Caleb played you in friendlies at AR2, and beat you V.A, and I was watching. And he's been to more tournaments, and placed at least 9th in all but two, one where he came 13th, and one where he came 5th. My opinion is pretty considered. Now, you and AmcD is an entirely different story, so you can feel free to argue that one.
-
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
WOC presents: Cold Hand Johns - Sat 26th Jan 2008
- Thread starter Aiko
- Start date
VA
Smash Hero
I played him in one friendly, and it was really close, then we had to stop for the tournament, mid game if I remember. Anyway like I said, not fussed for him to receive a seeding over me.
However in my opinion AmcD should not receive a seeding above me, that's all I have to say on it.
However in my opinion AmcD should not receive a seeding above me, that's all I have to say on it.
Retroking2000
Smash Master
I knew someone loved me
J03
Smash Master
those arent the seeds lol, i just thought id post some my opinion obvz
they dont matter much, if edwin was a top seed and ed was a high seed it doesnt matter that much
how much can people care about something so trivial lol
if your not seeded then beat a seed, its pretty obvz imo >_<
they dont matter much, if edwin was a top seed and ed was a high seed it doesnt matter that much
how much can people care about something so trivial lol
if your not seeded then beat a seed, its pretty obvz imo >_<
Mr.P
Zeppo
Reacher
Charles
Frost
Jam
Wes
Ogre
Davemans
Ryan
Caleb
B.B
geek
Edwin
Ed
V.angel
Looks fine to me, because it gives Caleb his high seed, and B.B one because he's better then Joe if I'm not mistaken, and me losing my top seed after missing one tournament, when it didn't happen to Euan twice, like I mentioned, would be ********. But other then that, Jam's list is looking the best so far, so go Jam xP
Zeppo
Reacher
Charles
Frost
Jam
Wes
Ogre
Davemans
Ryan
Caleb
B.B
geek
Edwin
Ed
V.angel
Looks fine to me, because it gives Caleb his high seed, and B.B one because he's better then Joe if I'm not mistaken, and me losing my top seed after missing one tournament, when it didn't happen to Euan twice, like I mentioned, would be ********. But other then that, Jam's list is looking the best so far, so go Jam xP
J03
Smash Master
is geek coming?
i have no idea.
also AmcD mad deserves a seed, hes blates better then caleb imo
i have no idea.
also AmcD mad deserves a seed, hes blates better then caleb imo
Bullet Bill
Smash Master
I was just posting that I was agreeing with BB. Whats with the rant?
ac_anon
Smash Ace
pfff it hardly matters we all know im getting 13th anyway
Bullet Bill
Smash Master
I think Ogre deserves a top seed as well- 3rd at AR2 remember. What about Coey? he's tied with V.A. IMO.
grayfox
Smash Champion
I reckon Allan should get a seed lol, hes consistantly taken the higher seed spot in the pools of every tourney he's been too.
Also, Coey came in top seed over me in a tourney, put him in lol
Also, Coey came in top seed over me in a tourney, put him in lol
ac_anon
Smash Ace
go me
not that i mind, people seem to get seeded above me all the time despite me having never met them or lost to them, il still get 13th, always happens.
however at least humour me and make me a reserve seed lol
J03
Smash Master
no offence to VA but i still think coeys better
Omadon
Internal Combustion Power
Question - who the hell is AmcD? (I'll make you eat those words, joe my boy 
) and tbh - obviously I'm biased - But I deserve high seed. Nowhere near top. but high, yes. And like **** should Ed be seeded over Ogre.
) and tbh - obviously I'm biased - But I deserve high seed. Nowhere near top. but high, yes. And like **** should Ed be seeded over Ogre. Amen to the above. I actualy couldent agree more. However - so long as I'm at least high seed, I really don't care. But I'm going to castrate whoever finalizes the list if I'm not.
grayfox
Smash Champion
"I really don't care. But I'm going to castrate whoever finalizes the list if I'm not."
lol good times
lol good times
J03
Smash Master
Top Seeds
Mr.P
Zeppo
Reacher
Charles
Frost
Jam
Wes
Ogre
High Seeds
Ed
Davemans
Ryan
AmcD
Coey
GEEK
Edwin
B.B
Low/Backup seeds
J03
V.angel
Spam
Ac_anon
Caleb
Monty
V3x?
Aiko
Ouch
are there any other candidates for this
this is all obvz ******** >_<
Mr.P
Zeppo
Reacher
Charles
Frost
Jam
Wes
Ogre
High Seeds
Ed
Davemans
Ryan
AmcD
Coey
GEEK
Edwin
B.B
Low/Backup seeds
J03
V.angel
Spam
Ac_anon
Caleb
Monty
V3x?
Aiko
Ouch
are there any other candidates for this
this is all obvz ******** >_<
Cpt.Zeppo
Smash Lord
I think the main thing is that the high and low(so to speak) seeds are distributed fairly so everyones got a shot.That way it doesnt really matter.If the low seeds joe mentioned are distributed equally with the high seeds then it doesnt make a difference whether you're high or low.
But it does matter who is placed with who.Caleb,for example,should be placed with say Coey.VA with BB.Otherwise it disrupts the accuracy-the higher low seeds pair with the lower highs,that way it decides disputes that people have about them being high.
Whatever happens I dont think Ed can be top atm-Ogre has simply been placing higher more consistently for the last few tournaments,and thats all we can really go by.
But it does matter who is placed with who.Caleb,for example,should be placed with say Coey.VA with BB.Otherwise it disrupts the accuracy-the higher low seeds pair with the lower highs,that way it decides disputes that people have about them being high.
Whatever happens I dont think Ed can be top atm-Ogre has simply been placing higher more consistently for the last few tournaments,and thats all we can really go by.
Bullet Bill
Smash Master
NOOOO!!!!!! Caleb instead of Edwin. OMG CALEB POSTED!!!!!!!! 
COEY
Smash Lord
Lmao BulletBen has been trying for ages to get GMC to make some posts. Then Joe makes one little post and all hell breaks loose lol. Seed me or don't w/e, just means i have to upset some poor high seed, as i'm sure half of high seeds at least and all the top seeds would be gutted to lose a set to me. Also i mean yea Caleb has finished 5th and so has Edwin, fair enough that makes them qualified for seeding..... but wait shock horror so have i!!! OMGWTF ^^ But like i said it doesnt matter really aslong as like Zeppo has said lower high seeds get put with higher non seeds. Plus i mean if 40+ ppl show up to this wont it be a 24 man bracket?
Though i think my sig qualifies me for a seed if nothing else.
Though i think my sig qualifies me for a seed if nothing else.
Aiko
Smash Champion
This is what happens when seeds are made. We will be releasing seeds sometime in the first week of Jan.
Ogre: Caleb is very likely to get a high seed. All the lists here are just speculation, non of it is official.
To answer the question on everyones lips: "whos AmcD?!"
He's a relatively new player from Liverpool, but is arguably the best player out of STFU and WOC. If JO3, CO3Y and B.B are seed worthy, then AmcD is without a doubt. Plus he placed 7th at GT.
Ogre: Caleb is very likely to get a high seed. All the lists here are just speculation, non of it is official.
To answer the question on everyones lips: "whos AmcD?!"
He's a relatively new player from Liverpool, but is arguably the best player out of STFU and WOC. If JO3, CO3Y and B.B are seed worthy, then AmcD is without a doubt. Plus he placed 7th at GT.
J03
Smash Master
and 4th in teams
COEY
Smash Lord
grayfox
Smash Champion
I've won teams twice, best in the uk? prolly obv
ac_anon
Smash Ace
iv been 3rd in teams :Meh who hasn't done that?
.
COEY
Smash Lord
Lol Allan 
Need an MM with you at this maybe i can make up for AR2 and for quite simply embarassing me on the dance floor xD.
Need an MM with you at this maybe i can make up for AR2 and for quite simply embarassing me on the dance floor xD.
ac_anon
Smash Ace
Lol Allan
lol sure, im quite glad i can barely remember that
J03
Smash Master
top seeds are pretty set
except 8th place between ed and ogre
ogre finished 3rd at some tourney
ed has finished 2nd in some tourney
.
ogre has been practicing against caleb
ed has been practicing with wes
.
except 8th place between ed and ogre
ogre finished 3rd at some tourney
ed has finished 2nd in some tourney
.
ogre has been practicing against caleb
ed has been practicing with wes
.
COEY
Smash Lord
Putting up seeds at a time like this means that they can be discussed and refined. It also gives us somethign relevant to talk about so the thread doesnt desend into absolute ****e. (Like the previous thread) It's always good to put them up early to iron everything out so this sort of talk doesnt happen on the day.
grayfox
Smash Champion
LOL Allan destroyed us all on the dance floor, give that man a seed
COEY
Smash Lord
The best bit was still you getting thrown out from the club for going behind the bar to serve Jam as the bar staff were taking too long. :D
grayfox
Smash Champion
XDXD sorry mang
ac_anon
Smash Ace
good times
Retroking2000
Smash Master
i hate ppl who sandbag ^
J03
Smash Master
tos=b.bill obv
Retroking2000
Smash Master
Smoking is not good for you messes with people minds
Reacher
Smash Apprentice
If Jake doesn't get a top seed then, well, whoever made the list has nowt. He should get it above Ed, me and maybe even Euan.
Caleb and AmcD should both get high seeds imo, and also you should take pokemon stadium off random (I'm going to keep piping on about this until you agree just to shut me up.)
Caleb and AmcD should both get high seeds imo, and also you should take pokemon stadium off random (I'm going to keep piping on about this until you agree just to shut me up.)