SWF member voted tier list

[Barge]

ddd +1
olimar + 1

 

[Rawnie]

Lucario -1
Sonic -1
Diddy+1
Marth +1
Samus +1

 

[Super_Sonic8677]

G&W+1
Mk+1
Sonic+1
Bowser -1
Lucario -1

 

[deepseadiva]

King Dedede +1
Olimar +1
Ike +1

Bowser -1
Sheik -1

This is actually starting to shape up. :D

Dedede and Ike seem a tad too low though, as well as Olimar who needs to move up one or two tiers. Bowser and Sheik look slightly misplaced.

 

[Allin]

Marth +1, Lucario +1, ZSS+1, R.OB -1

 

[Thiago26792]

Link +1
Jigglypùff -1

 

[Amazing Ampharos]

How fun. There's no harm I guess.

Mr. Game & Watch: +1
Pikachu: +1
Toon Link: +1
Ness: +1
Mario: -1

As an aside, Zelda/Sheik is one character. Why do you list her as two?

 

[KarateF22]

Lucario +1
Ice climbers +1
Marth +1
Kirby -1
Pit -1

 

[Browny]

yay for activity :D

Im gonna reformat the list... Just so people dont think there are actually ranks within divisions. should look better overall and would allow this to form quicker i think. updated too

---

woops i forgot im going out now lol... cant finish the update. plz no one post till i get back in 2 hours, the current list is all messy lol ill fix it soon >_<

 

[Red Arremer]

w00t, the staffs join. <3

Also, djbrowny, can you maybe exchange the non-Brawl character smileys with their actual ones? Such as Samus or Bowser. XD

As an aside, Zelda/Sheik is one character. Why do you list her as two?

I partially agree. I personally think Zelda, Sheik and Zelda/Sheik should be 3 entries.

Here is an essay and a discussion about why there should be 3 entries for them:
http://www.smashboards.com/showthread.php?t=226311

 

[Denzi]

-smacks head-
Ignore this post.

 

[Red Arremer]

Please take this part of djbrowny's post into account, Denzi. :3

woops i forgot im going out now lol... cant finish the update. plz no one post till i get back in 2 hours, the current list is all messy lol ill fix it soon >_<

 

[Browny]

ok i fixed it... and i seriously need to find out whats going on the the bowser and samus icons. its so weird.

i can type and and here and it works perfectly but it wont work in the OP wtf

lol so I just took a screenshot of this post and C&P'd the image into the OP until i find a real fix hahaha


WHY WONT IT WORK

 

[Teran]

Sonic +1
Pikachu +1
Fox +1
ROB +1

Lucario -1

 

[Amazing Ampharos]

So I take it we're supposed to vote again every time you update? Also, you use the wrong Pikachu in the OP; it's not his Brawl head like the others.

Anyway...

Toon Link +1
Olimar +1
Jigglypuff +1
Meta Knight -1
Fox -1

 

[Red Arremer]

Hence I said "such as" ... XD Kirby is part of that, too.

Tier List needs moar

Kirby +1
ROB +1
Pit +1
Wario +1

Fox -1

 

[Teran]

So I take it we're supposed to vote again every time you update? Also, you use the wrong Pikachu in the OP; it's not his Brawl head like the others.

Anyway...

Toon Link +1
Olimar +1
Jigglypuff +1
Meta Knight -1
Fox -1

Hence I said "such as" ... XD Kirby is part of that, too.

Tier List needs moar

Kirby +1
ROB +1
Pit +1
Wario +1

Fox -1

Counteraction ftl.

XD

 

[Red Arremer]

Fox is definitely not better than Wolf, and he isn't even better than Bowser or Ike. >_<

 

[Teran]

Perhaps I should show you teh Fox one day huh Spade?

 

[Red Arremer]

lol, that doesn't mean much to me. XD

In skilled hands, every character is good, but I know Fox is not better than Wolf.

 

[Teran]

True, but then someone should bump Wolf up.

I just don't have a very high opinion of Wolf lol. =\

 

[Red Arremer]

Wolf is pretty spot on where he is, but Fox isn't XD

 

[Teran]

We need to bump down that pesky Ness if anything. I overlooked him. =\

 

[Amazing Ampharos]

Ness is about right. I think we were right to single out Fox in that group.

 

[Teran]

It makes no difference what you think, fiend. Hopefully justice will prevail in the end.

 

[:034:]

So, like this?

Kirby +1
Olimar +1
Wolf +1
Bowser +1
Ness -1

 

[dancingfrogman]

Zelda + 1
R.O.B + 1
Bowser + 1

Fox - 1
Lucario - 1

EDIT: I'm for the extra Zelda/Shiek character in teh listz

 

[Browny]

@ dutchman, yep

I partially agree. I personally think Zelda, Sheik and Zelda/Sheik should be 3 entries.

Here is an essay and a discussion about why there should be 3 entries for them:
http://www.smashboards.com/showthread.php?t=226311

Hmmm, maybe ill add that as a separate char at a later stage. Ill ask now... If many people want that, I'll do it.

So I take it we're supposed to vote again every time you update?

That wasnt meant to be the plan, it depends on how active this thread gets. i didnt want people voting multiple times per day. but as long as i dont see 3 lots of 5 votes on the same day which seem to be on a mission to rapidly drop one certain chars to the bottom and a few to the top, it should be fine

 

[The_Blue_Bomber]

ROB +1
Ness +1
Fox +1

Yoshi -1
Luigi -1

 

[MysticKenji]

Snake +1
Wario +1
ROB +1

Link -1

 

[Super_Sonic8677]

MK +1
Wario +1
Rob+1
Jiggz+1
Bowser -1

 

[Kinzer]

So I take it we're supposed to vote again every time you update? Also, you use the wrong Pikachu in the OP; it's not his Brawl head like the others.

It probably would be best to wait 24 hours before you make another bump, just to be safe.

Speaking of which, I'm overdue...

Snake +1
LOLimar +1

Shiek -1
Meta Knight -1

 

[Bowser King]

Bowser+1
Wario+1

Shiek-1
Fox-1
Ness-1

-Bowser King

 

[Browny]

mmm updating.... my votes btw
wolf, pit +
zss -1

 

[Amazing Ampharos]

An update, how fun.

Mr. Game & Watch +1
Marth +1
Olimar +1
Meta Knight -1
Bowser -1

For those who think I'm crazy with my minus votes to Meta Knight, I'm just trying to keep him with the other top tiers.

 

[deepseadiva]

Wario +1
ROB +1
Peach +1

Wolf -1
Pit -1

Just some minor adjustments. I like the little Zelda/Sheik portmanteau thingy.

 

[Red Arremer]

I like the little Zelda/Sheik portmanteau thingy.

Thankoo. :3

Peach +1
Zelda/Sheik +1
Sheik +1
ROB +1

Sonic -1

 

[Browny]

yeah lol @ MK being a whole 2 ranks above everyone else

dont be hesitant to bring other characters up to fill the void instead of dropping MK down, since in the end its highly likely MK will be on like, 25 before the fluctuations within the rest of the list begin to slow down lol

 

[FTWin]

Mario +1
Lucas +1
Marth -1
PT -1
Sonic -1

 

[Man of Popsicle]

Ness +1
Bowser -1