You have not shown me that brawl is not capable of being competitive at all with your statements or comparison
That's not my claim, my claim is that it can never be as competitive as Melee. I really believe that that claim has been demonstrated at this point, most of my points are in summary by M2K.
Yes, Melee has RPS elements, but the whole game isn't like that. Something as simple as landing an attack in Brawl leads to a choice of attacking again or waiting for someone to airdodge out. Everything has a mindgame to it because nothing links, few things are guaranteed.
And the other thing that Melee has by way of competitiveness is that no one can compete with us if they aren't a part of the community. If you have never gone on SWF you basically lose at Melee. I would not bet too much money that some random person with good spacing and timing could come and beat basically anyone in Brawl right now. Not the kind of money I'd bet on M2K in Melee, or even myself for that matter.
I realize that the only difference is a lack of advanced techs but I'm pretty sure we would have found stuff to play with by now if it's there. Not even an advanced tech but something we can manipulate.