It just gets so frustrating when you like one thing (Sonic/WB/DC etc) and don’t like it’s primary rival (Mario/Disney/Marvel etc) and everyone wont shut up about how the thing you like is trash compared to the thing you hate, and that it would be better if it was more like the thing you hate, but doing that would take away the identity of the franchise that attracted it to you in the first place. It’s like people are actively trying to kill what I like.
But that's not my intent. I'm a fan of both, and very much so.
Actions speak louder than words, so, a little history.
I bought a Genesis Model 2 along with S3&K back when you could still do that brand new off the shelf, and ever since he's been introducing me to new experiences and fuelling my love of gaming. Best example is when I snapped up the 6-Pak specifically because it came with Sonic 1, and got hooked on literally every other game there as well, but I also got hold of 2, 3D Blast, Spinball, and Mean Bean Machine and adored even tangential Sonic references anywhere else. I read the Archie comic faithfully from the time it just hit double digits until it got somewhere just shy of 100, and I'm pretty sure I still have a box of em somewhere in cheap penny sleeves. I had my grandmother record the old DiC cartoon to watch after school.
Fast forward to adulthood and 2011, roughly my introduction to SB as a whole. I skipped most of the sixth generation of consoles - Gamecube, Xbox, PS2 - and had gone almost entirely PC. My playgroup was at work - we'd have rounds on breaks and lunches - and I picked up a secondhand Gamecube to practice Melee at home.
But my second and third game purchases for the system were SA1 DX and SA2 Battle - which I was sad to have missed out on with the Dreamcast - beating out Twilight Princess, Starfox Assault, and the Metroid Prime games.
Other side of things, Pokemon. I picked up Red when it came out and got thoroughly hooked. My neighbor tended to pick up the other version available at the time, so I ended up getting Red, Yellow, Gold, and Sapphire. Played the TCG in its early days, even going to tournaments (though not placing well); while I no longer do, I credit that with sparking my interest in Magic which continues to this day. I saw the first two movies in theaters and followed the early days of the anime pretty regularly. I adored the collectible monsters format so much I even picked up other franchises that played like it, including Dragon Warrior Monsters I and II, Robopon I and II, Azure Dreams (GBC), and Magi Nation.
These are just the highlights; my history with both companies goes
miles back and we'd be here all morning talking about it. The point I want to lay in stone is that I adore both highly.
Now that all said I can acknowledge individual ups or downs within franchises I love. I enjoyed X&Y, but ORAS got a big meh from me. Very few of the 3D Sonics appealed to me. Stuff like that. Just because I love a franchise doesn't mean I love a franchise
blindly, in brief.
And what I'm seeing here is that I prefer Detective Pikachu over Sonic The Hedgehog
Sonic kind of reminds me of the recent slate of superhero origin movies, but a manhunt for Sonic isn't especially compelling to me, even if it's Eggman hunting him. I'm getting no vibe off the world they're in other than Generic Present Day, USA. The writing has spirit - Sonic and Tom seem like they'll be fun to watch especially - but more of it feels slightly cliche'd than not. I feel like other properties - cartoons and comics, mostly, but also the games - told such stories much better. This doesn't necessarily doom it to be a bad movie. Might even like it. But so far I get the feeling I won't be wowed.
Detective Pikachu meanwhile has the advantage of being a spinoff of a franchise rather than an adaptation (that's what the anime and its movies are for), meaning each of these feels like a fresh take on prior themes. The way it's written also oozes characterization for Tim and Pikachu and the world they inhabit. Everything they've shown so far only leaves me wanting more.
The best juxtaposition I can put forward is between Ryan Reynolds' Detective Pikachu and Jim Carrey's Eggman. The former's only other established appearance was in the Detective Pikachu game, and because he's not expected to conform to the same traits as, say, Ash's Pikachu, Reynolds gets to really make the character his own - and the two's personalities mesh together very well, with Reynolds only needing to add a bit of sass and wit to finish the job. Meanwhile Carrey is kind of superimposing himself on Eggman, and that's not necessarily a terrible idea, but I've grown up with Deem Bristow, Mike Pollock, and Long John Baldry's interpretations (Jim Cummings not so much, although I liked his take from what I've since seen) and Carrey's really comes to blows with all those.
Let's TL;DR this before I start giving people a headache.
I love Pokemon. I love Sonic. I have for longer than a good chunk of SB has been alive.
I love the way the Detective Pikachu movie is going because it feels fresh and well put together, and it's effectively unshackled itself from most of its expectations since most of the franchise is already a blank slate.
I think the way the Sonic movie is going, though not necessarily bad, feels more generic and cliche'd, and not all of it meshes with what I've come to expect going into a Sonic story because the characters and world are established very differently elsewhere.
None of these statements contradict each other. None of these statements should be construed as an attack on the franchises as a whole or anyone who enjoys them. They are simply my opinions and nothing more.
Anyone else is free to hold differing opinions and I will respect them accordingly.
And the last thing I want is for you to feel like you're under some kind of assault. That ain't what I'm about.
Aight?