Kiki:
How does it make sense that he would be a survivor? Don't you think he would of stopped acting ******** the first time people were looking at him funny if that were the case?
Nick seems to have basically answered this already, but it "makes sense" because I got indie vibes from him D1 and I don't think there's a second serial killer in the game. The most obvious indie role that isn't SK is survivor. I have trouble explaining his behavior after people started looking at him funny regardless of his alignment, but my best guess is that he wanted to look as much of a lynch candidate as possible so that no one would bother NKing him.
Wasn't the question you directed at me just asking if I'd promise to be a lot more active today? Being extremely active in a mafia game has never exactly been my cup of tea.
But here's a question for you, why do you think Tom was nightkilled and not you?
Yes, but you didn't even respond to say "hello" or "okay" or "being extremely active in a mafia game has never exactly been my cup of tea". Any of which would at least have indicated you were reading the thread.
As for why Tom was NKed, I don't have much to add to what I said before. If I were to metagame off it I'd probably posit that mafia thought Tom was a better player than I was, which might suggest DGers were involved more than BRoomers. Then again, we know redcell was mafia, so what little we know for sure doesn't really support that theory. So I'll stick to what I said before: Tom has a reputation as a good player, and trying to read into things much more than that this early seems unpromising, even if there is in fact more behind that particular choice.
@Everyone: What do you think about the possible effects the silencer has in the game?
I'm curious about his alignment. Since you were among the most suspicious characters D1, and your talkativeness appeared to hurt town (specifically when it came to pointing out Tom's post restriction gaffe) it actually seems like silencing you could be a pro-town maneuver. On the other hand a mafia-aligned silencer might suspect that silencing you could bring more attention to you, and might foster your lynch. All things considered, though, I think anyone who scum silences is going to naturally look pro-town, so if we do find a mafia silencer I'm going to wonder if you getting silenced was supposed to be an elaborate mindgame.
Beyond that if we already know how to undo the effects of a silencer it'll probably just be a minor nuisance.
