The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[ZagarTulip]

More Sonic

WYR cut or ?

 

[FNUStory]

is more iconic outside of Smash Bros, so .

Would you rather cut or ?

 

[ZagarTulip]

WYR have Nimbleaf, Peyero, Liquiput as a playable character? (These all come from Pokemon Vega)

 

[zeonie888]

Liquiput

WYR have Criketune or Chatot?

 

[NoahAbc12345]

Criketune!

Would you rather have the original eight and the secret four or just the original eight in the base roster?

 

[Frizz]

Original Eight and the Secret Four. That sounds like a movie title.

WYR see the return of Wobbling or the return of edgehogging?

 

[Handy Man]

Original Eight and the Secret Four. That sounds like a movie title.

WYR see the return of Wobbling or the return of edgehogging?

Edgehoging easily. Wobbling is an infinite that can rack up imsane damage with good timing, while edgehogging is a strategy that can lead to KO's. I do not think wobbling is cheap, as it relies on being grabbed and can be avoided, but edgehogging affects all characters instead of just one and defines an aspect of the metagame.

Would you rather see Earthworm Jim as a playable character, or a Battletoad like Rash as a playable character?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Earthworm Jim

WYR make the default outfit for , or make the default outfit for ?

 

[LoZ00]

Earthworm Jim

WYR make the default outfit for , or make the default outfit for ?

Make female Villager the default one. I can’t stand male Wii Fit Trainer

WYR have Ken and Incineroar or Black Knight and Geno as the last two characters

 

[Sari]

Ken and Incineroar

WYR have Geno and Minecraft Steve as the last two characters or Isaac and Skull Kid?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Geno and Steve

WYR have Waluigi revealed through a trailer that heavily teases Geno until a second before the splash screen, where it's revealed "Geno" was Waluigi in a costume, or have him revealed after the AT portion of a direct by Sakurai just saying "speaking of Assist Trophies, Waluigi will be making the jump to playable!", showing off his render and no gameplay?

 

[Manonymous]

Geno and Steve

WYR have Waluigi revealed through a trailer that heavily teases Geno until a second before the splash screen, where it's revealed "Geno" was Waluigi in a costume, or have him revealed after the AT portion of a direct by Sakurai just saying "speaking of Assist Trophies, Waluigi will be making the jump to playable!", showing off his render and no gameplay?

The first one, IT WILL BE SO HILARIOUS XD !

WYR have a Wii Balance Board as a character or Epona ?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Wii Balance Board. I actually wanted WBB before WFT's reveal

WYR have a "drunk cameraman" mode (under a different name of course) or a Ramblin' Evil Mushroom mode?

 

[FirestormNeos]

drunk cameraman

WYR add a mode that brings back tripping OR add a mode that replaces every taunt with dabbing?

 

[ShadowYoshi04]

drunk cameraman

WYR add a mode that brings back tripping OR add a mode that replaces every taunt with dabbing?

Dabbing taunts.

WYR have a Fossil Fighters character be a player character or a vivosaur?

 

[Sari]

Fossil Fighters.

WYR have 2 new Zelda semiclones or 1 new completely unique Zelda character?

 

[WiredRM]

Fossil Fighters.

WYR have 2 new Zelda semiclones or 1 new completely unique Zelda character?

I'll take the two semi-clones, hopefully Impa is one of them.

WYR Have Squad Strike or Smashdown playable online?

 

[Sari]

Definitely Squad Strike

WYR have Mute City (Melee) or Pokefloats return?

 

[ShadowYoshi04]

Definitely Squad Strike

WYR have Mute City (Melee) or Pokefloats return?

Pokefloats

WYR have a new Pikmin character or a new Punch-Out character?

 

[Mogisthelioma]

New Pikmin.

WYR get 5 new Kirby fighters or Geno + Waluigi?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Geno and WAH

WYR have a Fortnite character (do they have names?) or Jazz Jackrabbit?

 

[Deleted member]

A Fortnite character.

Would you rather have Luffy in Smash or Ichigo in Smash?

 

[ZoroCarlos]

A Fortnite character.

Would you rather have Luffy in Smash or Ichigo in Smash?

Luffy. He'd make for a fun character and we don't have any straight up pirates in Smash. (Ridley is a Space Pirate, but nothing about his design yells pirate. K. Rool owns a ship and was Kaptain once, but I consider him more of a king. Toon Link only worked with pirates)

WYR get Bubsy as a playable fighter, or The Noid?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

hard choice, I love both of those characters, but I'd have to go with the Noid due to better moveset potential.

WYR have be Shadow Mario, Tiny Wario, Peachette or Dr. Luigi? either way, they'll be an echo.

 

[FirestormNeos]

Peachette.

WYR (not including characters and stages that have already been announced) have the total stages in Ultimate be 150 with the total number of characters (excluding echoes) is 80 OR the total stages are 120 and the total number of characters (excluding echoes) is 100?

 

[WiredRM]

Peachette.

WYR (not including characters and stages that have already been announced) have the total stages in Ultimate be 150 with the total number of characters (excluding echoes) is 80 OR the total stages are 120 and the total number of characters (excluding echoes) is 100?

100 characters / 120 stages, for sure! 20 characters is certainly worth more than 30 stages to me.

WYR have alternate costumes or new stages as DLC?

 

[TheTrueBrawler]

I couldn't even name 100 characters for Smash Bros, and I think even that is an excessive number considering Echo Fighters are not included. 80 seems like a reasonable number for the Ultimate Smash Bros to be perfectly honest.

Now stages on the other hand I really want more of, and it can help balance out the character to stage ratio from with in franchises. None of that 7:3 crap Fire Emblem brings, or the 4:1 crap Yoshi brings. No offense Zinith .

So I'm going with 150 stages and 80 fighters.

Would you rather have Hector or Viridi as a new fighter?

 

[Mogisthelioma]

Peachette.

WYR (not including characters and stages that have already been announced) have the total stages in Ultimate be 150 with the total number of characters (excluding echoes) is 80 OR the total stages are 120 and the total number of characters (excluding echoes) is 100?

100 fighters/120 stages
Viridi over Hector
New stages

WYR Get Lanky Kong or Slippy (from Star Fox)?

 

[TheTrueBrawler]

Three people originally did the same one? Wow.

Well for the one above mine, I pick Slippy. Hopefully it's still above mine when this is posted.

Would you rather have Crash Bandicoot, or Rayman?

 

[ZagarTulip]

CRASH!!!

WYR have Raiden or Shadow playable?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Raiden.

WYR have Ms. Pac-Man as a Pac-Man semi-clone with different fruit, or Tails as a Sonic semi-clone with a different Up-B?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Tails as a Sonic semi-clone with a different Up-B

Which stage WYR this song play on? Midgar, Bridge of Eldin OR Norfair?

 

[WiredRM]

Tails as a Sonic semi-clone with a different Up-B

Which stage WYR this song play on? Midgar, Bridge of Eldin OR Norfair?

What a random song, lol. I'd pick Midgar, as it only has 2 music tracks on it.

Would you rather be able to toggle which assist trophies appear in a menu, or have the stronger ones separated into a separate item like the Master Ball for Pokemon?

 

[FirestormNeos]

assist toggle.

WYR have a vocal theme made for smash that's super edgy OR super memey?

 

[Mogisthelioma]

assist toggle.

WYR have a vocal theme made for smash that's super edgy OR super memey?

Super Memey

WYR get the 30th anniversary orchestras for Zelda and Kirby as part of the soundtrack OR get parts of the Batman: Arkham soundtrack in Smash?

 

[Room100]

Super Memey

WYR get the 30th anniversary orchestras for Zelda and Kirby as part of the soundtrack OR get parts of the Batman: Arkham soundtrack in Smash?

30th Anniversaries!

WYR have just Break the Targets come back but each fighter gets their own tailored stage, or have BtT/Board the Platforms/Race to the Finish come back but only have 1-3 variants?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

just BTT. I love Race to the Finish, but Board the Platforms is hell.

WYR have this song play on Fire Emblem stages, Final Fantasy stages or Zelda stages?

 

[Frizz]

Final Fantasy stages. They said they needed more songs, right?

WYR have the audience more involved in matches (i.e. have them throw tomatoes/stones at their least favorite fighter, give their most favorite fighter beneficial items, etc.) or play Super Smash Bros. in First Person/Virtual Reality?

 

[WiredRM]

Final Fantasy stages. They said they needed more songs, right?

WYR have the audience more involved in matches (i.e. have them throw tomatoes/stones at their least favorite fighter, give their most favorite fighter beneficial items, etc.) or play Super Smash Bros. in First Person/Virtual Reality?

I'd pick audience involvement, if only for the fact that Game & Watch would be OP in First Person. You wouldn't be able to see him!

WYR have matchmaking based on player performance on For Glory, or have tournaments, Squad Strike and Smashdown playable online?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

the prior.

WYR have a bigger emphasis on 3rd parties (with a notable amount of new Sonic characters), or a bigger emphasis on obscure Nintendo series? (StarTropics, Drill Dozer, Mole Mania, e.t.c.)