The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[Diddy Kong]

Buff Diddy, nerf Dedede and Jigglypuff

Would you rather have 3 lost veterans of your choice return, or 3 complete new characters?

 

[Spoon Man the Eleventh]

New characters

Would you rather have things from indie games like Undertale in Smash, or instead have things from classic Nintendo games?

 

[Blargg888]

New characters

Would you rather have things from indie games like Undertale in Smash, or instead have things from classic Nintendo games?

Classic Nintendo Games

Would you rather have a new character that can only use projectiles as a whole, or a new character that can only use command grabs as specials?

 

[baconquistador]

New characters

Would you rather have things from indie games like Undertale in Smash, or instead have things from classic Nintendo games?

Indie games definitely! (Shovel knight, Alex from River City Ransom, etc.)

Would you rather remove Smashville or Town & City from the stage roster?

 

[baconquistador]

Classic Nintendo Games

Would you rather have a new character that can only use projectiles as a whole, or a new character that can only use command grabs as specials?

Projectiles

 

[The Smash Nerd II.0.]

Classic Nintendo Games

Would you rather have a new character that can only use projectiles as a whole, or a new character that can only use command grabs as specials?

Command grabs.

 

[Zerp]

I like Town and City more but I'd remove it because Smashville is definitely the most popular stage in competitive play.

Would you rather bring back the Ice Climbers in Smash 5 but they have all their Brawl chain grabs or bring back Bayonetta but she's exactly like she was in patch 1.1.4?

 

[The Smash Nerd II.0.]

New characters

Would you rather have things from indie games like Undertale in Smash, or instead have things from classic Nintendo games?

Classic Nintendo games

 

[Blargg888]

I like Town and City more but I'd remove it because Smashville is definitely the most popular stage in competitive play.

Would you rather bring back the Ice Climbers in Smash 5 but they have all their Brawl chain grabs or bring back Bayonetta but she's exactly like she was in patch 1.1.4?

Bayonetta 1.1.4, definitely.

Would you rather have the Cracker Launcher return or the Red Shell?

 

[Koopaul]

Cracker Launcher.

Would you rather have 5 old stages return as remastered and updated with better graphics, or 10 old stages return but unchanged.

 

[Diddy Kong]

Give me the 5 old but updated stages. I still dream of a updated Kongo Jungle, Hyrule Castle, Saffron City and Brinstar. Those would be awesome to see in full HD.

In regard of a newcomer for Fire Emblem and Pokemon, would you guys prefer a new face / flavor of the month or a old classic fan favorite?

 

[PeridotGX]

New Face, mostly cause I want Decidueye.

Would you rather have your main cut or Tripping return?

 

[Zerp]

Tripping return.

Would you rather get a new Sonic character or a new Mega Man character?

 

[Spoon Man the Eleventh]

new sonic

Would you rather have Marx playable, or Dark Matter?

 

[Zerp]

Dark Matter all the way.

Would you rather have a menu like Brawl's or Melee's?

 

[Blargg888]

Dark Matter all the way.

Would you rather have a menu like Brawl's or Melee's?

Brawl's. Melee's menu's are alright, but I think Brawl's are a bit nicer.


Would you rather have a newcomer with a faster running speed than Sonic, but lower jump height than Ganon, or a newcomer with a higher jumping height than Falco, but a lower speed than Robin?

 

[Sprite]

2nd option, sonic has to be the fastest.

Would you rather them buff bayonetta again or nerf jigglypuff

 

[biigshaq]

Nerf the Puff.

WYR have no grabs or no Smash attacks?

 

[Blargg888]

Nerf the Puff.

WYR have no grabs or no Smash attacks?

Oof. Uh...

No grabs.


Would you rather have Ridley in the game as a Charizard clone and K Rool with an original moveset, or have Ridley with an original moveset and K Rool as a clone of Bowser?

 

[Freduardo]

Projectiles

You should have posed a question. It’s a game. Please note how it’s played.

Command grabs.

You should have posed a question. It’s a game. Please note how it’s played.

... same for your next post...

(So says thread creator who has made the same mistake and knows it happens)

Oof. Uh...

No grabs.


Would you rather have Ridley in the game as a Charizard clone and K Rool with an original moveset, or have Ridley with an original moveset and K Rool as a clone of Bowser?

Oof, tough one. Guess I’ll take K Rool as a clone of Bowser because I like the moveset more.

Would you rather have Galleom or Duon (those two bosses) from Subspace Emmissary as an assist trophy?

 

[Blargg888]

You should have posed a question. It’s a game. Please note how it’s played.




You should have posed a question. It’s a game. Please note how it’s played.

... same for your next post...

(So says thread creator who has made the same mistake and knows it happens)



Oof, tough one. Guess I’ll take K Rool as a clone of Bowser because I like the moveset more.

Would you rather have Galleom or Duon (those two bosses) from Subspace Emmissary as an assist trophy?

GALLEOM PLEASE.

Duon still gives me war flashbacks. He was my least favorite SSE Boss.

Would you rather permanently cut Mario or Link?

 

[CaptainAmerica]

Well, I'm a Link main, so...

You can still play Mario in MarioKart?

WYR have Icicle Mountain or Rumble Falls return?

 

[Blargg888]

Well, I'm a Link main, so...

You can still play Mario in MarioKart?

WYR have Icicle Mountain or Rumble Falls return?

Icicle Mountain.

Would you rather add Goku to Smash, or add Reggie to Smash?

 

[CannonStreak]

Reggie in Smash.

Would you rather no Mario or no Link if one wasn't going to be in for some reason?

 

[Blargg888]

Reggie in Smash.

Would you rather no Mario or no Link if one wasn't going to be in for some reason?

Deja vu, I've just been in this place befor-

AHEM

Uh... No Link.

Would you rather have a Melee style game with only Smash 4 and Brawl Newcomers, or a Smash 4 style game with only 64 and Melee Newcomers?

 

[CannonStreak]

Melee style with only Smash 4 and Brawl Newcomers.

Would you rather have Smash 64's sound effects or Melee's sound effects.

 

[Blargg888]

Melee style with only Smash 4 and Brawl Newcomers.

Would you rather have Smash 64's sound effects or Melee's sound effects.

64's

Would you rather have Board the Platforms back, or Brawl's Break the Targets?

 

[Garteam]

Board the platforms, only problem is there's a certain boxer who may not have the air mobility to realistically complete this

Would you rather see Square Enix get a new rep or Namco Bandai get a new rep?

 

[Blargg888]

Board the platforms, only problem is there's a certain boxer who may not have the air mobility to realistically complete this

Would you rather see Square Enix get a new rep or Namco Bandai get a new rep?

Square Enix.

Would you rather have 9 clones or 1 completely unique character?

 

[Diddy Kong]

9 clones honestly. I began to appriciate them greatly. If they differ as much as the Melee clones did I'll be content, if the character additions at least feel like good additions at least.

Choose between Robin and Corrin

 

[nirvanafan]

Corrin

Would you rather have a new Pokemon Stadium stage (Stadium 3 or Coliseum) or a Poke Floats 2 stage

 

[Garteam]

Poke Floats 2

Would you rather see Takamaru or Lyn get the upgrade from assist trophy to character?

 

[Thatboyjojo]

Poke Floats 2

Would you rather see Takamaru or Lyn get the upgrade from assist trophy to character?

Lyn
Would you rather see projectile heavy characters get a buff( faster projectile speed, more hitstun , more damage etc) or brawler like characters get a buff ?

 

[Garteam]

Projectile heavy character, they always tend to worse than their physical counterpart

Would you rather see a Zelda newcomer or a Donkey Kong newcomer?

 

[Thatboyjojo]

Projectile heavy character, they always tend to worse than their physical counterpart

Would you rather see a Zelda newcomer or a Donkey Kong newcomer?

definitely donkey kong (dixie or funky) would you rather have lagless aerials or 64 hitstun ? )

 

[Thatboyjojo]

Projectile heavy character, they always tend to worse than their physical counterpart

Would you rather see a Zelda newcomer or a Donkey Kong newcomer?

Donkey kong new comer ( dixie or funky )
Wyr have lagless aerials or all moves( tilts smash attacks specials ) cancel into each other

 

[SneakDuckens]

Lagless Arials.

WYR have Ridley in the game and shrunk to a manageable size or not have Ridley in the game but all other characters are true to size (aka 4 inch Olimar)

 

[Thatboyjojo]

Lagless Arials.

WYR have Ridley in the game and shrunk to a manageable size or not have Ridley in the game but all other characters are true to size (aka 4 inch Olimar)

Shrunken ridley
wyr have lloyd from tales of symphonia with a completely new moveset or issac from golden son

 

[Crazy456Rhino]

Shrunken ridley
wyr have lloyd from tales of symphonia with a completely new moveset or issac from golden son

Issac from Golden Sun, assuming that he gets a completely new moveset as well. If not, then Lloyd.

Would you rather have Young Link return, but with an all new moveset or Snake return, but he's a clone of Link.

 

[Freduardo]

Issac from Golden Sun, assuming that he gets a completely new moveset as well. If not, then Lloyd.

Would you rather have Young Link return, but with an all new moveset or Snake return, but he's a clone of Link.

Young Link return with a new moveset.

Would you rather have DJ Octavio or an Octoling as a second Splatoon character?