I'm not very familiar with some of the series the smash roster comes from but some I'd love see:As far as adding characters from existing series goes (either in this game or the next), here are who I think would be good picks:
- Super Mario: Waluigi would probably be the best to go with due to the outcry for him. Beyond that, it really doesn't matter. Just wait a game to add another regular enemy like the Goomba and you'll be fine.
- Donkey Kong: Dixie Kong (or Dixie Kong & Kiddy Kong if you wanted to revisit the duo/character swap idea) is pretty much the only good option left. There are still a few memey options that could be well received like Lanky or Kranky Kong, but the character pool is otherwise unexciting for now.
- The Legend of Zelda: Pretty much any character with a major role that isn't Link, Zelda, or Ganondorf. Impa, Girahim, The Skull Kid...even Ganon is acceptable, though maybe not the best case scenario. I'd personally add two characters if one of them is Ganon.
- Metroid: At the moment, the best candidate is the Metroids themselves, but depending on how other characters make a name for themselves in the coming games, that could easily change.
- Yoshi: It literally doesn't matter. Poochy, Kamek, both, none, take your pick.
- Pokémon: Nothing I say here matters because we all know the next character will be a Generation 9, 10, or perhaps even 11 starter. There are a ton of good and better candidates, but they're not getting in anytime soon unless they become like Mewtwo or something to "warrant" going back for them.
- Earthbound: Porky. It's just Porky. Not a necessity, just a fun idea.
- Later on down the line, pretty much any of the party members from Earthbound and Mother 3 could add a bit more variety to the cast, but they aren't entirely necessary either.
- F-Zero: Black Shadow and Samurai Goroh are pretty much the only two characters people are interested in at present.
- Blood Falcon would make a neat alternate costume if you made the final tweaks necessary. I suppose that would probably involve giving him blood effects instead of fire though huh...I would personally try and see what I could get away with, but it would be fine if we had to settle for just red flames as opposed to Captain Falcon's orange ones.
- Other: N/A
- Fire Emblem: There are a lot of options, but it would probably be best to just chill with characters from this series for now, then reel everyone back in with someone cool.
- Kid Icarus: Hades, Medusa, and Viridi would be pretty interesting. Varying levels of unnecessary, but interesting nonetheless.
- WarioWare: Ashley of course.
- Maybe one day Wario Land can get some recognition as well...
- Metal Gear: Raiden aaaaand...I honestly don't know.
- Sonic the Hedgehog: Tails, Knuckles, Shadow, Amy, Dr. Eggman...Take your pick.
- Pikmin: The current character kind of covers the entire series's gameplay, but Alph could add some things as an Echo Fighter or clone character. You could also add a Bulborb or the Plasm Wraith or something but like...why?
- Animal Crossing: Tom Nook and K.K. Slider are good choices. The animal villagers could work as an Echo Fighter of Villager (call 'em Resident). There are probably a few other choices, but I would stick with Tom Nook in terms of the next full character.
- Mega Man: Depends. If you want an Echo Fighter, than Proto Man, and probably Bass would work just fine. Dr. Wily is a decent choice for a classic eddition, but I think the better way to go would be to add Mega Man X or Zero to cover more of the series.
- Wii Fit: Don't.
- PUNCH-OUT!!: OK, setting aside worries on how they'd be designed, PUNCH-OUT!! does have its fair share of standout characters.
- Glass Joe would probably have to be a joke character in order to be faithful to him, but it could be kind of funny if he was used to poke fun at Little Mac's previous design if you fixed it, and gave Glass Joe all the same problems and none of the strengths. I personally don't like making characters intentionally weak though.
- King Hippo might be fun, though they'd probably have to pull out all the stops to make him functional.
- Soda Popinski could be decently interesting with some sort of powerup mechanic involving his "soda".
- And of course, they could always add
definitely not Mike TysonMr. Sandman.- Super Smash Bros. (Mii): For a Super Smash Bros. original character, Master Hand would probably be the least divisive choice. For the Miis, add a Mii Caster for the magical flavour.
- PAC-Man: Ms. PAC-Man in any way, shape or form would be nice.
- Xenoblade Chronicles: I can tell this is going to end up being a "new protagonists only" series like Pokémon and Fire Emblem before it, but if they do miraculously add a character that isn't that, Elma, and any non-spoilery playable character from the first game are all good choices.
- Street Fighter: Chun-Li. There are a few other reasonable options like Akuma or Zangief, but I think Chun-Li would be the best option due to her popularity and differences from Ryu and Ken. Street Fighter is more than just shotos after all.
- Final Fantasy VII: None. Just expand the series beyond a single timeline already. There's more to Final Fantasy than Final Fantasy VII as great as it is.
- Bayonetta: I dunno.
- Splatoon: The Octolings would probably be the best option. There are some potentially fun other options like D.J. Octavio, but I'd go with the Octolings first.
- Castlevania: Alucard.
- Persona: I'd go with Yu, but the series works like Fire Emblem and Xenoblade Chronicles so it's likely that we'll never see a Persona character from anything pre Persona 5.
- Dragon Quest: Slime.
- Banjo-Kazooie: Gruntilda could be fun I guess.
- Fatal Fury: I don't really know who's specifically from Fatal Fury other than Terry. His series's scope goes way beyond Fatal Fury though, so looking at all of SNK, I'd probably add Kyo next.
- ARMS: Spring Man and Ribbon Girl.
- Minecraft: I think Minecraft characters other than Steve go into unnecessary territory, but if you did add something it probably wouldn't matter what.
- Tekken: Heihachi and Jin.
MGS would be awesome to play as Revolver Ocelot.
Castlevania been wishing for Alucard I even made replications of various areas of the SOTN castle during the stage builder submissions in Brawl Online.
Mega Man would be dope to see Zero
(Ooo that's 2 in a row that are already ATs hrm)
Mario I would enjoy playing as toad for sure!
Zelda gotta be Ganon in all his porky goodness
DQ Jessica imo obv with the awesome alts
Tekken definitely King with his Tbone finisher intact pls
Pokemon that's kinda tough... Machamp tough.
Fire Emblem........ No.
Ok! Anna. Ah Anna. ..
Metroid uh well Kraid
I can't think of any more atm.
Last edited: