Smashboards: "We'd be okay with any Square Enix character."
>Erdrick suddenly becomes the most likely character
Also Smashboards: "NO ONE LIKES DRAGON QUEST AND IF ERDRICK GETS IN I HOPE SQUARE ENIX FAILS BECAUSE OF THEIR CORPORATE GREED."
I'm laughing at the idea that Erdrick would be a Robin clone and that's what why he shouldn't be in. Just because people here aren't imaginative enough to come up with a moveset for Erdrick doesn't mean that one can't exist. Surely you're forgetting that this is the team that made a moveset for a Plant, a Dog who only laughs at you in the source material, a character who only shows up outside of a car in an anime that released after his appearance in Smash Bros., and more.
Role-Playing Weapons Specialist
There's one of many three word summaries for Erdrick.
They derived from Duck Hunt Dog,
Third-Party Cover Fire. They can derive something unique and original from Erdrick, despite what you may personally believe.