Haven't I up-B'd you enough out of shield to know that b-air spam at the edge isn't broken?
LOL you're gay, I'm fairly certain if I just wait after bair #1 you're screwed. I also recall breaking your shield with 6 bairs in Fox vs Peach
They could also shield release->powershield->jab/tilt/whatever with other characters.
<_<
>_>
<_<
I've never seen anyone do that.
Sheik can DS tech the d-smash too.
Jigglypuff can also tech Falcon punch at 321%
http://youtube.com/watch?v=NFxdYCr5yAI data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/eb6e0/eb6e064145cbdfb955861a2bc688e1828c9445e1" alt="Laugh :laugh: :laugh:"
And if they're preparing to tech it you can waveshine them off the stage and then shinespike them because they're not DIing the way they should be to get out of that. Besides, teching anything at the ledge gets you punished anyways.
Eggm said:
The shine combo isn't broken for a ton of reasons, # 1 its hard # 2 you have to get the first shine off # 3 it can be smash DIed out of # 4 sheik can DI the down smash well and land on the stage using a double jump air dodge, or try to swipe at the fox and maybe get him off the edge early, do a tricky up b that seems like they are goin gon the stage then goes to the ledge.
#1 - Waveshining = basic Fox technique. If you play Fox competitively, you can waveshine or you're garbage.
#2 - That's like saying you have to hit your opponent to start a combo
#3 - You can react to that and waveshine dtilt to combo
#4 - Ok, then I can just randomly waveshine them off the stage into a shinespike which gimps her at a low % because my opponent DIing to be able to recover the best possible way from the dsmash. Double jump airdodge onto the stage can be punished. and wtf is this "swipe at the fox and maybe get him off the edge early?"
Possibilities - Sheik DIs the dsmash wrong and has to up B and then you repeat it and she's at too high a % to not get owned by it now.
- Sheik DIs the dsmash correct and still gets sent off the stage and probably has to up b. Maybe if you do it too low she can up with double jump fair, which you can just CC into dsmash or shine spike if you're at low %, but even if you can't I don't see how she's going to hit you off the stage unless you're at high % and it's at the other side.
- Sheik techs the dsmash and gets owned right after it because teching at the ledge = suck.
As for "tricky up b", you can just grab the ledge, stall, and then react. If you see her land then punish, and if she goes for the ledge she dies. Plain and simple. Maybe you won't be able to do that everytime, but she dies at low % if you goes for the ledge and you're still there, and if you don't do it right, she's on the ledge and has to get past spaced back air. Win-win situation.
Scar said:
When you say "spaced, timed bair" that means directly that whoever is using this technique has thought about the game, knows the spacing and timing well, and knows the opponents' options. Waveshining takes a lot of practice.
Yes...knowing my opponent has NO options really requires a lot of thinking. Waveshining = basic Fox technique that any Fox player should be able to do at the very lowest level of competitive melee.
Scar said:
Spam you are awful. Your first point is Inui-ish, I'm going to refer to it as Spam logic.
Scar, YOU are awful. You don't even address
basic facts that I bring up.