No, just a willingness to consider how "small" (I disagree) differences might affect a character's viability, and tier placement, in a 50+ character roster.
I don't mind if you disagree, but if you just discount all the reasoning I gave previously by saying "lol, it's trivial" your post doesn't even mean anything. It's just hot air. It's useless.
"It is the arrows and the side-b, I believe Dark Pit has a slightly weaker F-tilt as well, but you're seriously minimizing the importance of those 2 moves in the character's repertoire. Especially the arrows"
This is all your reasoning, two sentences.
The differences of course are trivial, they don't make Dark Pit bad, they make him inferior.
When we're talking getting a kill as Pits Upperdash knocking the opposition vertically straight up for a 140% kill anywhere on the stage, where as Dark Pit only gets that same % by the edge? He can aim for an earlier kill off-stage with it, with it being a *significantly* risky move off-stage that very easily lends itself to you dying if you use it off stage.
His arrow does 2% more damage at the loss of flexibility.
We're talking very small numbers. If it was 2% with the same features? Yes, however its 2% for lack of control, it's a general wash however landing a hit is better then not landing a hit, and because Pits arrows have greater ability to confirm damage due to their control, they are generally *better*.
What is your claim in favor of Dark pits ftilt?
Tl;dr Dark pit has a poorer performance then Pit. Now given this, who on the roster do you think possibly squeezes in the gap between them?
The differences are trivial but they are in Pits favor. There is a matter of practicality, I've written you quite a small piece, for your 2 sentences, as I did before.
Let's put it another way?
Who does Pit beat that dark pit "can't" beat and vise versa?
Nobody. Can anybody in this thread say a single matchup Pit actually wins over Dark Pit other then Pit vs Dark Pit?
The differences between them while significant on a level, aren't enough to really discuss. Pits better then Dark pit, Dark pits inferiority is insignificant on a general level.
So again the hell is there to consider. What do these small differences due to any viability accept vs Pit vs Dark Pit? You haven't really said a damn thing but feel we should. Show me the differences in viability? All that matters is Pit vs Dark Pit, pits tools are better in general. Which makes him win slightly more. **** the match up is probably legit 50.005:49.995
"I don't mind if you disagree, but if you just discount all the reasoning I gave previously by saying "lol, it's trivial" your post doesn't even mean anything. It's just hot air. It's useless."
Im going to have to send that right back at you.