Alright, so I'm new to this particular thread, and I just wanna ask the following:
What do you think of the idea of introducing Black Shadow as a character that took over Ganondorf's role as a Capt. Falcon clone and making Ganondorf unique?
I come from the Project M forums, where the idea is, to my absolute complete surprise, controversial.
See, Mewtwo and Roy are in Project M because the PMBR (Project M Backroom) found a way to access the "Forbidden 7" character files to create 7 extra characters. Roy and Mewtwo take up two of the "slots" so there's room for 5 more characters. If you already know this, then sorry for being redundant.
Anyway there's a thread for discussing possible candidates for the slots (any additional characters have to have appeared in Brawl as a trophy or sticker, btw), and one of the first presented ideas was the Black Shadow / Ganondorf idea. Essentially, the new, revamped, not-a-clone Ganondorf would use a slot while the original Ganondorf would be reskinned and slightly reanimated to look like Black Shadow. Apparently, while a lot of people expressed fondness for the idea, there was also a sizeable, very loud group of people who wanted Ganondorf to stay the same. Some provide a few good reasons:
1) why redo a character we already have in Smash but not other clones?
2) maybe the very few slots should go to other characters instead (Isaac, Ridley, Dark Samus, etc.)
3) some people say Black Shadow isn't the ideal F-Zero rep after Capt. Falcon, sahing that Samurai Goroh better deserves it.
These are good reasons to live with Ganondorf sticking as a clone even with the opportunity to change that is present. However, there are a few reasons people give that are extremely base-breaking and borderline mean-spirited:
1) Black Shadow is "really stupid-looking," having to play him to keep playing the Capt. Falcon clone is going to feel "f*cking ********."
2) Ganondorf shouldn't be changed because "surprisingly, this is a game for Smash fans, not Zelda fans, so they should just deal with it."
And, my favorite,
3) Ganondorf as a clone of Capt. Falcon is actually "perfect sense" because he has the Triforce of Power, therefore being a physical fighter is completely fitting and revamping him is wrong.
I could counterargue all 3 of those for days, but the problem that flame wars come up in the Clone Engine Character thread every single time the idea is mentioned persists, so it's no use.
What I came here for, and the purpose of this post, is to ask if Smash 4 forumgoers feel different, or the same way. Thoughts?