Official DLC Speculation Discussion Volume II

[ARandomFruit]

This might be a hot take but I find Bandana Dee to be a potentially interesting character if they got in.
You could add the elemental stuff from Star Allies and the parasol and the beam ability. That might not be enough for some people but it's cool to me.
It's also just hard to not like the idea of beating the stuffing out of characters like Sephiroth and Bowser as a little bean with a umbrella.

 

[ArkSPiTFirE]

I think my least wanted is a toss up between Pokémon and an RPG character that isn't Isaac.

I have nothing against Pokémon other than it has stupid amounts of representation already, and it's just the most obvious choice for Nintendo to make. I haven't played Gen 8, so I have no attachment to any of them. That's not to say other people don't, but can we just...wait til the next one? Thanks.

Then RPG character is kinda funny. I like RPGs, but that doesn't mean I want every RPG character under the sun. I've already got Hero, Cloud and Sephiroth, the only one missing for me is Isaac; that's a personal connection that needs to be realised for me. 18 years of "That would be such a cool moveset to have in Smash." The spotlight on Golden Sun is a bonus at this point.

But screw all you other McJRPGs. I don't want you getting in over Isaac, that sucks. Hero is fine, he's the Grandad of traditional JRPGs and I love him to death. Sephiroth was low key my most wanted Squeenix after Cloud, he's a big deal. Pythra I didn't like, that actually caused me to lose the most hope as I thought the RPG picks were all gone now for Fighters Pass 2. Lloyd from Symphonia, I actually do like! But I knew that if he got in before Isaac I would be so let down, even though I do want him to get there eventually (Isaacbros and Lloydbros for life).

So I'm looking at you, Dragalia Lost, Atelier, PSO, Ys, and SMT. Begone.

 

[GilTheGreat19]

Ok but like
We might really be in the endgame now

Also happy Sunday everybody : )

 

[Wunderwaft]

Ok but like
We might really be in the endgame now

Also happy Sunday everybody : )

If you wanna be more precise, things might end in 3 days

....Wow now that I think about it we spent a long time speculating this game, three and a half years have gone by since Smash for Switch was announced. I'm gonna miss speculation once the final character is revealed, it's gonna be the end of an era.

 

[Evil Trapezium]

Ok but like
We might really be in the endgame now

When Nintendo decides to delay the reveal of Challenger Pack 11 to December.

 

[Guybrush20X6]

You know after Pass one had a lot of stuff leaked and Pass 2 opened with the whole ARMS roster tease (of which realistically it could only have been four of them max), it's been oddly refreshing to have most of Pass 2 be complete and utter unknowns. After Min Min I could have guessed there'd be a Xenoblade 2 rep but besides from that, it was all surprises that make sense in hindsight.

Steve/Alex/Zombie/Enderman, Sephiroth, Kazuya all brought in stuff that Smash felt like it was missing but we were too wrapped up in other stuff to see.

 

[GilTheGreat19]

When Nintendo decides to delay the reveal of Challenger Pack 11 to December.

Ok guys,
See y’all at TGA

 

[MasterCheef]

I hope so but probably not. Next Monday or Tuesday is likely though.

why do you think so?

The only Smash OC I accept is Master Hand tbh, but that one is one of the best choices for a character period.

Why not Tabuu?

 

[WeirdChillFever]

why do you think so?



Why not Tabuu?

I think Master Hand is a better fit considering he’s in all Smash games and is basically the mascot. Tabuu leans more towards generic boss, however fun his power set is.

 

[The Rhythm Theif]

Why not Tabuu?

Two words for you: GOLDEN BRACKETS.

 

[Guybrush20X6]

Tabuu's a case where his moveset would be easier to figure out but Master Hand simply a much more iconic character.

My pick for an OC character would be Sandbag personally but that's just me.

 

[GilTheGreat19]

Tabuu as a playable fighter would be cool
But hear me out:

WoL expansion pack: Tabuu comes back and is the main baddy

 

[Dinoman96]

I just find the idea of a playable "Smash OC" pointless when that's pretty much what the Mii Fighters are.

Like yes, they're Miis, but their movesets are entirely original (as opposed to taking stuff from Wii Sports/Wii Play/etc), their logo is the Smash emblem, and their victory themes are even renditions of the Smash 4 theme and Lifelight in Ultimate. They were clearly designed as a way for people to insert their OCs into the game.

 

[Gengar84]

If they were to add a Sony character to this game who would you pick?

My top 2 are Kratos and Nathan Drake just because I feel like Kratos is a natural pick and I love the Uncharted games.

I’m going to be the only person to ever say this but Zegram Ghart from Rogue Galaxy is not only my most wanted Sony rep but my most wanted overall. It’s a shame that he’s about as close to 0% as possible.

 

[Guybrush20X6]

I just find the idea of a playable "Smash OC" pointless when that's pretty much what the Mii Fighters are.

Like yes, they're Miis, but their movesets are entirely original (as opposed to taking stuff from Wii Sports/Wii Play/etc), their logo is the Smash emblem, and their victory themes are even renditions of the Smash 4 theme and Lifelight in Ultimate. They were clearly designed as a way for people to insert their OCs into the game.

Oh, that'd be perfect for the final update, porting over the Switch version of Miitopia's makeup system.

 

[MattX20]

I'm actually more interested in who people do NOT want/ Worst ideas they have heard.

Some of mine:

• All four champions as one character. In addition to this having nothing to do with them in game (they aren't linked in any way as fighters), if they were going to do this- Sakurai might as well go ahead and make four separate characters.
• Another Pokemon Trainer. "Let's just go ahead and steal the one thing that makes another character specifically unique! But this time, let's do it in a less iconic way!"
• Undertale: it just bothers me. I don't see why this is the game that would get a character, if we breeched this topic. We have also already gotten to 2 culturally relevant things from it- Sans and Megalomania. It's fine to want an Undertale character, but it seems foolish of me when people think of it as a prediction.
• Porky/ Anymore Earthbound. Again- find to want in my eyes (not all on this list are, to me), but thinking it is needed or DESERVED... alright. Let's be happy this small, dead series (as great as it is) got as much representation as it has. We have every Nintendo-made RPG series in Smash already (short of Fossil Fighter, a sleeper series), except GOLDEN SUN. C'mon!
• Chun Li. She may be on my list, too...perhaps 100 characters down... but if we are going for female gamechangers in video games- there are better options. If we are going for Video Game icons, let's go to a new series.
• EMMI/ Metroid Dread or Prime character. It's so amazing that Metroid got buffed involvement in this new game! How about spreading that love to other series, particularly ones that have been even more monetarily profitable and culturally impactful? Donkey Kong is here...

Characters I don't want? Well, my most hated character was Heihachi and he was deconfirmed hard with the Mii Costume so that's a plus. As for other characters like a Fortnite rep, Nabohino or Demifiend, and promotional picks from Nintendo like a BOTW rep or Gen 8 Pokemon, I don't think they're happening because of the development timeline for Ultimate and that all the DLC characters were picked by the end of 2018 and negotiations concluded the following year. That, and Nintendo already had 1/3 or roughly 1/2 of the pass with Pyra and Mythra, so a lower key 3rd party pick would be more plausible at this point

 

[The Rhythm Theif]

Oh, that'd be perfect for the final update, porting over the Switch version of Miitopia's makeup system.

If Nintendo's next system includes a Mii Maker, they better give us an option of which music we want to use for it. Between the Wii...

...the 3DS...

...or the Wii U music (my personal favorite).

Ok but like
We might really be in the endgame now

Yeah... if the final character gets revealed soon, it might be game over for this speculation page.

 

[Guybrush20X6]

If they were to add a Sony character to this game who would you pick?

My top 2 are Kratos and Nathan Drake just because I feel like Kratos is a natural pick and I love the Uncharted games.

Ratchet and Clank or Kat from Gravity Rush.

There's a lot of fun to be had with R&C's varied weapon arsenals and Kat is a precious bean who need to be brought back into the limelight.

 

[Mamboo07]

If they were to add a Sony character to this game who would you pick?

My top 2 are Kratos and Nathan Drake just because I feel like Kratos is a natural pick and I love the Uncharted games.

Sackboy

 

[CureParfait]

I'm actually more interested in who people do NOT want/ Worst ideas they have heard.

Doomguy- I didn't care about him at first but the Caccomallow leak is real thing kinda soured my view.
Geno- Same reason as above.
Any Mortal Kombat character- Mainly out of not really interested in MK series as a whole.

 

[Rie Sonomura]

I'm actually more interested in who people do NOT want/ Worst ideas they have heard.

Some of mine:

• All four champions as one character. In addition to this having nothing to do with them in game (they aren't linked in any way as fighters), if they were going to do this- Sakurai might as well go ahead and make four separate characters.
• Another Pokemon Trainer. "Let's just go ahead and steal the one thing that makes another character specifically unique! But this time, let's do it in a less iconic way!"
• Undertale: it just bothers me. I don't see why this is the game that would get a character, if we breeched this topic. We have also already gotten to 2 culturally relevant things from it- Sans and Megalomania. It's fine to want an Undertale character, but it seems foolish of me when people think of it as a prediction.
• Porky/ Anymore Earthbound. Again- find to want in my eyes (not all on this list are, to me), but thinking it is needed or DESERVED... alright. Let's be happy this small, dead series (as great as it is) got as much representation as it has. We have every Nintendo-made RPG series in Smash already (short of Fossil Fighter, a sleeper series), except GOLDEN SUN. C'mon!
• Chun Li. She may be on my list, too...perhaps 100 characters down... but if we are going for female gamechangers in video games- there are better options. If we are going for Video Game icons, let's go to a new series.
• EMMI/ Metroid Dread or Prime character. It's so amazing that Metroid got buffed involvement in this new game! How about spreading that love to other series, particularly ones that have been even more monetarily profitable and culturally impactful? Donkey Kong is here...

• Ryu Hayabusa. Some people have soured him for me, including a former friend
• Nahobino. Same as above but without the former friend angle
• Jonesy. I’m not big on Fortnite, simple as
• Bubsy. Not that I think he’ll happen anyway
• Mortal Kombat character, I just don’t think they’ll fit. Extreme violence is their whole character
• An Overwatch/Diablo/Warcraft rep in particular as they’re associated with the more problematic half of Activision Blizzard and given their current state… yeah. Crash I can forgive somewhat as he’s more Activision

 

[Dinoman96]

Ratchet & Clank and Kratos are probably the longest and enduring Playstation mascots, so them.

 

[The Rhythm Theif]

I'm actually more interested in who people do NOT want/ Worst ideas they have heard.

Some of mine:

• All four champions as one character. In addition to this having nothing to do with them in game (they aren't linked in any way as fighters), if they were going to do this- Sakurai might as well go ahead and make four separate characters.
• Another Pokemon Trainer. "Let's just go ahead and steal the one thing that makes another character specifically unique! But this time, let's do it in a less iconic way!"
• Undertale: it just bothers me. I don't see why this is the game that would get a character, if we breeched this topic. We have also already gotten to 2 culturally relevant things from it- Sans and Megalomania. It's fine to want an Undertale character, but it seems foolish of me when people think of it as a prediction.
• Porky/ Anymore Earthbound. Again- find to want in my eyes (not all on this list are, to me), but thinking it is needed or DESERVED... alright. Let's be happy this small, dead series (as great as it is) got as much representation as it has. We have every Nintendo-made RPG series in Smash already (short of Fossil Fighter, a sleeper series), except GOLDEN SUN. C'mon!
• Chun Li. She may be on my list, too...perhaps 100 characters down... but if we are going for female gamechangers in video games- there are better options. If we are going for Video Game icons, let's go to a new series.
• EMMI/ Metroid Dread or Prime character. It's so amazing that Metroid got buffed involvement in this new game! How about spreading that love to other series, particularly ones that have been even more monetarily profitable and culturally impactful? Donkey Kong is here...

Doomguy- I didn't care about him at first but the Caccomallow leak is real thing kinda soured my view.
Geno- Same reason as above.
Any Mortal Kombat character- Mainly out of not really interested in MK series as a whole.

• Jonesy. I’m not big on Fortnite, simple as
• Bubsy. Not that I think he’ll happen anyway

What CureParfait & Rie said, but also including Tails, Eggman, any Gen 8 Pokemon, or any Monster Hunter related character/monster. Especially the latter considering how much Capcom has milked Monster Hunter to death at this point.

 

[Trevenant]

I don't think they're happening because of the development timeline for Ultimate and that all the DLC characters were picked by the end of 2018 and negotiations concluded the following year. That, and Nintendo already had 1/3 or roughly 1/2 of the pass with Pyra and Mythra, so a lower key 3rd party pick would be more plausible at this point

All the DLC characters being picked in 2018... I thought there were rumors spread by Imran Kahn that a second pass was never even finalized until mid-2019. And even if you want to say Sakurai initially said 1-2 bonus characters were the original idea, we still have 4 more characters beyond that. The Byleth showcase also pretty much said that the characters for pass 2 were finalized pretty close to when that aired in November, so the pass 2 roster very likely weren't finalized in 2018. That and a gen 8 pokemon does line up with pass 2's finalization with this in mind as they've historically gotten concept art for pokemon characters to select from before they even star in a game so.. Not that I want one, but this idea isn't really true when you factor in what we know and seems more like arbitrary roadblocking for blatant shills tbh, even if it only puts one of them back in the running, other evidence not withstanding.

 

[Michael the Spikester]

Incoming last minute leak to ruin the surprise and throw us into a hectic argument up until the reveal.

In b4 we don't get a direct or CP11 for that matter this week.

 

[Adrianette Bromide]

In b4 we don't get a direct or CP11 for that matter this week.

I mean late September would be a change of pace but I wouldn't be surprised. Still in September though.

 

[Momotsuki]

Have Master Hand be stamina-based no matter the type of match it is for everyone else. Scale him down just a tad, give him two jumps, and make him extremely floaty. Have him usually not flinch to anything - but at damage intervals, crashing to the ground (thus getting screwed over if it happens while he's offstage) and laying there for about one second flat.

 

[LiveStudioAudience]

Some sort of asymmetrical Smash mode with the likes of playable Master Hand, Crazy Hand, and some of the various bosses would be pretty cool. No replacement for having them as actual fighters, but it'd be something.

 

[Guybrush20X6]

I'm actually more interested in who people do NOT want/ Worst ideas they have heard.

Well mine are

• Freddy Fazbear and other FNaF related stuff: Not a fan of the series and have no interest in a Smash trailer with jumpscares.
• DOTA/LOL characters: I am a bit interested to see how they could translate over but I am not a fan of MOBAs as they communities make the game toxic to play (Like getting kick for wanting to play a non-meta hero)
• Fortnite: I am not a fan on the thing that Epic has become ever since this game got big. Must say, it'll be something to see how they can do a Fortnite moveset without guns and without stepping on Steve's non-existent toes.
• Chorus Kids: I want a Rhythm Heaven character but I have no idea how these creepy things got so far ahead in Smash speculation when there's many more RH characters that represent the series better.

 

[Sucumbio]

Master Hand would be cool. Iirc wasn't he supposed to be the boy's hand playing with the original cast in his bedroom or something?

 

[chocolatejr9]

I'm actually more interested in who people do NOT want/ Worst ideas they have heard.

Some of mine:

• All four champions as one character. In addition to this having nothing to do with them in game (they aren't linked in any way as fighters), if they were going to do this- Sakurai might as well go ahead and make four separate characters.
• Another Pokemon Trainer. "Let's just go ahead and steal the one thing that makes another character specifically unique! But this time, let's do it in a less iconic way!"
• Undertale: it just bothers me. I don't see why this is the game that would get a character, if we breeched this topic. We have also already gotten to 2 culturally relevant things from it- Sans and Megalomania. It's fine to want an Undertale character, but it seems foolish of me when people think of it as a prediction.
• Porky/ Anymore Earthbound. Again- find to want in my eyes (not all on this list are, to me), but thinking it is needed or DESERVED... alright. Let's be happy this small, dead series (as great as it is) got as much representation as it has. We have every Nintendo-made RPG series in Smash already (short of Fossil Fighter, a sleeper series), except GOLDEN SUN. C'mon!
• Chun Li. She may be on my list, too...perhaps 100 characters down... but if we are going for female gamechangers in video games- there are better options. If we are going for Video Game icons, let's go to a new series.
• EMMI/ Metroid Dread or Prime character. It's so amazing that Metroid got buffed involvement in this new game! How about spreading that love to other series, particularly ones that have been even more monetarily profitable and culturally impactful? Donkey Kong is here...

Waluigi, Overwatch, The Last of Us... that's about it, really.

 

[MBRedboy31]

Have Master Hand be stamina-based no matter the type of match it is for everyone else. Scale him down just a tad, give him two jumps, and make him extremely floaty. Have him usually not flinch to anything - but at damage intervals, crashing to the ground (thus getting screwed over if it happens while he's offstage) and laying there for about one second flat.

If we are to try to make Master Hand a fully balanced character, I think it’d be better if he is prone to flinching and limited knockback. Unless his stamina pool is absolutely puny, it means you can’t just throw out moves for free and armor through everything (remember that his frame data is way less reactable as a player) , it makes it so that your opponent can get more satisfying follow-ups, plus the knockdown state would be pretty frustrating on the player’s side.

 

[Theguy123]

We’ll know if we’re getting a character reveal on Tuesday night since they do the tournament events. If they skip the tournament event on Tuesday then we might genuinely have an idea that the reveal is this week. If we get the event then it’ll be safe to say no reveal surely.

 

[Super Devon]

We’ll know if we’re getting a character reveal on Tuesday night since they do the tournament events. If they skip the tournament event on Tuesday then we might genuinely have an idea that the reveal is this week. If we get the event then it’ll be safe to say no reveal surely.

I don't think that matters at all
we got the announcement for a tournament event the day before the February Direct, which is also the day before Pyra/Mytrha were revealed

There was a problem fetching the tweet

The same thing happened with Kazuya as well, albeit the day of the reveal.

 

[Guynamednelson]

I thought there were rumors spread by Imran Kahn that a second pass was never even finalized until mid-2019

Second Chance Theory if anything should've been a hint against this. Look at how every single character/franchise in FP2 is something Sakurai considered before 2018.

 

[The Rhythm Theif]

I don't think that matters at all
we got the announcement for a tournament event the day before the February Direct, which is also the day before Pyra/Mythra were revealed

There was a problem fetching the tweet

The same thing happened with Kazuya as well, albeit the day of the reveal.

(remembers that Pyra & Mythra were revealed on my birthday)

A big flex, I know... but one that was worth it.

 

[Trevenant]

Second Chance Theory if anything should've been a hint against this. Look at how every single character/franchise in FP2 is something Sakurai considered before 2018.

A hint at the DLC being finalized in 2018 or mid-2019? I think I've just completely confused myself by making the reply you quoted lol as I thought it was just common knowledge that nothing was finalized in 2018 aside from pass 1. Now that I think about it, suggesting that the second pass was finalized in 2018 whilst negotiations finished in 2019 is kind of absurd as they wouldn't have finalized anything until they got the rights to use a character from a third party, not that it was done here but the message I made beforehand kind of suggested that.

 

[Guynamednelson]

A hint at the DLC being finalized in 2018

This. If nothing in FP2 involves anything Sakurai first considered in 2018 onward, doesn't that seem a little suspicious?

 

[Þe 1 → Way]

So, is the generally accepted idea that we get the announcement on Tuesday and Direct on Thursday?

Its actually wild that we might be done soon.

 

[Theguy123]

I don't think that matters at all
we got the announcement for a tournament event the day before the February Direct, which is also the day before Pyra/Mytrha were revealed

There was a problem fetching the tweet

The same thing happened with Kazuya as well, albeit the day of the reveal.

Ohh right I didn’t realise that happened. I take it all back people then.