Sworddancer, why are you rashly voting OS over information that we have yet to have been confirmed and just going off what Ranmaru said? What is your actual read on OS sans the claim the Ranmaru has made on him?
Yet to confirm? Unless I missed something, how are we going to confirm it?
I don't think that my vote is rash given the circumstances. I waited for Ran to clarify what he meant, and he did. Strongman seems to be a very logical role for scum to have in this set up. A town strongman with a town vig? No.
Idk why someone didn't die last Night, but I'm not going to concern myself with WIFOM like that. RR claims to have shot PJB, but he didn't die. That's two shots that failed. For all we know, all kills could have failed last Night for whatever reason. I'm not saying that this is the case, just that I'm not going to concern myself with the unknowable.
Not taking ANY Night actions into account, I am confused as to what to think about OS. He seemed very convinced in his case, and I'll be damned if he was faking all that content. If he went out of his way to just make that monster of a case for town points, then I tip my hat to him. However, he must have realized that the very basic premise was dumb, yes? The idea that Nabe would make a player IN THE GAME a puppet slot? Hell, not just OS, but others must have realized just how unlikely this type of connection would exist in the first place, right?
Nope, he didn't. Starting from late Day 1, he started to convince himself and others in a huge BS case for Chuckie being Le.
*sigh*
Chuckie said it best, it basically comes down to rather or not you believe OS could fake this effort. If it was anyone else but OS I would say no. However, it was OS, and I do believe it's possible for mafia OS to be legit indy hunting. I'm not saying that he was mafia because he was indy hunting, but just that it's possible.
Without Ran's claim, I would say town, just because he HAS put in a lot more effort than others, which while I believe it to be possible for him to fake, I don't believe likely. However, with the claim, I'm going scum on him now.