acrostic
Gheb > Swiss > Ranmaru
Red Ryu > EBR!
July > EBR! > EBR!
EBR! > Asdioh
Vult Redux > EBR!
Ranmaru > Asdioh
Asdioh > asianaussie > EBR!
asianaussie > EBR!
Shadow Moth > Swiss
SangfroidWarrior > Asdioh
Tandora > Gheb > EBR!
[/collapse]

A lynch has been reached!
It is now Twilight for 24 hours, or until any necessary Twilight actions have been received.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Night 3!

Shouted, strained arguments fly back and forth, filling the ceilings of the massive library. Many people are eager to get the death of someone whom they feel slipped away yesterday.

Finally, the crowd settles on EBR. He struggles, but a punch bowl cracked across the back of his head sets him to rest. He crumples, and collapses to the ground, dead.

Erupting Burning RYKERRR!!! was dressed as Dr. John Watson, as seen in The Hound of the Baskervilles (2002), and was mafia.​

But what's this? Soon after he falls, his body disintegrates into a pile of dust!! What's going on? You feel a sense of dread.


A player's alignment has shifted.
Night 3 starts now and lasts 48 hours.
Send in those theme guesses and Night actions!

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

JTB has replaced Acrostic!

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Day 4!

Owls in the forest announce the rising of the sun, as the library crew mourns its newest loss.

Swiss was dressed as Kazran Sardick, as seen in A Christmas Carol (2010), an episode of Doctor Who, and was town.​

You wonder if Christmas will ever be cheerful again. Although first, you'll have to make it through Halloween.


Day 4 begins! Deadline is September 17th at 1500 EST.

With 13 players remaining, it's 7 votes to lynch.

 

[Asdioh]

god dammit predictable jadfjgoidfjgoiadf

LJKFGDAJSGOIASJOIFGJ NOW I NEED TO ACTUALLY DO WORK THANKS A LOT ASDIFJGADOGI

 

[JTB]

I've read like the first 5 pages and the last page.

X1, why were you threatening to reveal the flavor just to get me vigged? I know Acrostic was inactive, but is it really worth giving away the flavor to scum?

 

[JTB]

Also, if someone can bring up why X1 didn't want to vote EBR, it would be helpful to have as a reference.

 

[July]

@Shadow Moth: Who are your scum picks now?

Vote: Gheb

Gheb, respond to my #1344. Everyone else, read it as well and if you don't agree with the fact that Gheb was bull****ting all D2 and D3 about his read on EBR then tell me why.

Also, this is Ryker's #992:

And in case of shenanigans, I'm Aunt Sponge from James and the Giant Peach.

Which isn't what his costume flipped, so scum does have safe claims for their costumes.

@Asdioh: Updated read on X1?

 

[Asdioh]

I've read like the first 5 pages and the last page.

townbros. maybe.

Also, if someone can bring up why X1 didn't want to vote EBR, it would be helpful to have as a reference.

Because he's scum

Vote: X1

I find it hard to believe he's town after stopping EBR's lynch Day 2, almost doing the same yesterDay, and tunneling me ('cause i'm town)

unvote

because I'll have to look for more evidence, but you know who my current scumpick is off the top of my head.

I was going to ask Swiss why asianaussie is town, but scum kind of killed him. v_v

 

[X1-12]

Now what is really unusual is that Sworddancer's character doesn't fit the original theme at all whereas Ryker's does, as did his fake costume claim

JTB is was just scaring him. He replaced out and his replacement is going read up (right????) so I'd call it an improvement

I didn't want to vote EBR because Asdioh is so ridiculously scummy and has done nothing the entire game after replacing in, which is why we should all vote him. I challenge anyone to find some analysis by him with any level of depth in, rather than just regurgitation and commenting on things without explanation

We actually ARE lynching Asdioh toDay no **** and no messing about. We might be lynching Gheb tomorrow.

 

[JTB]

Swords character fits the theme of the game if you see what Nabe did. More importantly, why did you need to bring it up?

 

[X1-12]

I challenge anyone to find some analysis by him with any level of depth in, rather than just regurgitation and commenting on things without explanation

SERIOUSLY GUYS I CHALLENGE YOU

/caps

 

[JTB]

Actually, I like this.

Vote: X1

 

[Asdioh]

I am conflicted. Does he actually think I'm scum, and would he tunnel me so hard as town?
Or is he scum, still trying to push my ML? I thought X1 would know townAsdioh better than this. Do you legitimately think I am more useless than the inactive/nonexistant playerslots? And that I'm actually scummy, wtf? I miss Swiss. I made the right choice in trusting and following him yesterDay, and of course he went and got killed.


In the meantime, can anyone give me (and JTB) a full list of who has claimed so far, and what they've claimed? I also remember someone believing certain players were town mostly because of their claims, which makes no sense to me. I mean, I'm dressed up as a character from Sleepy Hollow that I'm pretty sure is a villain, but I'm town. Because they're just costumes.

 

[July]

@X1: I agree with you that Asdioh has not done anything, but Gheb is a scummy ******* and his shenanigans with the EBR wagon ever since replacing in are tremendously scummy and his flip from the EBR wagon to Acrostic was completely unfounded.

Gheb is the lynch toDay, Asdioh toMorrow.

 

[X1-12]

I didn't stop EBR's lynch at all. At D2 deadline I was completely pro-EBR lynch, and even spent a large amount of D3 attacking Gheb for acting against the EBR lynch. Saying otherwise is completely untrue

 

[X1-12]

I am conflicted. Does he actually think I'm scum, and would he tunnel me so hard as town? Or is he scum, still trying to push my ML? I thought X1 would know townAsdioh better than this. Do you legitimately think I am more useless than the inactive/nonexistant playerslots? And that I'm actually scummy, wtf? I miss Swiss. I made the right choice in trusting and following him yesterDay, and of course he went and got killed.

This isn't a defence? You haven't done anything useful, if you believe you have then show me, accept my challenge. Your post here isn't a defence just meta(bolded) and deflecting towards the inactives (italics) Its not a question of who's more useful, they are useless yes, but their inactivity is not indicative of alignment. You on the other hand are hear and are posting, yet what you post is useless and shows not even an attempt at analysis. This is scummy

 

[JTB]

Don't just ignore my 1377 yo.

 

[X1-12]

@Asdioh where have you read up to?

Also the fact Ryker appeared to be a Day Yakuza (and could use his powers) "A player's alignment has shifted" suggests that the scumteam have figured out the flavour. What do people think about just revealing it now then?

@JTB: I assume you refer to the picture? Well the flip as written by mod doesn't fit so I had no reason to assume the costume flip would be incorrect. I have not seen Alice in Wonderland 2010

 

[th3kuzinator]

=)

go scum

 

[JTB]

I'm asking why did you need to bring up the comparison between Swords flip and EBR's flip?

 

[X1-12]

It was something I couldn't understand so I felt it was worth bringing it to the table

 

[JTB]

Bull****. Literally all it does is paint you as a nk target for knowing the flavor and provoking others who know the flavor into answering you.

 

[X1-12]

And what? I'm assuming Sword wasn't actually dressed as Alice Kinsleigh.. Like I said, nothing was lost from bringing this to the table and I gained some information. Its not gonna suddenly help scum find out the flavour because if they don't already know (I assume they do as mentioned previously) one more flip isn't going to help them, all the info needed to figure it out is already out there

I also claimed I knew the flavour on D2 JFYI


Are you actually gonna talk about why you think I'm scummy? Because your voting me for no reason and attacking me for things without going so far as to explain what is scummy about them

 

[July]

@Asdioh where have you read up to?

Also the fact Ryker appeared to be a Day Yakuza (and could use his powers) "A player's alignment has shifted" suggests that the scumteam have figured out the flavour. What do people think about just revealing it now then?

@JTB: I assume you refer to the picture? Well the flip as written by mod doesn't fit so I had no reason to assume the costume flip would be incorrect. I have not seen Alice in Wonderland 2010

No, I don't agree to this. Even if EBR figured it out, it doesn't make sense to assume the entire scum team has figured it out. In fact some of EBR's and J's interactions on D2 make me think that scum might not have figured it out or had private communication at the time:

J, splitting an alternative wagon will get me killed faster than leaving your vote there. This bothers me. Do you honestly think that you can push an RR wagon through in the time we have, because I think I can punch an Acrostic lynch in there.

If the wagon is there, will you vote Acrostic over me at crunch time?

This interaction looks like one scum buddy guiding another scum buddy to find the best way to avoid one's lynch, but if they are both scum which I think is highly likely why not do that through private communication? Furthermore, EBR stated his guesses in thread at one point, which could have been his way of trying to direct his scum buddies away from wrong guesses.

tl;dr we have no reason to believe that all of scum is aware of the theme, we have scum picks and good leads to go off of with the EBR flip so don't reveal the flavor now.

 

[X1-12]

Also, if someone can bring up why X1 didn't want to vote EBR, it would be helpful to have as a reference.

You claim to only have read the first 5 pages and the most recent page (from this post that would mean page #35 (40ppp) - What made you think that I didn't want to vote EBR? Where did you get this information?????? There is nothing on any of the pages you claim to have read which suggests this.

 

[Swiss]

The figure watched the lynch with satisfaction. His vengeance was pure, his will resolute. The day done he retreated to his chamber to think on these revelations. He would be needed this next day.

Locking the door behind him, immediately he sensed something awry. He was not alone, a presence behind him.

A gloved hand crushing his throat. A glint of silver and a grin of malice as the blade slid under his ribs, grating on bone and biting flesh. Blood pouring onto the old, oaken floor.

The figure stumbled, falling forwards, reaching out for help - finding nothing but laughter. Mind clouding and knees weakening, only one thought echoed through his head.

He was the help.


And so ended the tale of the figure; the jester of darkness, the witchdoctor of your soul.

 

[JTB]

It's really not hard at all to look on the last page and see you voting Asdioh instead of EBR. Because of that, there was some reason why you weren't voting EBR and that's what I'm asking for.

 

[Asdioh]

You claim to only have read the first 5 pages and the most recent page (from this post that would mean page #35 (40ppp) - What made you think that I didn't want to vote EBR? Where did you get this information?????? There is nothing on any of the pages you claim to have read which suggests this.

I assume he means page #34. Look there:

X1, why is Asdioh a priority to you before EBR?

8/15 to lynch.

EBR! [8]: Swiss, Asdioh, Red Ryu, Gova, July, asianaussie, Vult Redux, Tandora
Asdioh [4]: X1-12, Ranmaru, SangfroidWarrior, EBR!
Swiss [1]: Shadow Moth
Ranmaru [1]: Gheb


Not voting: Acrostic

There you go.

Now what is really unusual is that Sworddancer's character doesn't fit the original theme at all whereas Ryker's does, as did his fake costume claim

Even with this hint, there's still no way I'm going to be able to guess the flavor, lol.
Hint: it's not Halloween Party Mafia, nor is it
British
Mafia

which doesn't make sense with some of the flips I assume, but the fact that X1 supposedly got it correct partially biased my guess

Swords character fits the theme of the game if you see what Nabe did. More importantly, why did you need to bring it up?

oh, but then disagreement. \(o_o)/

I didn't stop EBR's lynch at all. At D2 deadline I was completely pro-EBR lynch, and even spent a large amount of D3 attacking Gheb for acting against the EBR lynch. Saying otherwise is completely untrue

Oh. That's just what I thought someone said. That's what I get for not reading the thread I guess :3

@Asdioh where have you read up to?

I just read random crap.

Also the fact Ryker appeared to be a Day Yakuza (and could use his powers) "A player's alignment has shifted" suggests that the scumteam have figured out the flavour. What do people think about just revealing it now then?

Don't the rules say that scum can't communicate unless at least two of them figure out the flavor, or something to that effect? Even if EBR figured it out, it doesn't mean that he could communicate it to anyone else, except by crumbs.

 

[X1-12]

July don't you think Ryker would have claimed it during Twilight then?

Asdioh regardless of whether you have read the bit before you replaced in, since then stuff has happened and you haven't even tried to analyse scum motivation in the posts which you have responded to

JTB you specifically said you thought I didn't "want" to vote EBR, not merely that I wasn't on his wagon at Day end. From looking at the votecount how can you assume this? I would gladly have voted EBR at deadline. but he was hammered when I arrived?

 

[JTB]

Then the better question is why were you voting Asdioh over him?

 

[Asdioh]

July don't you think Ryker would have claimed it during Twilight then?

Not directed at me, but it all depends on him. If it's claimed in-thread, then EVERYONE will know it. It's up to whoever knows it to decide if it's worth revealing it to everyone. I assume the game will be balanced if everyone knows, but until then, whichever team has more people that guessed it, will have the PR advantage.

Asdioh regardless of whether you have read the bit before you replaced in, since then stuff has happened and you haven't even tried to analyse scum motivation in the posts which you have responded to

I'm being lazy. Is that a scumtell?

At least I'm trying harder than I did in Kingmaker >_>


How's this:

No, I don't agree to this. Even if EBR figured it out, it doesn't make sense to assume the entire scum team has figured it out. In fact some of EBR's and J's interactions on D2 make me think that scum might not have figured it out or had private communication at the time:



This interaction looks like one scum buddy guiding another scum buddy to find the best way to avoid one's lynch, but if they are both scum which I think is highly likely why not do that through private communication? Furthermore, EBR stated his guesses in thread at one point, which could have been his way of trying to direct his scum buddies away from wrong guesses.

tl;dr we have no reason to believe that all of scum is aware of the theme, we have scum picks and good leads to go off of with the EBR flip so don't reveal the flavor now.

July is reaching so hard to push J/me as scum that she just HAS to be town.

 

[X1-12]

JTB you must be trolling. Read the thread, everything J did was underhand and manipulative and everything Asdioh did is.... nothing, just commenting without analysis or substantiated reads

@Asdioh: You're too lazy to actually try to scumhunt but not too lazy to post regularly with sideshow commentary??

 

[JTB]

How am I trolling? I told you I haven't read the entire game yet, so I have no idea what each player has done.

Can you link me to your initial case on J/Asdioh?