The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[osby]

Sora.

WYR have no new Kid Icarus fighter or no new Fire Emblem character?

 

[ZagarTulip]

No New Kid Icarus, Kid Icarus is much smaller as a series than fire emblem. MUCH SMALLER

WYR have Crash Bandicoot or Banjo and Kazooie?

 

[ZTurtle]

Crash. Barely played Banjo Kazooie, so I don't really have much of a connection to them.

Would you rather Bayonetta's Witch Time be extended even further or have Brawl Meta Knight return and be just as OP?

 

[ZoroCarlos]

Sora.

Edit: oops, half awake, replied to the wrong person.

I'd rather extend Bayo's witch time tbh.

WYR have Young Link's final smash drop the moon on the stage or use the Fierce Deity Mask?

 

[ZTurtle]

Fierce Diety mask. Young Link dropping the moon would be kind of weird since that's what he's trying to prevent throughout Majora's Mask...

WYR have Pokemon Trainer retain the switching mechanic in the future, or for Charizard, Squirtle, and Ivysaur to become separate characters with their own Down-Bs with the Pokemon Trainer himself becoming purely a background element?

 

[ShadowYoshi04]

Seperate Characters.

WYR have a new Pokémon Trainer with any 3 starters of your choice (still following the types and first/middle/final evo) OR have Ash Ketchum with Charizard, Sceptile, and Greninja (Greninja is not seperate and the Kanto Trainer is cut)?

 

[TotallyToasted]

Pokemon Trainer with any 3 starters of your choice.

WYR put the Avengers into Smash or the Justice League?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Ash Ketchum with Charizard, Sceptile, and Greninja
EDIT--- Avengers

WYR have Sephiroth or Black Mage as a second Final Fantasy Rep?

 

[ZoroCarlos]

Sephiroth = One Winged Angel as Smash music.

WYR have Classic mode from the first few Smash games back, or have classic mode from Smash 4 back in Ultimate.

 

[zeonie888]

Classic mode from the first three smash

WYR have a Turbo mode or an mode where you choose characters for each stock?

 

[FirestormNeos]

choose characters for each stock.

WYR M. Bison Bonus Boss when you clear Classic Mode as Ryu on a tuesday OR Luman Sage Bonus Boss when you clear Classic Mode as Bayonetta while holding the Switch upsidedown?

 

[WallyPalmer]

Luman Sage because I want to punish myself.

WYR have your pick of 6 newcomer characters but the only new stage is the minecraft lava texture over and over OR pick any number of new stages to come in but the only newcomer is Minecraft Steve

 

[ZagarTulip]

pick any number of new stages (8) to come in but the only newcomer is Minecraft Steve

WYR have a Goomba or Slime from Dragon Quest as Playable?

 

[BonafideFella]

Slime has better potential in my eyes.

WYR have Sukapon or Jill Dozer as a playable character, assist trophy contradictions aside?

 

[ZoroCarlos]

Since Rayman is my most wanted, I feel like Sukapon would be redundant.
I'll go with Jill, besides, I can make Gurren Lagann puns with her.

WYR have Gray Fox back as an assist trophy for Metal Gear, or would you replace him with Raiden with his MGR design.

 

[ZagarTulip]

Gray Fox

WYR have Petey Piranha and Birdo added together OR Toadette and King Boo added together?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Birdo and Petey. I like Toadette but her without Toad would just be weird

WYR have Muddy Mole from Mole Mania playable while Jill from Drill Dozer is an AT, or vice versa?

 

[ZagarTulip]

I would honestly love Muddy Mole playable, I'd be fine if Jill was an AT anyways

WYR have a second Final Fantasy Character or a second Sonic Character?

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

second Final Fantasy Character, obviously

WYR have a second Mega-Man or a second Animal Crossing rep?

 

[osby]

Second AC character would be welcome?

WYR have no cuts or more cuts?

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

no cuts

WYR have Ephraim or Bandana-Dee?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Personally Ephraim

Wyr have more Square Enix Characters or more Namco characters?

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

Namco , just for the possibility of KOS-MOS

WYR have Pichu or Young Link be cut?

 

[osby]

Pichu, though I want both to stay.
WYR make Lyn or Waluigi playable?

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

Lyn has more Moveset potential,, but Memes, so Waluigi

WYR have Lycanroc-Day or Lycanroc-Dusk playable?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Lycanroc-Day

WYR have Shantae or Dixie Kong for a playable fighter that attacks with their hair?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Dixie.

WYR have Waluigi added to Smash with fan input a la the Ballot on the moveset but without a surprise reveal or trailer, just a showcase posted out of nowhere with the chosen moves, or Waluigi be revealed exactly a day before release with a moveset chosen entirely by the Smash team?

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

revealed exactly a day before release with a moveset chosen entirely by the Smash team

WYR have 5 new XC or 6 new FE reps(4 of them being from Fates and Awakening)?

 

[ZoroCarlos]

5 new XC. Zeke, Morag, Malos, Elma and Reyn.

WYR have online lagless 8-player smash, or have an option to set up your own tourney brackets with your own rules.

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

online lagless 8-player smash

WYR have Squall or Tidus as a new FF rep?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Squall.

WYR have the Stork, Kamek or Woolly Yoshi as a second Yoshi rep?

 

[Zinith]

Woolly Yoshi, because Yoshi

WYR have a playable Neil Breen or Tommy Wiseau

 

[Gallerian]

Tommy Wiseau, for his lines would be amazing to hear in Smash Bros.

WYR More newcomers to the series or revamped veterans to make them reflect more current games?

 

[zeonie888]

newcomers to the series please

WYR have more boxes with different traps in them or more types of item containers?

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

more boxes with different traps

WYR have more weapons as items(like the Homerund Bat) or more powerups(like the Tanuuki Tail)?

 

[FirestormNeos]

weapons.

WYR Keep the roster as is OR Captain Falcon is cut from the roster, but in exchange, a new F-Zero game is made for the Switch and it turns out to be really good?

 

[osby]

Keep the roster, we don't really need a new game after GX.
WYR have a new Ice Climbers or a new R.O.B. game?

 

[Hydra of Chaos]

Ice Climbers, cause that was an actual game

WYR have Magearna or Diancie as a new Pokemon rep?

 

[King Sonnn DeDeDoo]

Magearna, I think the clockwork motif is kinda cool

WYR have DK have his voice from the Donkey Kong Country cartoon series or King Dedede have his voice from Kirby right back at ya?

 

[FirestormNeos]

King Dedede's southern accent In a Smash game--? yes please thank you very much.

WYR MGS2 Raiden as an echo fighter for Snake OR Blaze as an echo fighter for Sonic?