Xiivi Loves America Mafia - Game Over! Who won?

[Vlade]

I was contrasting his posts to LeishaChu's

 

[Vyse]

It's because I enjoy making you post. You told me that you dislike revealing things in mafia games regardless of alignment. I don't see playing cards close to your chest about anything other than power roles as town as being a good thing so I'm going to make you say some things.

Actually that is my strategy. Attack my play as much as you want, but when it comes to role claiming, I try extra hard to defend myself and do everything possible to avoid relying on a role claim.

Yes, Vyse hasn't backed up his vote with good reasoning though. Firstly, he used something from the last game and that fact that Leisha is acting the same way this game. Secondly, he's giving himself a fallback when/if LeishaChu flips town. Say Vyse IS mafia, if Leisha is voted today and dies, when she flips town, Vyse can just say "she wasn't helping anyway"

Actually no. Whilst my current vote reflects my opinion of her play in Rocky, it is an attack on her post #49.

Well regardless of gender, anything can really be possible. But since we really lack evidence now so im just going to wait till an agreement comes across

Which clearly stated her position and stance on her strategy, which I formed a theory around.

FFFFFFF I wanted to be in this game so badly but forgot to shotgun a spot.

Oh well I've been studying all your play styles and lots of previous games, so I guess I'll keep doing that until the next game.

Sorry for interrupting your fun...please carry on

<3 <3 <3!

It's alright Toby, it's a 9 person game with shorter deadlines, so it should be quicker than Rocky.

 

[Vyse]

Would you mind specifically pointing out the questions so I don't misinterpret what questions you mean Vyse?

What made your suspicions so good that you decided to vote her after she actually voted then?

Also, stop complaining about being ninja'd, check the page before you post :]

I'm not going to allow the use of "oh but she ninja'd my vote" as an excuse. You can avoid almost ALL ninja's by refreshing.

Mostly it's so that all my typing doesn't go to waste. lol.

And either way, I didn't address her vote on me at all in my post, which means it's not an OMGUS vote, but a vote based in theory unrelated to her reason of voting for me.

 

[SummonerAU]

pointing out I'd like you to specify which questions you want me to answer again.

 

[Vyse]

EditByWayOfPost:

The question I posed back to you: What made your suspicions so good that you decided to vote her after she actually voted then?

Is actually inaccurate. What I really mean is why is your vote on her?

 

[Hobobloke]

Summoner I'm unsure at the moment, Vyse has done a good job of getting things rolling and putting pressure on people so I'm inclined to see how things roll out otm.

FoS:Vyse
I know Vyse is a good player at mafia and he may be using that to his advantage, I mean if mafia leads the town it's gg the alternative to that is if he was lynched and town we'd lose a great asset.

 

[Hobobloke]

Ninja'd by this whole page. Wow.

 

[SummonerAU]

I voted Leisha before she voted.
---From here on was ninja'd so I laughed---
I will presume you meant the question to be "What made your suspicions so good that you decided to vote her?" because I didn't want her to play like she did last game. Regardless of her alignment this game I just don't want to see inactiveness because I HATE IT. IT'S SO BORING. I didn't believe this to be much better than a random vote because I can't go by the assumption she will play the same way. Then there was the little thing with the mention of Lord Bowser as a Zangoose and then another thing with FoS which I think are a better basis for a vote than a theory of inactivity.

 

[xXArrowXx]

" How do you feel about LeishaChu and Vyse at this point in time?"

they are trying to make something out of nothing... just watching how it goes
cant really tell between them enough to make my vote not random. leaning more towards liesha being town tho.

ah might aswell come out with it

Vote:Vlade

he seems logical but abit to much pressuring on a potential townie.

 

[SummonerAU]

Going back over some posts, I saw these posted by Arrow.

So what does Australia mean to you?
(town please try to be patriotic...)

i dont want vyse trying to lynch me for bad grammer and speeling...
FoS: vyse

Arrow, the advocate of lynching today not placing a vote. I'm pretty surprised by that.

 

[xXArrowXx]

we aren't gonna get lead the whole way by mafia... -.- be inderpendant in thought, however trusting when it matters.

 

[xXArrowXx]

NINJAH i am ninja, you are ninja

 

[SummonerAU]

Oh lol

SHUT UP VYSE. I TOTALLY WASN'T NINJA'D

 

[SummonerAU]

God Dammit **** You Again Arrow

 

[SummonerAU]

Could people who have said they are think about their vote at least lay a random vote?

 

[SummonerAU]

thinking*
10*

 

[Vlade]

Where's the rush to force people to random vote?

Just let them bandwagon

 

[SummonerAU]

To all: What's your take on the current situation?

 

[SummonerAU]

Vlade, who said random votes can't bandwagon?

The idea is to stop people being inactive so we don't get distracted by killing inactives/letting mafia lurk. Pretty much I want to avoid what Sieg was doing last game :]

 

[SummonerAU]

GAWD, WHEN I GET BACK FROM BED, THERE BETTER BE SOME **** POSTS
caps

 

[Sieg]

Sorry what I did was effective and accurately used.

Next time I will try to be more active and fail at my specific roles for the game.

EDIT: YOU DIDN'T SEE THIS POST XIIVI.

 

[SummonerAU]

You miss the point Sieg. The idea is to make mafia members post more. I'm not attacking you for playing as you did.

Vote: LeishaChu

I worked out an idea when I was trying to sleep last night :]

 

[Pete278]

I..wow, didn't expect the thread to move so quickly. Leisha does seem a tad suspicious (who thinks out a random vote? you don't have anything to actually consider), but I dislike letting pressure votes get to the point that the mob has control of the hammer, so..
FoS: Leisha

Probably vote later, depending on how the pressure goes.

 

[Vlade]

Yeah, I would imagine the Mafia are playing fairly conservatively right now and just waiting for the opportunity

 

[SummonerAU]

;-;

So many 'I'll see how it goes'

@Leisha: Have you had a big think a decided on the vote for today?
@Lord Bowser: Who do you feel is the most suspicious atm?

Vote: Lord Bowser

 

[Muzga]

sign me up as a replacement

 

[xXArrowXx]

well we can decide to choose a pot of random people then get game moderator to roll it....

say 2 people voted liesh.. that means there will be 2 sides on the die as liesh. etc..
so the bandwagoning increases the chance however essentially is random.

 

[SummonerAU]

Vote: Arrow

Nothing that says day one HAS to be random Arrow.

 

[Xiivi]

Day 1 Vote Count 2

LeishaChu - Vyse, Vlade (

)
Lord Bowser - (0)
Pete278 - (0)
SummonerAU - (0)
undead_moose - Pete278 (

)
unreon - (0)
Vyse - LeishaChu (

)
Vlade - xXArrowXx (

)
xXArrowXx - undead_moose, SummonerAU (

)

Not Voting - Lord Bowser, unreon (

)

Deadline for Day 1 is January 28th, 2010 9:00PM AEST. With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch!

No word from unreon still, will replace if needed.

 

[undead_moose]

I do like arrows idea but we should make it 3 people

I put myself on the line for the russian roulette game of death

 

[SummonerAU]

So, you two would rather making the vote entirely random instead of going after people with little suspicious things?

You two made me frown.

 

[undead_moose]

Well no one has done anything sus yet seeming as it is the first day

YET

and summoner.... Dont you start me about people not listening to you in a mafia game

 

[Pete278]

See, this is why we didn't get anywhere in the last game. Everyone acts suss.

 

[SummonerAU]

I think it isn't a good idea. If you want a random vote, get the town to do it and leave the mod out of it.

 

[undead_moose]

How the hell can the town do it

 

[SummonerAU]

Moose, that's the point. How can players do something truly random when there's people with ulterior motives in the game. We want those people to do as much as possible so we can catch them out on it. If you tell the mod to just roll dice, how will we get this info?

At least if people get a lynch today we can see if the person flips town and then see who was on the bandwagon. Odds are there's a scum member in there.

 

[Pete278]

Complete random lynching is equivilent to not lynching at all in terms of information, so I'm suspicious of Arrow and Moose now.

 

[undead_moose]

Well i had a way of clearing town day 1 but because you wouldnt co operate its pretty much ruined

Also arrow is pretty much cleared for town now

 

[SummonerAU]

I'm more suspicious of Arrow than Moose though. Mosoe cam up with the idea and didn't sign himself to it. At least Moose did. inb4 Arrow says he will

I've voted Arrow
FoS: Leisha
fingernail of suspicion: Vyse, Moose

 

[SummonerAU]

Hey Moose, it's a pretty terrible plan if it relies on everyone going with you. People aren't even going to touch that day one if they're smart as, you know, everyone has potential to be scum.

I assume your plan was to see who would put themselves into the random kill?