The story starts with Yoshi and Ridley getting done with their jobs, and wanting to have dinner with someone. Yoshi goes on a date with Rosalina, while Ridley chooses Samus. However, it turns out that Ridley has had problems with Samus outside of his job too.
Ridley asks Yoshi for advice, and Yoshi simply tells him to offer your date some gifts, and order the same meal as her. Dinnertime then arrives, and coincidentally, Yoshi and Ridley end up having dinner at the same location.
Yoshi and Ridley meet up with their dates, and are surprisingly seated next to each other. Yoshi's date with Rosalina is working perfectly, but Ridley's date with Samus is still quite sour.
Soon, Yoshi offers Rosalina some gifts that she happily accepts, and Ridley decided to follow Yoshi's lead. However, every one of Ridley's gifts to Samus got rejected, leaving him even more disturbed.
Not long after that, the two groups begin to order their meal. Yoshi orders the exact same meal as Rosalina, but with Ridley, he finds out the Samus is ordering a meal that he hates to eat. Reluctantly, he decides to order the same meal as Samus, which briefly manages to get Samus's attention.
Dinner gets served, and as usual, Yoshi and Rosalina are in perfect sync, but with Samus and Ridley, upon taking the first bite of his meal, Ridley feels a painful aftermath. Ridley's painful experience has Samus feeling quite amused, but knowing that he's getting somewhere, Ridley eats his other hated meals.
One after another, each of Ridley's meals leave him in horrendous pain, amusing Samus more and more. Eventually, Ridley collapses while feeling very nauseous. Samus then comments to Ridley that he always looked good while in pain.
Ridley then sees the results with Yoshi's date with Rosalina, and nothing bad ever happened between them. Realizing that Samus only appreciates him while he's feeling pain, Ridley gets very upset that his date will always be sour in one way or another.
The next day, Yoshi encounters Ridley at the hospital, feeling very sick, and asks how his date went. The only comment that Ridley said was "chillingly bad".