1st gen>2nd>3rd>4th
Easy. I really like Gold and Silver, I just wish they would remake them for the DS or GBA, just so I could use them with the newer games. Ah well...
Definitely agreed.
I'm kind of wishing they would recreate G/S. On one hand, they were awesome games that deserve to be remade, and would probably be really good remade. On the other hand, I can't help but have this inkling that it'll turn out to ruin Gold and Silver in some way. Like with Fire Red and Leaf Green...they weren't that bad, they didn't ruin anything, but I play those games and, unlike any other remake I've ever played, it doesn't feel like the original. Again, they're not bad, they're fun games, in fact. But something about them is just...off.
What would be REALLY great is if they would just learn something already; POKEMON FANS WANT MULTIPLE REGIONS IN A GAME AGAIN! Seriously, ever since Gold and Silver people have been saying that, and we still haven't gotten multiple regions again. Way to listen to your fans, guys.
Third gen is surprisingly underrated, though. While I wouldn't put it above first or second, I liked the feel of it a lot. It felt so...creative, so interesting, so different. Yet, with a lot of Pokemon fans, it's rated even worse than fourth gen. I don't get it.