The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[Zerp]

Oh man this is hard, I think I'll go with no ledges though.

Would you rather have Brawl Meta Knight, Smash 4 pre-patch Bayonetta, Smash 64 Pikachu and Melee Fox return completely unnerfed from their primes or get 6 new Fire Emblem characters with zero cuts to the franchise?

 

[Diddy Kong]

6 new Fire Emblem characters. Mostly because of Melee Fox, Bayonetta and Brawl Meta Knight.

A BOTW Champion or Impa?

 

[Sprite]

Impa

Would you rather have custom moves fixed or 2 final smashes

 

[Mafew]

Custom moves fixed

Would you rather have an unfun rep or an unfaithful rep (Characters)

 

[biigshaq]

Unfaithful. Unfun is worse for the series and players

WYR have no more Ike or no more Robin?

 

[Jeck]

That's easy, cut Robin keep Ike. He has a much tighter moveset, plus I'd rather keep the only brawler swordsman than the only spellsword.

All right, would you rather have Master Hand make an evil return or have another brand new boss like Tabuu or the... malevolent black orb thing.

 

[CaptainAmerica]

EDIT: Ninja’d

Master hand is best boss!

All music ported over with no new songs, or all music tossed and completely redone?

 

[Jeck]

Completely redone music. Wait, am I missing something?

Mike Tyson or Shaq.

 

[LoZ00]

Completely redone music. Wait, am I missing something?

Mike Tyson or Shaq.

Mike Tyson. His name is also in the title of the first Punch Out game ever.

WYR no longer have Poké Balls or Assist Trophies?

 

[biigshaq]

Pokeballs but that's because I want the pokemon to end.

WYR have a stupid new character like Miley Cyrus to be added, or have one of your favorite characters nerfed HARD

 

[BlazingFireOmega]

Favorite character nerfed hard.

WYR have the next newcomer be an Anime character or a Deviantart OC?

 

[OctolingRift]

Anime character

Would you rather have a New Pokemon Trainer (Rowlet, Birone, Incineroar) or get the old one back (no stamina bull****)

 

[CaptainAmerica]

OLD ONE!!!! I need my Squirtle and Ivysaur! They were my favorite, and the Stamina mechanic didn't bother me in the slightest. I actually liked learning three kits.

WYR have only one or two newcomers, or a significant number of cuts to make way for 10 or so newbies?

 

[Garteam]

Significant cuts, at least it would give a reason to occasionally come back to Smash 4

Would you rather King Dedede or Meta Knight cut?

 

[biigshaq]

Dedede

WYR have everyone with clone movements (slight variations, and have the game be balanced, or have it really unbalanced and the way it is rn

 

[Depressed Gengar]

Tough question, but unblanaced yet unique. Everyone as a clone would be really boring, balanced or not.

WYR have Bowser's Castle as a stage or Gangplank Galleon as a stage?

 

[Deleted member]

Bring back the real Break The Targets from Melee! Remove Bayonetta.

 

[Sprite]

Tough question, but unblanaced yet unique. Everyone as a clone would be really boring, balanced or not.

WYR have Bowser's Castle as a stage or Gangplank Galleon as a stage?

Both, but gangplank sounds more fun and king K Rool might come with this stage.

Would you rather have Bowser Jr. or Rosalina/Luma cut?

 

[LoZ00]

Both, but gangplank sounds more fun and king K Rool might come with this stage.

Would you rather have Bowser Jr. or Rosalina/Luma cut?

I'd say Rosalina and Luma, as I feel that Bowser Jr. is more relevant. Honestly, I'd like to have both.

WYR have Fountain of Dreams or Smashville as a stage?

 

[Garteam]

Smashville, it was always more important to competitive smash (being the most balanced stage in Smash 4 vs one of the 5 legal stages in melee)

Would you rather see Pokemon Trainer return, or see Squirtle, Ivysaur, and Charizard get their own solo characters?

 

[Sprite]

Pokemon trainer with his issues fixed, so that people don't complain about there being too many Pokémon characters.

Would you rather see wavedashing return or air dodging be cut

 

[biigshaq]

wavedash.

WYR have Smash be the same or more adult oriented like Mortal Combat?

 

[Garteam]

Smash be the same, the darker turn Brawl didn't always mesh well with every franchise

Would you rather have Xander or Ryoma as a Fire Emblem rep?

 

[FamicomDisk]

Hm... I liked Ryoma more than Xander! Initially I said I'd put in Xander, but I'm editing this because I guess he uses swords too, and not spears like I thought. So I'd prefer Ryoma!

Would you rather they bring back Pichu, or add Raichu, a heavier clone of Pikachu with stronger moves but generally less range?

 

[Freduardo]

Hm... I liked Ryoma more than Xander! Initially I said I'd put in Xander, but I'm editing this because I guess he uses swords too, and not spears like I thought. So I'd prefer Ryoma!

Would you rather they bring back Pichu, or add Raichu, a heavier clone of Pikachu with stronger moves but generally less range?

Add Raichu. Sounds fun.

Essentially Same as the last question but would you rather Igglybuff or Wigglytuff as a clone of Jiggles the puff?

 

[DutchPichu]

Wigglytuff as a heavier clone with stronger moves, but less range and she's slower than Jigglypuff.

Would you rather cut Lucas to put Ninten in (with a full original moveset) or Ness to put Ninten in (again, with a full original moveset)?

 

[Garteam]

Cut Lucas, Ness is a little too important to cut and he's kinda the face of the series

Would you rather have Paper Mario with a moveset based on Sticker Star and Colour Splash or Celica but she uses swords exclusively?

 

[Zerp]

I'll go with Paper Mario with Color Splash/Sticker Star just so I can avoid adding more Fire Emblem characters.

Would you rather get Tails or Dr. Eggman as a newcomer?

 

[CaptainAmerica]

Tails. I’ve always liked him better than Sonic anyway.

WYR get no news of Smash until release, or have the full roster leaked early?

 

[Garteam]

Tails, he just feels like he'd fit more than Eggman

Would you rather see Decidueye or Lycanroc?

Edit: Ninja'd

I'd rather just wait until launch, it would keep people talking at the very least

 

[biigshaq]

Decidueye, but I don't know much about 'em.

WYR hate smash 5 and be amazing at it or love it and suck?

 

[Sprite]

Love it and suck, atleast it would be fun.

Would you rather add only Rex or only Pyra

 

[Troykv]

I would rather have Pyra (because I like her design more, even without talking about the buttcracks)

Would you rather have 3 Uninspired new characters from any franchise, or 3 Fire Emblem Characters with fun movesets?

I need more Micaiah love... please.

 

[ssbashworld]

3 Fire Emblem characters

Would you rather an adventure mode or online co-op capabilities for classic, all-star, stadium, events, etc.

 

[LoZ00]

3 Fire Emblem characters

Would you rather an adventure mode or online co-op capabilities for classic, all-star, stadium, events, etc.

An adventure mode. Single player in Smash 4 was really lacking

WYR have a Mario Kart inspired character (fighting in a racing kart) or a Mario Sports character?

 

[Garteam]

Mario Sports character, I can't envision a character stuck in a kart as being fun in all honesty

Would you rather have another Kid Icarus character or another Xenoblade character?

 

[HyperSomari64]

I like Arle Nadja, is my favorite character, but it's extremely annoying!!!!!!

 

[HelloImAxel]

Kid Icarus
would you rather have Lucas and mewtwo or Roy and Cloud

 

[Zerp]

Lucas and Mewtwo, I don't want any of them cut but Mewtwo is just too important for me to cut so I'm going with him.

Would you rather get to design and choose all of the stages for Smash Switch or be in charge of writing it's story and the trailers?

 

[biigshaq]

Story? Smash has almost 0 story. Trailers? I'm not very good at that. Stages? Yes please. #Bridgeofeldinbeststage

WYR have every character be like Lucario with the damage thing, or Lucario become like every other character?