Super smash Kart? Would it work?

[Trapt497]

"Would it Work?"

No. Bad idea. 'Nuff said.

 

[Chagen46]

I actually have ANOTHER idea, but this would be met with even more laughs.


Should I tell you guys anyway?

 

[roy_owns]

Sure, go ahead.

 

[retro gamer 6]

that would be cool if it did work. kirby would be on his warpstar. bowser on his clown ship. link on epona? lol.

 

[Chagen46]

My OTHER idea for a wierd Brawl spin-off:


A Super-smash bros. RPG.


For the DS.


Go ahead, Laugh.


EDIT: I could tell how the combat, Items, and moves work into the turn-based battling.

I like this idea.....

Of course, I also like the Super Smash Kart idea.

Hey, Thanks!

I somewhat like the idea of an Smash Bros RPG however simply because having character development and a genuine plot in Smash Bros would definately be interesting and completely worth it if it was done right.

Thanks to you too!

 

[Bowser King]

Aren't fox, kirby, zelda and pikachu apearing in SMS (super mario sluggers)? Then mabye a FEW characters (max 7) will apear but not all of them. A seperate game just wouldnt work well IMO.

 

[blooagga]

No it would just turn into super wavedash kart.

 

[notftomearth7]

It'd be weird sure, but it would be great. Think about the variations of tracks, karts, and items we'd see. And NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO Double Kart stuff!

 

[The Real Gamer]

Don't know about you but I can't picture Game and Watch driving a kart... Not a bad idea though.

 

[retro gamer 6]

It would probably work better than the new Mario-Kart, which is awful, honestly the N64 version is far better.

hey i agree, MK64 was an awesome game. but mario kart double dash and DS was fun as well. the only thing i didn't like about MKDD was the specific character items. like the loads of time i lost to toad because of his stupid golden mushroom (although i loved the chain chomp, i really wish they kept that in MK Wii). and i'm surprised MK Wii nearly has no lag online, which makes me wished that brawl was like that. but 64 was fun, no doubt. i loved playing as yoshi in that game! ^_^

 

[JawaJedi]

I'd buy it the second it was put on the shelf.

 

[Chagen46]

I'd buy it the second it was put on the shelf.

I can sense sarcasm....

But, if you actually are telling the truth, thanks for supporting the Idea!

 

[Banjodorf]

My OTHER idea for a wierd Brawl spin-off:


A Super-smash bros. RPG.


For the DS.


Go ahead, Laugh.


EDIT: I could tell how the combat, Items, and moves work into the turn-based battling.

I like this idea.....

Of course, I also like the Super Smash Kart idea.

 

[Puffs]

Super Landmaster Kart

It involves a bunch of tiny landmasters driving landmasters on giant landmaster-shaped tracks.

 

[Magnacor]

My OTHER idea for a wierd Brawl spin-off:


A Super-smash bros. RPG.


For the DS.


Go ahead, Laugh.


EDIT: I could tell how the combat, Items, and moves work into the turn-based battling.



Hey, Thanks!

Seriously, I wouldn't buy that one. RPG's usually involve a plot and when there's only a limited amount of non-silent antagonists, they would run into some trouble.

Super Landmaster Kart

It involves a bunch of tiny landmasters driving landmasters on giant landmaster-shaped tracks.

XD Nice. And when you get a mushroom you'll be using a a boost to get through. Then you do a barrel roll. And that's the whole game.

 

[Chagen46]

Seriously, I wouldn't buy that one. RPG's usually involve a plot and when there's only a limited amount of non-silent antagonists, they would run into some trouble. .

They would just all the characters talk.


Even Link and Mario....

 

[OverlordCrono]

Would it work? I honestly doubt it. Do I like the idea anyway? You bet you behind I do. Sonic would easily decimate the rest though, unless he rode on those Ex-Gear boards from his Riders games.

 

[Fatmanonice]

Remembering the last racing game Sakurai worked on (Kirby's Air ride) I'd run like hell away from it.

It definately wasn't that bad. Probably one of the more underrated Nintendo games of that generation behind the Pikmin games.

Regarding this idea, it would pretty much kill the franchise. I somewhat like the idea of an Smash Bros RPG however simply because having character development and a genuine plot in Smash Bros would definately be interesting and completely worth it if it was done right.

 

[Tristan Fattest of All Kids]

Put snaking back in, and I will be okay

 

[Chagen46]

. However, I personally would prefer Super Smash Strikers Soccer. That's just me though.

Heh,heh, That would be cool.

 

[pirkid]

Ahh.
Smash RPG, I'm looking at it like Mario RPG. It just might be epic enough, but would never happen.

 

[Grunt]

Ahh.
Smash RPG, I'm looking at it like Mario RPG. It just might be epic enough, but would never happen.

Capt.F used FALCON PAUNCH!
It's super effective!

 

[Chagen46]

Capt.F used FALCON PAUNCH!
It's super effective!

The falcon punch would have a base damage of 100, have a 30% chance of burning the opponent, and, it requires one turn to charge up.

 

[Mewter]

Yeah, and maybe a small chance of stun/flinch(10% chance)

 

[Grunt]

The falcon punch would have a base damage of 100, have a 30% chance of burning the opponent, and, it requires one turn to charge up.

Capt.F is taking in Manliness!

 

[acv]

super smash kart wouldnt work because capt. falcon would roundhouse kick FALCON PUNCH everyone to the finish line.

 

[smashbot226]

Smash Racing?

Lovely!
Rides:

Mario: Wing Cap

DK: Rambi

Link: Epona

Samus: Miniature Airship

Yoshi: Poochy

Kirby: Warp Star

Fox: Miniature Landmaster

Pikachu: Pidgeot

Lucas: Mecha Drago

Bowser: Koopa Clown Car

Olimar: Miniature Hocotate Freight Ship

Jigglypuff: Donphan

Captain Falcon: Blue Falcon

Ness: Mr. Saturn's Coffee Table

Luigi: E. Gadd Booster Mobile

Peach: Umbrella Mobile

Zelda: Farore's Wind? IDK...

Ice Climbers: Pterodactyl

Ganondorf: Beast Ganon Transformation

MGNW: LCD Kart

Falco: Mini Arwing

Everybody I CAN name so far...

 

[smashbrotherssuckballs_halorocks]

hey i agree, MK64 was an awesome game. but mario kart double dash and DS was fun as well. the only thing i didn't like about MKDD was the specific character items. like the loads of time i lost to toad because of his stupid golden mushroom (although i loved the chain chomp, i really wish they kept that in MK Wii). and i'm surprised MK Wii nearly has no lag online, which makes me wihed that brawl was like that. but 64 was fun, no doubt. i loved playing as yoshi in that game! ^_^

THAT IS so true i feel the exact same way, i wish that KIRBY wouldve been in mario kart because if he had been in MK he would have driven a giant vaccum cleaner and sucked and blown every car and character on the track

 

[Firus]

WHAT?


I liked 64. Alot. But I fail to see what factor makes it superior to Double Dash and MKDS, and MK Wii.


MK Wii has an AMAZING online with no lag, you can race with 12, it actually has unlockable characters, etc.

Mk64 - It was hella fun, but it had - No unlockable characters

Only 16 stages (It wasnt the original, they could have used SNES stages

No CPUs in versus


etc. etc.

What makes it so amazing? (Besides the rainbow road music)

Sonic the Hedgehog:

Had only one storyline. No extra characters to play with, no extra missions.

Only 6 Zones, a total of 18 Acts.

No Versus mode at all.

It still epically wins over every new Sonic game.

As for the thread itself, I have thought about this multiple times. If they're going to make games like this, I'm not going to buy more than 2 or 3 with just Mario characters. With characters that I actually like (Yes, I dislike Mario characters, sue me) it would definitely make it more likely that I'd buy the game.

On the other hand, though...it would pain me to see poor Samus, Link, and other awesome characters entering the universe of games like Mario Party. Smash should be the exception to Nintendo characters coming together like that. I wouldn't complain if it happened, and would probably buy it, just saying that at the moment I don't like the idea a whole lot.

 

[Storm Eagle]

Samus should totally ride on Ridley.

 

[Deleted member]

Ike: I ride for my friends.

O_o

Anyway, it COULD work, but I'd never want to see it outside of a fangame. I don't want Smash milked to death, that kills franchises.

 

[feardragon64]

Wouldn't this be a bit rigged?

I mean, having an EXPERIENCED racer race against a bunch of random people with no racing experience. The person with the closest experience are the space animals. Lol

 

[Martham112]

Mario has racing experience! As does Luigi, Peach, Yoshi, Bowser, DK and Diddy from Mario Kart. Kirby, Dedede, not sure about Metaknight, were in Kirby's Air Ride, Captain Falcon has F-Zero. Pikachu and Jigglypuff had Pokémon Dash for the DS. Sonic had Sonic R or whatever.

Plenty of experience there.

 

[smashbro29]

Aren't fox, kirby, zelda and pikachu apearing in SMS (super mario sluggers)? Then mabye a FEW characters (max 7) will apear but not all of them. A seperate game just wouldnt work well IMO.

source please?

 

[SmashChu]

I would go more with Nintendo Karts then Super Smash Karts. Change the line up a bit, and don't have everything be based on Smash, but rather Nintendo.

The idea could work, but I think your original idea needs some tweaking.

 

[Bowser King]

@ smashbro nvm..... Wikipedia originally had it written but its seems they changed it. Some one must have lied >.>

 

[J18]

But that brings me back to the main question: Would it work?

no it would not work. anybody working on a game like this would have their brains exploded from the sheer magnitude of such a concept. there head would remain intact, but there would be nothing but splattered brains inside.

but on a serious note, what kind of question is that? would it work? if someone made a game like that, why wouldn't it work? i really don't understand your question.

 

[Marie_54]

It wouldn't work... Pokemon Trainer is so broken he would reach the finish line before any kart can start the engine...


Someone had to say it...

 

[The Chuff]

Super Dance Bros Revolution. That's what they should really make.

 

[Gilgamesh]