...
Wow, I just majorly derped. I'm going to have to take back what I said about not including Adumb due to missing JTB.
Thing is, for me to not put Adumb as a full out town read for the reason of him missing a JTB read is to suggest that Adumb is scummy for that reason. However, if Adumb was actually scummates with JTB, there is no way that he would of just totally ignored him up until this point. At least, it's highly unlikely.
With that in mind . . .
July said:
Would a JTB town flip affect your read on Adum then? And do you think that pressuring Kantrip was scummy in itself, or the way in which he pressured Kantrip was scummy?
@July: Slightly, in a positive manner. I think it would look good on Adumb's part that he was ignoring the main wagon to go after his own picks. Thing is, I don't think a scum Adumb would of just totally ignored a mislynch and the biggest discussion toDay. Which pretty much leaves a town Adumb, who would probably be more concerned with going after his own picks.
What keeps Adumb only as a lean is the fact that I think he's been visiting all of the wrong places (obviously since I know I'm town I know that he's at least wrong about me). Disregarding the whole "he missed JTB" (for the reasons stated above), there's not really any of his scum reads that I can agree with of his besides RR.
...
Now I'm realizing how dumb that sounds and am rethinking it entirely. Intent trumps the given effect, after all.
Sorry guys, but I'll take responsibility for changing my mind on this one. After being pressed about it I realized that I really didn't think it through properly. It's generic of me to be cautious of someone just because I disagree with their reads, especially if the effort that they went through to obtain those reads are plainly laid out and believable.