Dang C+ to C-... all the way from E. Basically everything you said except Lucas and Luigi only going up to D right under PT in that order (read and it'll make sense). Plus Kirby moved up to C-, Diddy above Olimar, Falco above Snake, Pit moved up to C+, Ike above DK and Sonic, Ness above Sonic, Peach moved up to C+, Yoshi right under Sonic, PT right under Yoshi, Puff above Samus, Falcon above Bowser, Mario above Bowser but below Falcon, Lucario moved up to B, GW moved up to C+, Wolf moved up to C+, TLink moved down to C.I agree that experimentation is good, but it's that same experimentation that led everyone to figure out that MK trumps everything. Out of curiosity what specifically do you disagree with on the current tier list? Personally I feel that Pika should be in A- and Luigi and Lucas should be somewhere between C+ to C- other than that I pretty much agree with it.
I know I was jumping all over the place with that, just the thoughts that came to my mind came to me in a certain order. The changes aren't drastic, but I would say, as of now, thats how the tier list should be.