Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
And since this is the only one of yours I've seen, then I can only assume you are a whiny ***** who only looks at 1/4 of people's posts and makes ******** assumptions in an effort to insult me on a post that what I said was just my complete feelings, not directed in any rude manner towards anyone expect, obviously, Sakurai, and you have a ****ing problem with that?
Yo coreygames... were is your avatar from? I saw that on MGO.
I know that melee is more competitive than brawl but completely on the theory level why is gameplay that goes exactly as the creator intended i.e. can't be broken considered bad?
Please rephrase the question... ^_^'? please.
Either you're retarted, you have a bad memory, or you just don't remember me (the latter is a fine excuse), but on the "Brawl will have backwards progression thread" you and I argued for a good page or two... I've seen you post before. Plus, I've seen you're posts on other various threads, and trust me, they all make you seem like a douchebag. Here's an idea for you: Respect and listen to what other people have to say--it will make you seem nicer and people will do the same to you.
I'm pretty sure Sakurai didn't intend for Metaknight's infinite ledgestalling, nor all the infinite throws/grabs characters have. Or really even to be played without items.
I never said it was a bad thing. Im saying that trying to play this game like melee will never happen and this game will always be played the same. So if you want a challenge join the fight to bring Melee back nationwide/
That's a good point. What if I said that Metal Gear Solid was bad just becuase I don't like stealth based games?
This is a tangential question, but I'm curious to hear your response, Reaver (considering your very astute answer to EvolveOrDie's post):
Jack it isnt anti-melee. If it were than melee players wouldnt be dominating the scene. The game simply focuses on one style of play, whereas in melee there were many different competing styles of play.
I guess you just miss the page long ones where I explicitly cite every single rational thing I can think of on the topic, write in a manner worthy of a college professor, and stray from any forms of douche-baggery. I suppose your selective eye-sight just won't allow for that.
Like I give a **** about that.
The only reason I said 'anti-Melee' was because the only other phrase I can think of is 'anti-competitive', which I don't agree with because we don't agree on what makes a game 'competitive'. What I meant is the whole 'floaty, no hitstun, no combos, etc.' facet of Brawl. Basically, how Brawl is a lot of what Melee isn't.
And you don't think that you're a douchebag?!?!? Read what you just posted. If you like being annoying and having everybody hate you because you don't listen to what other people have to say, how can you not call yourself a douchebag?
Thank God for you.
I agree that I doubt those things were intentional programmed into the game, I consider them to be either programming oversights or exploits cause through unpredictable programming interaction. On the subject of items that's an iffy one because while Sakurai may not want you to play without items he acknowledges that you may want to and gives you the option. I don't think brawl is bad by any stretch of the imagination, but when you compare it to melee in the category that brawl has been proven to suffer at and melee excels at it skews the representation of both games as a whole; because while melee is more competitive than brawl is is melee more competitive than MvC2, CvSNK, GGXX, and the like and how does brawl stack up against them. We sort of willfully limit our analysis of the viable competitiveness of the two games to only each other when we use the definition that applies to more than just those two games.
And listen to what you just said. You are wasting valuable space in this thread, de-railing the conversation, to try to libel me. Way to go. That's not douche bag in any way. I'm not a douche. I post what I want to say when I want to. I don't care what other people think or feel, especially over the internet. If you have a problem with me saying, "Brawl sucks because it sucks all the awesome out of the everything," then fine. It doesn't bother me. But if you are going to whine that I never say anything worthwhile ever, then you are the one being a douche bag. You are the one trying to dis-credit someone. You are the one flaming. Isn't that douche bag worthy? If so, then I am but you are too!
He was talking to both of us, corey. I'm done, I hope you are too.
Its true. If you like a really competitive game, melee is probably better for you. If you would rather play with items or have a bigger cast, brawl is probably better for you. Neither game is better then the other, but people can like one more. Its all a matter of taste.
Well, I guess I should preface by saying that my Ed Wood/Shyamalan was just to show that a product can turn out almost exactly the way it's creator wanted it to be but still be panned for it. I didn't mean to imply at all that Brawl is a bad game in the way that Ed Wood movies are bad movies.
Reaver, take all the time you need. I'm glad to hear that you're going to think about your answers before you post; a lot of people would just regurgitate the same MvB arguments we've heard for months. You should be respected and applauded for taking the extra time to ponder about your response, as far as I'm concerned.
I want to know what your subjective answers are, tempered by the objective facts and data you've gleaned off of SWF and from debates. Your opinion, basically. Leave the rest of us out of it; what are the conclusions you've come to?
Coreygames is cooler than you
Truth, so why couldn't that have been the last post. lets end this thread, cause it is slowly going downhill....
