FalseFalco
Smash Master
Just wanted to address some things:
Those types of questions can't be answered to the satisfaction of everyone, and are the ones that came up when we made a PR that gave value to friendly matches. In my opinion you simply can't have those situations in an effective PR.
It's all about who you beat, and who you lose to. Only a fool would look at tournament results and pass good judgement on a player based on the number beside their name. The first thing I always ask is "who did ____ lose to". So should you.
also Joel vs Levi money match? It's Joel's call...
kI'm just sick of everyone treating this game like it's ****ing gold
The comparison of both Victor and your consistency in a tournament setting.FastFox said:especially since the power rankings are based solely on tournament placings. Let's say I lose to Victor in the tournament, then we play friendlies and I kick his *** every single time. What, then, justifies the position of myself and Victor on the PR?
And friendlies do? if there is even the tiniest inkling of friendlies affecting the PR, then you have to try to compare the value of a friendly to the value of a tournament match. Are 30 wins straight in friendlies=1 tournament win? 20 wins straight? What if one player simply cannot beat another in a tournament setting no for 5 years straight, but can 4 stock the other in friendlies all day?Alphican said:I also dissagree with the PR based only on tournament placing. Pools or no pools, seeded or not seeded, some times tournaments don't do justice to how good a player actually is
Those types of questions can't be answered to the satisfaction of everyone, and are the ones that came up when we made a PR that gave value to friendly matches. In my opinion you simply can't have those situations in an effective PR.
It makes them "look" exactly how good they areAlphican said:and some times it makes a player look better then they are
It's all about who you beat, and who you lose to. Only a fool would look at tournament results and pass good judgement on a player based on the number beside their name. The first thing I always ask is "who did ____ lose to". So should you.
also Joel vs Levi money match? It's Joel's call...