Okay, I really want to know, is Splatoon worth $60? I'm really, really on the fence on this one. It looks ridiculously fun and creative, but ever review I've read gives me the impression that it's a game that's flawed, but good. Can someone give me a fair evaluation of the game?
60 dollars is definitely a lot, but given the quality of the game itself, it's worth it. The content might not be like your average JRPG, but I'd say the content is on par with a typical non-Mario/Zelda Nintendo title (Pikmin). I haven't finished single player mode, but it's going to take several hours or so to finish from the looks of it. Learning curve is actually perfect for this game. After the first boss, the game actually requires thought and precision which is rather early and rare for recent Nintendo titles. Tutorial is handled perfectly. Game doesn't stop you to teach you things, it's more like Starfox 64 on how they teach you through dialogue boxes without pausing the game.
The game definitely gives off a Mario feel to me. It's like they mixed Mario Sunshine and Galaxy together and applied it to something new. Even the boss fights feel like they could fit in those games. Single player actually has some progression for your character. You can choose to upgrade weapons/abilities from the single player campaign, and you can find power ups in stages.
I've had fun playing multiplayer online. I've played by joining friends before but I wasn't expecting to have so much fun even with just strangers. At the moment, there's quite a bit of maps in rotation right now. Even playing the same two for an hour doesn't get boring. Plus, the more you play, the more you level up. It allows you to gain access to money and a bigger pool of equipment. Even if you put off on buying the game, you're still going to have to grind a bit just so you can experience more content at higher levels.
I haven't tried that 1v1 local multiplayer mode yet. While I know people wanted a full fleshed local mode, I'm quite fine with how it is. You can tell the game is suited for multiplayer battles, and they wanted people to focus on that.
When I heard the game will be adding content as it goes on, I was expecting the worse. Fortunately, it does feel like a completed game to me. I didn't feel like I paid for an unfinished game (which you see a lot of these days from companies). I really don't see any glaring flaws in this game. Game has good controls, graphics, good day 1 content (greater than something like Mario Party for sure).
The things you could pick at is that there could be more modes. However, I think it's good as it is. This is a lot for the first game of a new IP. If you have money to spare, I suggest getting it. If you're worried about content, they have stuff rolling out in the summer, so it's not even too far off.