K Well i havent had my questions anwsered that actually relate to the topic of this tier list but I'll still post to see if any wants to comment on it.
I in the first place dont completly like how the SBR does there list(They focus on tourney results, when other fighting games create tier list by match-ups)Thats an opinion that im putting forth but what im trying to really get to is I think thatthat the placement of characters and that the tiers misevalueate some characters in the brawl metagame.
Top
Meta Knight
Snake
King Dedede
Mr. Game & Watch
Falco
R.O.B.
High
Marth
Wario
Lucario
(the rest of the "high" tier)
Im only going to be talking about this area of this list so here it goes.
Wario tournament sucess in socal is truly astonishing and has been doing very well at tournaments, futile is ranked #2 in socal for a good reason, his ability to put a great amount of pressure on the opponent with wario's great movepool. That being said, tournament rankings show wario is higher than this list states, so i would like to now why he is put into the high tier instead of the top where he has been doing as well as falco and G&W in tourneis.
Then there's marth, also has a massive amount of good tournament placement and has one of the best general macth-ups this game has(equally if not bettering G&W and falco,and ROB) so why do we have a character that is competing at the same level as G&W Falco and ROB, in a different tier when they have very similar resul;ts in the metagame?
In my opinion the problem with the list is that MK, Sanek and DDD play at a level where that exceeds the competitive mtegame of falco,rob,G&W marth and wario and so the top tier should have been MK,snake and DDD, beacuse of there profusion of tournament placement that is at another level of the falco,ROb,marth G&W wario group. The falco,ROb,marth G&W wario group should be give a tier of their own as the are all below the standard MK,Snake and DDD have put up for brawl and they compete with extremly similar results. The division in the MK, snake DDD tier is obvious now in the metagame and should be recognize by the SBR. That being said the falco,ROb,marth G&W wario group is just slightly below them as the cannot compete at that level of metagame. And so I believe that the top/high tier should have been done this way:
Top
MK
Snake
DDD
High/very high
G&W
Falco
ROB
Marth
Wario
Upper/high
Lucario, DK,Diddy, pika and the rest
That just my opinion as I have looked at all tournament placement list and match-up lists> And I have the consesus of other norcal tourney brawlers such as Cuba is death, so please comment accordingly to my opinion.
Also that powell guy with the stupid brawl>melee comment is just one of the many noobs destroying the already weak brawl metagame, go and search
http://www.youtube.com/user/narutowatcher54, complete noobs ruining youtube with terrible mindgames and no technical skill, this is destroying brawl.