The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[Garteam]

Lucario becomes like every other character, I know rage/aura is supposed to be a comeback mechanic, but it always just ensure that leads get larger

Would you rather see Palutena return or an uncloned Dark Pit?

 

[Drawcia]

Lucario becomes like every other character, I know rage/aura is supposed to be a comeback mechanic, but it always just ensure that leads get larger

Would you rather see Palutena return or an uncloned Dark Pit?

Palutena return.
Would you rather have Smash 5 slow and floaty like Brawl, or quick and agile like Melee?

 

[biigshaq]

Like Melee

WYR have tripping come back or swords and the like be able to break?

 

[FamicomDisk]

Tough call, but honestly, I'm going to say tripping! I don't like tripping any more than the next person, but having weaponry break would cripple some characters to uselessness. Marth and Lucina, for example, use swords exclusively. If weapons break, they have nothing to fight with once that happens. Tripping is annoying, but at least it affects everyone - weapons breaking would give characters without weapons a huge advantage.

Would you rather they bring back Mega Man or Pac-Man?

 

[Spatman]

Mega Man

would you like to have the character loved by the biggest majority of people but that you hate, or to have one character you don't mind nor really like but that it's quite hated by many people?

 

[Sprite]

One that I don't mind.

Would you rather smash 5 have a side mode modeled after mario kart or a side mode modeled after mario party?

 

[Murlough]

Mario Party. Smash tour sucks but I can see what they were going for and it has potential. Too bad those dang custom items are a thing and the maps are um....lackluster....at best.

Would you rather remove RNG elements entirely or have a new Subspace Emissary.

 

[HelloImAxel]

Sub space no contest

Would you rather have Wolf or Falco in the game

 

[biigshaq]

Ehh... Wolf for the break.

WYR have most moves have no end lag and tons of start lag, or tons of end lag and no start lag?

 

[SuperDoom1]

No start lag. I mostly play SSB 1v1, and why would I worry about being a sitting duck when the other player is being thrown out the window as we speak?

Would you rather have a thousand characters but half of them are clones, or 20 characters but nobody is a clone?

 

[biigshaq]

1000 but half are clones. That still means 500 new characters.

WYR have all up smashes be like Game and Watches, or none of them?

 

[Freduardo]

No start lag. I mostly play SSB 1v1, and why would I worry about being a sitting duck when the other player is being thrown out the window as we speak?

Would you rather have a thousand characters but half of them are clones, or 20 characters but nobody is a clone?

A thousand characters. 500 clones and 500 unique characters is more than 20.

Edit: I got ninja’d. I’ll take up smashes. Even like game and watch. (What’s wrong with game and watch’s up Smash?)

Would you rather get Ridley playable, or Ridley stays a boss/stage hazard but you get playable Sylux, Dark Samus, and Weavil?

 

[CaptainAmerica]

Playable Riddles. Anything else is ridiculous - you would definitely want Bowser before Wart.

WYR have multiple alternate costumes for all characters (e.g. Wario's two different outfits), or everyone gets one costume with loads of pallette swaps (e.g. what most other characters currently have)

 

[mjwgamer805]

Multiple alternate costumes like Sm4sh Wario, Bowser Jr., Villager, Robin, Corrin

Would you rather oversee all development of characters in Smash 5 or oversee everything else in Smash 5 (modes, menus, stages, trophies, challenges etc.)

 

[HelloImAxel]

I want to oversee the characters
WYR Have Samus or Zerosuit Samus

 

[Zerp]

Samus, it'd be weird if her Power Suit wasn't in the game.

Would you rather know everything right now before everyone else does or wait until the release/leaks?

 

[LoZ00]

Samus, it'd be weird if her Power Suit wasn't in the game.

Would you rather know everything right now before everyone else does or wait until the release/leaks?

Wait untile the release/leaks. I really enjoy speculation.

WYR have 6 new clones or one original newcomer?

 

[biigshaq]

Original newcomer.

WYR have bad staages or bad music?

 

[baconquistador]

Pokeball summon.

Would you rather have to always use Nunchuk but add any character you wanted to the game, or only have characters from the original SSB?

 

[baconquistador]

Original newcomer.

WYR have bad staages or bad music?

Bad music (I'd just play my own w/ earbuds)

Would you rather lose rage or DI as a mechanic?

 

[Zerp]

I'd axe Rage in a heartbeat.

Would you rather get Jirachi or Gardevoir as a Gen 3 Pokemon newcomer?

 

[Accursed]

Gardevoir's pretty rad.

Would you rather axe 3 non-clone characters or remove the option to use Gamecube controllers?

 

[Seen]

I'd have it stay a platform fighter, wouldn't really be smash if it wasn't one.

Would you rather them give all of the clones original move sets, or add in 5 more third party characters.

 

[SuperSonicFlyer]

Five more third party characters.

Would you rather have the trophy store from Smash 4 or Coin Launcher from Brawl?

 

[biigshaq]

Trophy store.

WYR have FD be the only stage or have no trophies at all?

 

[ssbashworld]

Only FD

Would you rather have 8 player smash return with about half the stages being compatible or have a 6 player smash were all stages are compatible

 

[NintenZ]

How about Celica or Alm?

 

[Freduardo]

Only FD

Would you rather have 8 player smash return with about half the stages being compatible or have a 6 player smash were all stages are compatible

8 player return.

How about Celica or Alm?

Celica. But rules, man, answer the last guy’s question.

Anyway: would you rather have ancient minister as a costume/alt for ROB, or as a Luigified clone?

 

[biigshaq]

Luigified clone

No more Captain Falcon or no more Marth?

 

[_Sheik]

No more Captain Falcon.

Would you make the Challenge Grid more like Brawl's or Smash 4's?

 

[Cycrum]

I would make it more like Brawl's.

Would you rather have Turbo Mode or All-Star Versus from Project M?

 

[X1LE]

All star vs

Would you rather have the hyper light drifter or a new smash OC

 

[Accursed]

I'd have it stay a platform fighter, wouldn't really be smash if it wasn't one.

I can't help but wonder why you didn't answer my question.

Would you rather have the hyper light drifter or a new smash OC

Hyper Light Drifter.

Would you rather have another version of Mega Man or another Street Fighter shoto?

 

[Drawcia]

Would you rather have another version of Mega Man or another Street Fighter shoto?

Mega Man

Would you rather have Ridley as a playable character or King K Rool as a playable character?

 

[Diddy Kong]

Easy one, King K.Rool without question.

A DKC newcomer or a Zelda newcomer?

 

[Yokta]

Easy one, King K.Rool without question.

A DKC newcomer or a Zelda newcomer?

Donkey Kong Country has the best monkeys, so add another one of those please.

Would you rather add a newcomer that you're not allowed to play, or be the world's best main of a character you hate?

 

[The Smash Nerd II.0.]

Donkey Kong Country has the best monkeys, so add another one of those please.

Would you rather add a newcomer that you're not allowed to play, or be the world's best main of a character you hate?

That is easy. A new comer you're never allowed to play. One example is Ridley.

 

[Freduardo]

Donkey Kong Country has the best monkeys, so add another one of those please.

Would you rather add a newcomer that you're not allowed to play, or be the world's best main of a character you hate?

Worlds best main of a character I hate. I may not be a fan of Tingle, but if I’m playing him at a pro level, that’s game changing.

Would you rather a separate mode where every character has an associated mount or vehicle or a separate mode where every character has an associated AI sidekick/minion?

 

[biigshaq]

Mount/vehicle

WYR have a good Little Mac Recovery or Bayonetta gone?

 

[Zerp]

Good Little Mac recovery, I don't like cuts and I actually like playing against Bayonetta.

Would you rather buff your main and nerf Jigglypuff + Dedede or nerf your main and buff Jigglypuff + Dedede?