On Kat...actually, there really isn't much. The big thing was his "shopped log" comment. More intuition than anything else. Fortunately, I have someone else in mind now anyway. Go ahead and consider every instance of "Kat" in my #86 to be "Marc".
Marc said:
Until your more recent posts you {Cello} seemed calmer and less random, that's all there is to it.
Really now? So...
Cello said:
I don't know how to approach this group of players, so I'm not going to take any hard stances, constantly ignore questions from Summoner, back off from all confrontations and generally be a quiet player. Oh, and completely ignore my scummate.
Cello said:
Starshy, are you trying to get me to vote for you? Hmm, should I? No. I should say that I think Starshy is the most innocent person here.
Cello said:
I don't get a bad vibe from Tanny. We shouldn't lynch her. Tanny...maybe we should lynch you. Lynch you dead. After all, your questions aren't really going anywhere. Although we shouldn't lynch you. We should lynch Starshy. That will be a good start. Unless Steel fixes the problem I have with them.
...is calm and less random? If you really believed that, then you must have realized I thought Marshy was scum. Why didn't you say something back then? Beyond KEEKEE's and my initial exchange, what more could you possibly have learned?
Cello said:
Any decent partner would tell you that {you need to change your style}, but I don't think you're so bad that you'd need a partner to tell you what to do.
Obviously, I'm not Handorin's or your partner. Neither Summoner nor Tandora would have asked me to change (Summoner's Nothing Special mafia log and Tandora's personality show that). Kevin wouldn't tell me what to do or how to play (I've asked, before). KEEKEE wouldn't/doesn't know about Nothing Special, as the flow of our conversation would not have gone to how "random" I was in my last game. That leaves Kat and Marshy. Tell me that you think one of them is my partner, and why. You want to vote for me, after all, and there's no way in hell that it's pressure-based.
Also, your response to Marshy in #85 seems really firm. Like it was a quick and solid response. Saying you'd lynch me. Then it's all squishy and soft and just likely in #91. Also, why'd you say "
![Confused :confused: :confused:]()
Calm the **** down." when KEEKEE just told you to stop double-talking? It was really disconcerting. Also, "just making conversation to appear active?" Saying that I don't believe someone exists is quite a bit of a stretch of something someone would say to just "appear" active.
@KEEKEE:
Starshy would have had no need to post a fake log.
Marshy, on the other hand, needed to forge a log because he's in this game, alone, masquerading as Starshy without Steel, or was at least, until post #98.
"This game" just doesn't seem right to me. If I were typing that, I would have said "that game" or "the game" or even "Grammys". Also, I don't need to know the in-depth parts of someone's personality to think they would respond if someone was claiming they didn't exist.
whyd you specifically mention ee/kiki? for the record you/hando/kevin are the only ones whove seen me as scum i think.
I had/have no way to know that. They were the unknowns for you as far as I knew.
and i had no reason to fake the log...
"...so why did you?" is my point. But if no one believes that is the case, then it's fruitless.
@Summoner: You're grating on my last nerve. If lynching you would affect my opinions in the slightest, I'd have jumped on you in an instant.