The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[Pippin (Peregrin Took)]

Isaac

WYR have Goku and Vegeta costumes for Pit and Dark Pit or Gandalf (Lord of the Rings) as an echo fighter for Palutena?

 

[zeonie888]

Goku and Vegeta costumes for Pit and Dark Pit

WYR have the return of Pac Maze or new Pac Man stage?

 

[King Sonnn DeDeDoo]

Pac Maze, it’s a perfect stage to represent Pac-Man

WYR have Liquid Snake or The Boss as an echo for Snake?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Liquid Snake

WYR have Raichu and Alolan Raichu added to round off the Pikachu Line OR have a fourth version of Link playable?

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

fourth version of Link(Wolf Link) with an actually distinct moveset

WYR have Rayquaza or Suicune playable?

 

[R.O.B.]

Suicune because Rayquaza (unlike Ridley) is too BIG.

Would you rather have Professor Hector or Professor Vector as playable character?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Professor Hector

WYR have Ashley's wand (Red) as an item that temporarily transforms characters into usable items that only appears in 3 or more player matches, or the Wario Bomb as an item that obviously, goes 3, 2, 1 as it's about to explode?

 

[FirestormNeos]

Ashley's wand. That sounds hilarious.

I meant during Smash 3DS/Wii U...

Oh. I'll stick by my answer with Pac-Man and Mega Man swapping roles.

WYR Duff McWhalen from X5 as an assist trophy OR Green Biker Dude from X2 as an assist trophy?

 

[zeonie888]

Green Biker Dude... But he'll more likely be K.O'ed after a few hits

Would you rather have Ariados or Galvantula as a pokeball summon?

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

Galvantula

WYR have Zeke or Melia as a assist trophy?

 

[Screams in B-Minor]

Melia

WYR have your favorite character:

1. Be presented with none of the moves, personality or even look that made them iconic.
2. Be accurately portrayed in look, moveset and taunts, but given a voice so bad you have to mute the TV whenever they show up.

 

[PeridotGX]

Melia

WYR have your favorite character:

1. Be presented with none of the moves, personality or even look that made them iconic.
2. Be accurately portrayed in look, moveset and taunts, but given a voice so bad you have to mute the TV whenever they show up.

2. Between Dedede and Meta Knight, I think it's actually better when Kirby characters have out of place voices.

Would you rather have a Pokémon Spinoff character or a Mario spinoff character?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Pokémon Spinoff because those games deserve more representation

WYR have Agumon or Shadow the Hedgehog?

 

[ZTurtle]

Agumon, I'd love for Digimon to get some major recognition.

WYR have Captain Falcon or Ness be cut?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Ness Cut

WYR have Smash Run or Subspace Emissary in Smash Ultimate?

 

[XxCzardxX]

I'd rather have Smash Run back.

Would you rather have Smash Ultimate have an engine great for both casual and competitive play, but be filled with obnoxious micro-transactions and a horribly slow loot-crate system necessary to unlock characters and stages (unless you pay up), or have the game's engine and roster balance be identical to Brawl's?

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

I will play weeks out of the game, if I have to wait until I get my chars its not that terrible

WYR have a second Pokemon Trainer char(but with 3 totally different mons) or 25 new Pokeball-Pokemon?

 

[osby]

New Powell, there is no reason to make Trainer less special.
WYR have a new mode with Nintendo worlds or more stages with that locations?

 

[FirestormNeos]

More stages with that/those location/s. The Second One. Grammar kinda confusing here, but more stages is always welcome.

WYR 15+ Echo Fighters of your choice released over the course of several months as free DLC, or 3 random third-party newcomers as paid DLC?

Melia

WYR have your favorite character:

1. Be presented with none of the moves, personality or even look that made them iconic.
2. Be accurately portrayed in look, moveset and taunts, but given a voice so bad you have to mute the TV whenever they show up.

So... having to choose between Samus winding up either like Donte or like Smash 4 Fox? In that case, I'd go with... crap, this one's actually really hard.

I'd rather have Smash Run back.

Would you rather have Smash Ultimate have an engine great for both casual and competitive play, but be filled with obnoxious micro-transactions and a horribly slow loot-crate system necessary to unlock characters and stages (unless you pay up), or have the game's engine and roster balance be identical to Brawl's?

Spoiler: >mfw micro-transactions and lootboxes in a Smash game

I'll take gameplay balance ten times worse than Brawl's if it means keeping that AAA crap away from Nintendo.

 

[Screams in B-Minor]

3 random third party newcomers
Quality over quantity.

WYR have a new fighter from the CDi Zelda games or the Super Mario Bros. movie.

 

[osby]

Super Mario Bros
WYR have a story mode with Smash Run's gameplay or not one at all?

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

story mode with Smash Run's gameplay

WYR have Goku playable or have 2 less fighter?

 

[ZoroCarlos]

Have Goku playable.

WYR have Heihachi AND Nightmare (2 new Namco reps) or Sora and Geno (2 new Square reps)

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

Sora and Geno

WYR have Dragonite or Zoroark playable(both Pokemon)?

 

[zeonie888]

Dragonite

WYR have the return of Raikou or the return of Zapdos? (pokeball/masterball item)

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

Raikou

WYR have Hydreigon Kommo-o as a pokeball-mon?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Hydreigon

Would you rather have a Disney Movie Rep or a DreamWorks Movie Rep?

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

Disney Movie Rep, as long as something like Marvel counts

WYR have a Star Wars or a Frozen rep?

 

[Brindor]

Star Wars all the way baby

WYR cut Jigglypuff and have a new Pokemon rep of your choice or keep her and no new Pokemon rep

 

[The Jim Jims]

HM01 Cut her for Decidueye

WYR have a super weird character like Wii Fit Trainer revealed next or a super hyped up and requested character like King K. Rool next?

 

[FirestormNeos]

Super weird.

When you get Smash Ultimate at the store, WYR the game case be put in a paper or plastic bag?

 

[ZoroCarlos]

My answer would be no bag, but i'd rather plastic.

In a scenario where Banjo-Kazooie are put into Smash, and Microsoft allows one more Rare character, WYR have Conker or Battletoads

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

Conker, no question

WYR have Wario be cut for Waluigi or let it stay like it is?

 

[FirestormNeos]

Keep as is. Waluigi will get his turn in the sun one day, but not at the expense of another.

WYR be stuck with a Metal Gear Survive rep OR a Sonic 06 rep?

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

Metal Gear Survive

WYR have Hector or Lyn playable(both from FE7)?

 

[ZTurtle]

Probably Lyn.

WYR have one of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles or Batman as a playable character?

 

[FirestormNeos]

Batman. I already lose enough sleep from OCDing over the Pokemon reps. I don't want to develop outright insomnia because they put in the purple one over the orange one or something.

WYR Bob Ross OR Mr. Rogers as a commentator over fights (with option to toggle the commentary on/off)?

 

[KirbyWorshipper2465]

Bob Ross. The idea of him talking about the Inklings would have been inherently funny.

Given the choice, WYR Krystal as the only new Star Fox rep or Miyu and Fay as Echoes of the current representatives?

 

[zeonie888]

I think it would interesting to see Miyu and Fay

Would you rather have another explosive item or another trapping item?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Another Trapping Item

WYR have Sora or Shadow the Hedgehog playable?