I just want to state that I play both games.
I also want to state that people who play exclusively melee and put "N/A" in edgeguarding for brawl, etc. etc. are idiots, mostly because either they don't know much about the game and ***** without knowing what they are talking about, or they just suck too much at the game to get competitive. Also from what I saw, WC sucks at it hardcore. Enough flames. Come and use your scrubby Marths and MKs and come get ***** if you think the game is that easy, if not, then move on to new and interesting things to talk about.
My list isn't complete.
Best Combo Skills
Brawl: Ally, Elef, pastaboy
Melee: Bam, pkm, raynex
Smartest Player
Brawl: Ally, chesterr01, JL
Melee: Bam, Vwins, pkmvodka
Most Technical Skill
Brawl: Ambrose, Ally
Melee: Bam, vwins
Best Edge Guarding Smasher
Brawl: Holy, Ally (my favorite example is ally vs kingace at Fight For Your Friends in Montreal)
Melee: Bam, pkmvodka
Best Low Tier Smasher (uses low tier characters in tournament play)
Brawl: Ayaz, Percon, chesterr01
Melee: pkmvodka, Jagg
Most Diverse Smasher (plays the most characters)
Brawl: chesterr01, Percon, Ambrose
Melee: pkmvodka, vwins
Best Team Smasher (not necessarily the best skill wise, but knows how to contribute on a team)
Brawl: Holy, buenob, NikoK
Melee: Bam, vwins (these guys are just too good in teams, I'd put pkm but LOL sometimes he worst than me)
Most Traveled Smasher
Brawl: NikoK, Zaf, RunawayFire/Minus
Melee: Kage
Most Unpredictable Smasher
Brawl: Ally (holy crap that guy is good, but i'll get there)
Melee: pkmvodka (in every sense of the word unpredictable, you never know what's gonna happen when you watch him play, he should win this hands up)
Worst Smasher
Brawl: hmm... I haven't played everyone, so I can't tell
Melee: zaf, switchblade at niko's house (super baked)
Best Female Smasher
Brawl: koka, but holy crap she sucks, i saw her get ***** by mdk so many times
Melee: paty
Best Smasher Name
Brawl:
Melee: Kirbykaze
Best Crew
Brawl: Ally/Holy/Elef/Chet/Zaf
Melee: pkm/bam/vwins/chet/kage >>> top 5 GTA
Best Trash Talker
Brawl: MDK
Melee: Jagg
Best Tournament (canadian tourneys btw)
Brawl: Only in Niagara series, Fight For Your Friends
Melee: CAST4
Best Tournament Host
Brawl: Percon, NikoK, ThatGuy
Melee: Victra
Gayest Smasher (Figuratively, not literally)
Brawl: Erix!, Elef ("Walking Snake", plus owning montreal with yoshi)
Melee: Bam
Most Johns/Johns the most.
Brawl: NikoK (omg this guy johns a lot lmfao, get ***** moar!1 <3), Elef (LRAStart)
Melee: pkmvodka/chesterr01 (but we understand each other in our johns lol)
Favorite Visiting Smasher (a non-canadian smasher who came to one of our canadian tourneys.)
Brawl: MDK
Melee:
Funniest Smasher
Brawl: MDK
Melee: pkmvodka, MikeMonkey
Biggest *******:
Brawl: Zaf
Friendliest Smasher
Brawl: BentoBox, Rion
Melee: Stos
Best look a-like Smashers (Players who look like the smash characters)
Brawl:
Melee:
Most Improved Smasher
Brawl: chesterr01, JL
Melee: Bam, Raynex
Biggest Sore Loser
Brawl:
Melee: Europhoria, unknown522,
Most Missed Smasher (someone who has retired, or is rarely active.)
Brawl: Kanata Pwn Party who quit after the Metaknight Hurricane at ToS5.
Melee:
Breakout Smasher (Player to Keep an Eye Out For in 2009)
Brawl: ELEF. NO QUESTIONS ASKED
Melee: Ally
Best Team Combination (Player X, Player Y, not a figurative combination, one that ACTUALLY happened)
Brawl: Ally/Holy,
Melee: Bam/pkmvodka, rayn/ford,
Person to get the least ***** by Superboom in 64
Universal: Isai, tetsuya
Best Overall Smasher
(what does overall mean)
Brawl: Ally
Melee: Bam
Sexiest Smasher
Brawl: hmm that girl who sells t-shirts at OiN
Melee: I.B. should get some girls, he looks like he could have a rap album too
Best Moment
Brawl: Seeing Ally defeat every single challenger coming at every tournament, Zaf, the moment I realized Brawl was an awesome fighting game.
Melee: Game 2 vs Raynex at OiN4 (it was special), EC doing well at CAST4/Kansas, GTA thinking they are better than Montreal at Melee