-
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Totally Normal Mafia [Game Over, Town and Independent Win]
- Thread starter tmw_redcell
- Start date
Yes, I want you to use your ability on me tonight to test one of the two possibilities I can still see it being if that's a real role, and the other one could very well fit(although an odd implementation of it compared to what I've seen in the past). Once I thought of the possibility it was just enough, coupled with the other strange claim, to make me trust you a bit more. And more than that, if we don't have an sk it could potentially be very beneficial to town, and pretty much not damaging. Once again, I don't entirely trust you, but coming up with a working role has made me take it in a different light.
Maybe you are a protective role, and you protected me from a kill. That could explain why there was only one death. [If there is an SK]. Also, mentos, why do you want him to test it on you? He tested it on me and nothing happened to me. What do you think would happen to you?
Stop claiming URHGGHGHG silly Unvote: Yaya, Vote: Chaco
That's nonsense. Part of my reasoning was for him parroting people which I do not believe that I've done. Plus, I feel my posts have had more substance than his and I'm an obvious Townie as always anyway. Yaya is essentially a coasting, parroting vanilla now who we can't even be sure is Town. And stingers was an abysmal choice for such a potentially good role, let alone on Day One.
As for declaring Macman Town I've already gone over this. Maybe he's not but I doubt it and think it's silly to think me suspicious for it.
And again stop the claiming.
The more I think about it the more I think I have a protective role and not the role we're thinking of Mentos. Because I definitely would get something from Macman. Also, I'm sure the only reason it would work as a self protecting role is becuase you don't know what it does and have to figure it out. Also, it would make perfect sense, like Mac said, that someone targeted Mac and I protected him.
I don't know, that's why I want him to. I have a couple of theories on what could possibly be the power behind his role if it's real, and not knowing yours helps me piece together information. Also, if we have a tracker/watcher they can confirm Chaco(who is still one of the more suspicious people imo) by watching me or tracking him and verifying it the next day. In all honesty, I just feel this way may work out well with either of the things I can see him being if it's real.
Hmm, I still don't find a protective role as likely, but if that IS what it is, we may be on to something here. Assuming we're both still alive tonight, if you're willing to trust me, be on me as I asked earlier. I think it could be beneficial either way.
Why do you want him to test it on you though?
Also, it wouldn't confirm chaco, it would just let us know that he has a visiting role.
Also, it wouldn't confirm chaco, it would just let us know that he has a visiting role.
Really dumb question feel no pressure to answer that mentos.
pfft
I don't see how it is dumb at all. What will he gain from having it being tested on him. We already have seen that the affect it has isn't told to the target. If anything I think chaco should use it on whoever he pleases. I don't like the idea of Mafia knowing where people's night actions are being directed towards.
I don't see how it is dumb at all. What will he gain from having it being tested on him. We already have seen that the affect it has isn't told to the target. If anything I think chaco should use it on whoever he pleases. I don't like the idea of Mafia knowing where people's night actions are being directed towards.
no .
Don't say "we" I don't trust you yeesh. You, Chaco, Handorin, and Yaya are all cool with me.
Handorin
Smash Hero
- Joined
- Dec 2, 2005
- Messages
- 6,013
I've been at work for 12 hour.
Re|)iculou role are ually put in for thi rea5on. I |)i|) it in tli, an|) I got that i|)ea from tom, who i5 cohoting thi.
Hi5 crumb wa wack though.
both ha|) poi5on. =)
I figure it wa 1 time u5e.
After recxent |)evelopment, I feel better about my lynch choice a5 oppoe|) to the other two.
P.5. I nee a new keyboar. -_-
Handorin
Smash Hero
- Joined
- Dec 2, 2005
- Messages
- 6,013
5orry. =(
I believre my brother 5pille 5omething on it, an I coul|)n't fix it all the way. It'5 way more annoying to type.
Since you guys don't seem to want to lynch Chaco or Yaya then I'll Unvote: Chaco and Vote: Florida for stuff I said earlier and just being suspicious in general throughout the game. Let's lynch someone, preferably him.
test 7 a
Hando do you have any suspicions other than Rockin?
test 7 a
Hando do you have any suspicions other than Rockin?
Yep.
Mislynching is part of the game. It's either that or keep the **** townies who don't know how to make themselves look Town around and stay confused like Spidey-Mafia. And who cares who close mylo/lylo is, the whole point is to get some clarity by endgame. Maybe that's the pace we're supposed to play at, considering most mods shouldn't expect Town to suck enough to go 2 No-Lynches back-to-back like we're nearly going to. I'd have a much easier time in a lylo with Kevin and Macman than I would with, say, Hando and Florida.
No it isn't.
Lylo = Lynch-or-Lose
Mylo = Mislynch and Lose
Lylo = Lynch-or-Lose
Mylo = Mislynch and Lose
Handorin
Smash Hero
- Joined
- Dec 2, 2005
- Messages
- 6,013
You don't know how I am end game. =)
Vote: Smashman
My fault I assumed I had voted for him with the number of times I said I wanted to vote for him rofl.
My fault I assumed I had voted for him with the number of times I said I wanted to vote for him rofl.
I agree, but if you're gonna mislynch on a townie, get rid of the inactive ones. <.<
Which I suggested earlier but you were quick to criticize me for and even came to the defense of that person. Ugh why is no one else willing to vote you.
Uncertainty, and they are showing caution like they should. I'm only saying it now because we've basically covered everything we can today, and if you're gonna push a lynch at least an inactive is a win-lose with the possibility of a win-win.
Dark_Ermac
Smash Apprentice
- Joined
- Jun 24, 2007
- Messages
- 104
I sign up as a replacement.
Might as well point out that Chaco would probably die at this rate. You fellows need to step it up and vote so I know what you're thinking. Smashman, I hope you come to a decision soon on whether or not getting a replacement because you've been quiet and it's hurting us.
We only have two days left upon a decision, and we need to make one now. I've thought about the claim of Yaya's and Chaco's claims. In all honestly, I don't feel comfortable with either's claim. Not because it's just weird, but too 'wtf?'
For example, given the player the power to replace anyone he chooses. These kind of powers are pretty strong and are usually in charge of the Mods, so I can't much see how Yaya's claim is real. The breadcrumb doesn't look like a breadcrumb, but more of someone would actually say that. For all we know, stringers could've been replaced for inactivity (He stopped replying on the 10th of July and he was announced replaced 3 days later). If Yaya did have the power to replace, wouldn't he have replaced him SOONER if he felt Stingers was being a hinderance?
I am unsure what Mentos and Chaco have planned, but if Chaco DOES live to see the next day, I guess we'll know soon.
In either case, I don't mind either a Chaco or Yaya lynch at this point, but I may lean for a Yaya. I still have no idea what Chaco's power role suppose to do and how this may effect town. >> In terms of Florida, I never noticed him coasting, but I'm starting to see that now
For example, given the player the power to replace anyone he chooses. These kind of powers are pretty strong and are usually in charge of the Mods, so I can't much see how Yaya's claim is real. The breadcrumb doesn't look like a breadcrumb, but more of someone would actually say that. For all we know, stringers could've been replaced for inactivity (He stopped replying on the 10th of July and he was announced replaced 3 days later). If Yaya did have the power to replace, wouldn't he have replaced him SOONER if he felt Stingers was being a hinderance?
I am unsure what Mentos and Chaco have planned, but if Chaco DOES live to see the next day, I guess we'll know soon.
In either case, I don't mind either a Chaco or Yaya lynch at this point, but I may lean for a Yaya. I still have no idea what Chaco's power role suppose to do and how this may effect town. >> In terms of Florida, I never noticed him coasting, but I'm starting to see that now
Well my only worry is that Mentos is mafia, if it reflects what he thinks it is. It may not be good. Or if it's a protective role, it could just be protecting for N1, so if that's the case I'll make it to D3, scum using me though. That's why I'm kinda iffy about it.
I assure you, I am most definitely not mafia, and remember Chaco, you didn't get anything from Macman, so you're missing one vital part of the role I had in mind earlier that would make it completely safe if I was. If you are a protective role instead of that one, we may very well be on to something here.
vote: chaco for too many reasons. I don't necessarily think he's mafia, but he's made so many mistakes/slips that if he was mafia and we didn't get rid of him now I would be kind of annoyed with not lynching him. I'm still suspicious of mentos, but since it looks like noone will go along with that lynch i'd rather lynch someone than not.
Yeah, I understand that completely. I did make a lot of mistakes and stuff, but not because I'm mafia. I really probably deserve to be lynched because I played this game horribly. Well, I've learned quite a bit now, and with 2 days left if you're gonna do it just do it. If I'm a hindrance to your town then just get rid of me. I had a difficult time adjusting at the beginning, and with how confusing my role is, it's just like...well, ****. But yeah I understand completely. If I had any secrets left to defend myself, I would use them. But I mean, I don't. Right now, I mean it's solely up to you guys. I'm probably going to refrain from posting much more, because i mean it's useless. I've told you all my stuff, and we'll leave it at that.
Marshy you agree that Smashman is suspicious correct, what stuck out to you?
I'm actually ok with a Smashman lynch.