-
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Smash Switch Most Wanted Newcomer Bracket Challenge (Third-Party)- Game Over; Results Posted
- Thread starter Nimbostratus
- Start date
CaptainAmerica
Smash Master
Once a Kutthroat, always a kutthroat...
But I was a Space Pirate first...
Final: Riddles
Battle for 3rd: Decidueye
Man, what a great showing. Congrats to both the finalists - both of you deserve to be in hands down.
But I was a Space Pirate first...
Final: Riddles
Battle for 3rd: Decidueye
Man, what a great showing. Congrats to both the finalists - both of you deserve to be in hands down.
FamicomDisk
Smash Journeyman
- Joined
- Mar 17, 2018
- Messages
- 388
Ooh, the final showdown! I'm guessing Ridley's going to win, but K. Rool could be a tough contender. Looking forward to seeing how this one turns out!
Championship Game: 1. King K. Rool
He feels like a better fit for Smash to me. As someone who isn't pushing for either of them, I'm just looking at who I think would be a better fit for Smash, and I believe that title goes to K. Rool!
Consolation Game: 1. Decidueye
I just like Decidueye more than Dixie Kong
I think Decidueye would also have a more unique moveset than Dixie.
Championship Game: 1. King K. Rool
He feels like a better fit for Smash to me. As someone who isn't pushing for either of them, I'm just looking at who I think would be a better fit for Smash, and I believe that title goes to K. Rool!
Consolation Game: 1. Decidueye
I just like Decidueye more than Dixie Kong
I think Decidueye would also have a more unique moveset than Dixie.
Smasher 101
Smash Lord
Championship: King K. Rool
Consolation: Dixie Kong
Consolation: Dixie Kong
G-Guy
Smash Ace
- Joined
- Oct 9, 2014
- Messages
- 807
- NNID
- G-Guy1990
Here we go, what a matchup!
Champion: King K. Rool
Wanted him since Melee, DK is my favorite franchise and K. Rool just oozes personality!
Consolidation: Dixie Kong
I just love the DKC games so much and Dixie is a String companion of mine ever since i was a kid.
Champion: King K. Rool
Wanted him since Melee, DK is my favorite franchise and K. Rool just oozes personality!
Consolidation: Dixie Kong
I just love the DKC games so much and Dixie is a String companion of mine ever since i was a kid.
Super Nintendo Chalmers
Smash Ace
Championship:
King K. Rool
Wouldn't mind Ridley at all, but K.Rool is one of my most wanted characters.
Consolation: Dixie Kong
It would be fitting for Dixie to finish 3rd, considering she's well known as the third wheel of the franchise
Not a big Pokemon fan past Gen 3, but Decidueye from what I've seen has real potential and an interesting potential moveset.
I just love DKC that little bit more.
Regardless, all four are highly regarded/requested, are great characters in their own right and would bring something different to the Smash table.
King K. Rool
Wouldn't mind Ridley at all, but K.Rool is one of my most wanted characters.
Consolation: Dixie Kong
It would be fitting for Dixie to finish 3rd, considering she's well known as the third wheel of the franchise
Not a big Pokemon fan past Gen 3, but Decidueye from what I've seen has real potential and an interesting potential moveset.
I just love DKC that little bit more.
Regardless, all four are highly regarded/requested, are great characters in their own right and would bring something different to the Smash table.
FunAtParties
PM me ur character ideas girl
Top Dog: Ridley
Both are deserving characters whom I like a lot, I just have a small preference towards Ridley.
Consolation Prize: Dixie Kong
Not even close for me. Decidueye is nice, but Dixie is a need imo.
Both are deserving characters whom I like a lot, I just have a small preference towards Ridley.
Consolation Prize: Dixie Kong
Not even close for me. Decidueye is nice, but Dixie is a need imo.
JamesDNaux
Smash Hero
Zem-raj
Smash Hero
Championship: Ridley
Consolation: Dixie Kong
Both Ridley and K.Rool 999% deserve to be playable, and have been due for 20 odd years. The results will probably be in favour of K.Rool, but I will pick Ridley because I prefer him and he's more deserving.
Consolation: Dixie Kong
Both Ridley and K.Rool 999% deserve to be playable, and have been due for 20 odd years. The results will probably be in favour of K.Rool, but I will pick Ridley because I prefer him and he's more deserving.
Xhampi
Smash Lord
Championship Game: Ridley
Consolation Game: Dixie Kong
Consolation Game: Dixie Kong
D
Deleted member
Guest
Boy, the championship round is hard as I support both (I don't call myself a "kutthroat" though because I have a disdain for part of the K. Rool fanbase, and I'm not as supportive of Ridley so I don't call myself a "space pirate" either), so I flipped a coin.
Championship round: King K. Rool
Yeah.
Consolation round: Decidueye
My most wanted character vs a character I lowkey want but can do without. Absolutely no contest.
Championship round: King K. Rool
Yeah.
Consolation round: Decidueye
My most wanted character vs a character I lowkey want but can do without. Absolutely no contest.
Last edited by a moderator:
Championship: Ridley
"Instead of going through a lot of very convoluted hocus-pocus to make Ridley a fighter, I figured it’d be better to keep Ridley as it currently is, the correct way, and have it feel like a truly threatening presence."
I want to see how he'd do this. Apparently, it's quite complicated.
Consolation: Dixie Kong
"Instead of going through a lot of very convoluted hocus-pocus to make Ridley a fighter, I figured it’d be better to keep Ridley as it currently is, the correct way, and have it feel like a truly threatening presence."
I want to see how he'd do this. Apparently, it's quite complicated.
Consolation: Dixie Kong
MasterOfKnees
Space Pirate
Championship: Ridley
Pretty much the best imaginable final we could have gotten, either character will be deserving of the crown, but I'm a Ridley man through and through.
Consolation: Dixie Kong
I feel like over the long term Dixie would be a better addition, Decidueye is still a bit too much flavor of the generation for me.
Pretty much the best imaginable final we could have gotten, either character will be deserving of the crown, but I'm a Ridley man through and through.
Consolation: Dixie Kong
I feel like over the long term Dixie would be a better addition, Decidueye is still a bit too much flavor of the generation for me.
Last edited:
Cosmic77
Smash Hero
Championship: Ridley
Here's the thing. Even if K. Rool doesn't get in, he has three other relevant and somewhat iconic characters that could take his place as the next DK newcomer (Dixie, Cranky, Funky). So what consolation character does Metroid and Ridley have to fall back on? The extremely outdated Dark Samus? The mysterious Sylux who probably won't even be considered by Sakurai until Prime 4 gets an official announcement/release?
We need a Metroid newcomer, and after everything the guy's been through, Ridley definitely deserves that spot more.
Consolation: Dixie Kong
I actually prefer Dixie over K. Rool. Decidueye would be cool, but the Gen VII Pokemon I REALLY want to see in Smash is Lycanroc.
Here's the thing. Even if K. Rool doesn't get in, he has three other relevant and somewhat iconic characters that could take his place as the next DK newcomer (Dixie, Cranky, Funky). So what consolation character does Metroid and Ridley have to fall back on? The extremely outdated Dark Samus? The mysterious Sylux who probably won't even be considered by Sakurai until Prime 4 gets an official announcement/release?
We need a Metroid newcomer, and after everything the guy's been through, Ridley definitely deserves that spot more.
Consolation: Dixie Kong
I actually prefer Dixie over K. Rool. Decidueye would be cool, but the Gen VII Pokemon I REALLY want to see in Smash is Lycanroc.
- Joined
- Aug 10, 2011
- Messages
- 34,013
- Location
- This Thread
- NNID
- OpossumGuy
- 3DS FC
- 4742-4911-3431
- Switch FC
- SW 2859 6322 5208
Ridley, Decidueye.
Imadethistoseealeak
Smash Champion
- Joined
- Jul 30, 2014
- Messages
- 2,102
Pretty close so far, as expected.
Well for me,
Ridley for Championship.
He's my number one wanted since Brawl, no surprise here. I could go on about how I honestly think he deserves it more but nah.
For consolation I'm picking Decideueye.
Dixie absolutely deserves it more, more than King K. Rool as the next DK rep, but I really want a playable ghost Pokemon :/
Well for me,
Ridley for Championship.
He's my number one wanted since Brawl, no surprise here. I could go on about how I honestly think he deserves it more but nah.
For consolation I'm picking Decideueye.
Dixie absolutely deserves it more, more than King K. Rool as the next DK rep, but I really want a playable ghost Pokemon :/
Diddy Kong
Smash Obsessed
- Joined
- Dec 8, 2004
- Messages
- 26,300
- Switch FC
- SW-1597-979602774
Both the DKC characters get the vote from me.
Reasoning below.
King K.Rool for Championship because? He's got genuine support, is far more realisable as a fighter, is one of the most unique concepts of a character, has ever lasting popularity despite his very last entry being in a Mario Sport game... It's not hard to see why I choose him. The Kremling Campain, the fact we got a Mii Costume out of ballot popularity, King K.Rool getting a reference in a Mario game on a street sign... It should all be clear as water that King K.Rool is the obvious choice here.
Ridley has been overhyped ever since the Melee trailer. But guess what, more characters that where not playable in Melee where in the Melee intro trailer
Sakurai has shot the idea down, and you've all been lucky with consistant Metroid appearances where Ridley appears in, so with all things considered... Please step aside.
Dixie Kong also gets my vote over Decidueye. And why? I feel like Decidueye support is heavily forced mostly because he's a new and recent Grass Type starter. His design doesn't stand out too much from the rest, and Incineroar boasts similar popularity whilst not being HALF as forced. Next Grass Type starter of Generation 8 is gonna make people forget about Decidueye within a second.
Dixie has been the star of the last game of the legendary DKC SNES titles. She's one of Nintendo's first playable female heroes, is from a franchise that desperately needs more playable characters. And it SHOULD get more playable characters, because the DKC cast has lots to offer with them. Dixie with her hair grabs and Helicopter Spin makes more than enough for a playable character suited for Smash Bros., and you all know it. At worst she would be a semi-clone, but guess what? Her Helicopter Spin ability alone makes her worthy for inclusion, then there's the hair grabs... She would easily be as unique as Wolf was / is to Fox without even trying much.
Yes both DKC newcomers are big enough names to warrant them being included both. Dixie Kong has recency on her side and is a much beloved main character, and King K.Rool has massive popularity to boot and is in dire need of a new appearance. Decidueye will be forgotten, and Ridley won't EVER be forgotten Smash or not, and is pretty much guranteed for a Boss style appearance anyway.
Nobody can convince me otherwise. This is what must happen.
Reasoning below.
King K.Rool for Championship because? He's got genuine support, is far more realisable as a fighter, is one of the most unique concepts of a character, has ever lasting popularity despite his very last entry being in a Mario Sport game... It's not hard to see why I choose him. The Kremling Campain, the fact we got a Mii Costume out of ballot popularity, King K.Rool getting a reference in a Mario game on a street sign... It should all be clear as water that King K.Rool is the obvious choice here.
Ridley has been overhyped ever since the Melee trailer. But guess what, more characters that where not playable in Melee where in the Melee intro trailer
Sakurai has shot the idea down, and you've all been lucky with consistant Metroid appearances where Ridley appears in, so with all things considered... Please step aside.Dixie Kong also gets my vote over Decidueye. And why? I feel like Decidueye support is heavily forced mostly because he's a new and recent Grass Type starter. His design doesn't stand out too much from the rest, and Incineroar boasts similar popularity whilst not being HALF as forced. Next Grass Type starter of Generation 8 is gonna make people forget about Decidueye within a second.
Dixie has been the star of the last game of the legendary DKC SNES titles. She's one of Nintendo's first playable female heroes, is from a franchise that desperately needs more playable characters. And it SHOULD get more playable characters, because the DKC cast has lots to offer with them. Dixie with her hair grabs and Helicopter Spin makes more than enough for a playable character suited for Smash Bros., and you all know it. At worst she would be a semi-clone, but guess what? Her Helicopter Spin ability alone makes her worthy for inclusion, then there's the hair grabs... She would easily be as unique as Wolf was / is to Fox without even trying much.
Yes both DKC newcomers are big enough names to warrant them being included both. Dixie Kong has recency on her side and is a much beloved main character, and King K.Rool has massive popularity to boot and is in dire need of a new appearance. Decidueye will be forgotten, and Ridley won't EVER be forgotten Smash or not, and is pretty much guranteed for a Boss style appearance anyway.
Nobody can convince me otherwise. This is what must happen.
Nimbostratus
Smash Journeyman
- Joined
- Apr 14, 2014
- Messages
- 429
It looks like my choices are narrowly losing? It’s time to tip the scales!
Championship: King K. Rool
Both are very deserving and iconic, so that doesn’t play a role. What it comes down to is that I think K. Rool would play better. He’s got plenty of moveset potential to draw from to make him unique. While I don’t think Ridley is “Too Big”, I do think there is a higher risk of him not turning out very well, with the possibility of a mediocre moveset and an awkwardly scaled model. K. Rool’s personality and his kostumes also just feel more right for Smash. Don’t get me wrong, I want Ridley in for sure, but this is an easy (albeit painful) choice.
Consolation: Decidueye
Ok, this is a hard one. Really hard. Dixie Kong is definitely more iconic and deserving. I’ll probably still support her if she doesn’t get into this game, while my support for Decidueye would probably fade.
However, that might be the very reason I have to take Decidueye here. This is probably his one chance. I don’t think any Pokémon is ever going to be as deserving as Dixie or be relevant for more than one game. Does that mean we should never add Pokémon? Certainly not! When we do add them, though, I want them to be good choices, and Decidueye is a great one. Sure, maybe some people just support Decidueye because “new Grass starter.” However, I genuinely think he has a cool design and would be great to play as (probably more so than Dixie), and this is his one shot. He has some drawbacks, but I don't need Dixie that badly to overcome them. Maybe it's that I want K. Rool more, and it feels wrong to pick both DKC characters. I don't know, but he just seems like the right pick this time.
Really, though, both of these are turning out to be great matchups. I’m excited to see how it ends.
Championship: King K. Rool
Both are very deserving and iconic, so that doesn’t play a role. What it comes down to is that I think K. Rool would play better. He’s got plenty of moveset potential to draw from to make him unique. While I don’t think Ridley is “Too Big”, I do think there is a higher risk of him not turning out very well, with the possibility of a mediocre moveset and an awkwardly scaled model. K. Rool’s personality and his kostumes also just feel more right for Smash. Don’t get me wrong, I want Ridley in for sure, but this is an easy (albeit painful) choice.
Consolation: Decidueye
Ok, this is a hard one. Really hard. Dixie Kong is definitely more iconic and deserving. I’ll probably still support her if she doesn’t get into this game, while my support for Decidueye would probably fade.
However, that might be the very reason I have to take Decidueye here. This is probably his one chance. I don’t think any Pokémon is ever going to be as deserving as Dixie or be relevant for more than one game. Does that mean we should never add Pokémon? Certainly not! When we do add them, though, I want them to be good choices, and Decidueye is a great one. Sure, maybe some people just support Decidueye because “new Grass starter.” However, I genuinely think he has a cool design and would be great to play as (probably more so than Dixie), and this is his one shot. He has some drawbacks, but I don't need Dixie that badly to overcome them. Maybe it's that I want K. Rool more, and it feels wrong to pick both DKC characters. I don't know, but he just seems like the right pick this time.
Really, though, both of these are turning out to be great matchups. I’m excited to see how it ends.
Sailor Waddle Dee
Smash Journeyman
- Joined
- Jun 10, 2014
- Messages
- 402
And in the shock of the century. K. Rool and RIdley are the finalists.
Championship Game: King K. Rool vs Ridley
Baron Kaptain Krusha King K. Roolenstein
This may actually be the easiest choice in the whole entire tournament. while I am not desperate for K. Rool in smash, I am far more familiar with him than Ridley, and have many fond memories of DKC so he gets my vote easily.
Consolation Game: Dixie Kong vs Decidueye
Decidueye
I was all prepared to go Dixie Kong. She's a great and deserving choice, and possibly in my top 10 wants. but reading through the comments people have made and in particular Nimbostratus' I realized, Decidueye is a flavor of the month character. but he's one that i like. and as soon as Gen 8 comes out, he'll be forgotten as most smash fans move on to the next generation to look for potential newcomers. Decidueye is a genuinely good choice for his potential. but if he doesn't get in now. he never will. no Pokemon besides Pikachu really has the staying power to stick around on people's minds after their Generation is replaced. sure, Gen 8 might have an even more interesting Grass Starter, or just a more interesting Pokemon in general. but Decidueye is still a cool Pokemon and he deserves his shot at being a smasher.
Championship Game: King K. Rool vs Ridley
Baron Kaptain Krusha King K. Roolenstein
This may actually be the easiest choice in the whole entire tournament. while I am not desperate for K. Rool in smash, I am far more familiar with him than Ridley, and have many fond memories of DKC so he gets my vote easily.
Consolation Game: Dixie Kong vs Decidueye
Decidueye
I was all prepared to go Dixie Kong. She's a great and deserving choice, and possibly in my top 10 wants. but reading through the comments people have made and in particular Nimbostratus' I realized, Decidueye is a flavor of the month character. but he's one that i like. and as soon as Gen 8 comes out, he'll be forgotten as most smash fans move on to the next generation to look for potential newcomers. Decidueye is a genuinely good choice for his potential. but if he doesn't get in now. he never will. no Pokemon besides Pikachu really has the staying power to stick around on people's minds after their Generation is replaced. sure, Gen 8 might have an even more interesting Grass Starter, or just a more interesting Pokemon in general. but Decidueye is still a cool Pokemon and he deserves his shot at being a smasher.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Dec 10, 2013
- Messages
- 3,965
- NNID
- TCT~Phantom
This is gonna be grueling for
Nimbostratus
to count I am sure of it. By the looks of it so far the Kremling King and the Cunning God of Death are formidable foes.
Nimbostratus
to count I am sure of it. By the looks of it so far the Kremling King and the Cunning God of Death are formidable foes.
Phaazoid
Basket
- Joined
- Aug 29, 2006
- Messages
- 7,719
- Location
- Mr. Sakurai's wild ride
- NNID
- Mr.Grike
- 3DS FC
- 4854-6444-0859
Championship: Ridley.
I like K. Rool and would love him as a new DK rep, but, I am a Metroid fan through an through.
Runner up: I hate both of these characters, so I'll abstain.
I like K. Rool and would love him as a new DK rep, but, I am a Metroid fan through an through.
Runner up: I hate both of these characters, so I'll abstain.
Last edited:
Chihiro Fujisaki
Smash Journeyman
i feel like i'm in such a minority when i say "i don't really care about either of the winners"
but i'll pick k. rool though
of course i'll pick decidueye for the losers round
but i'll pick k. rool though
of course i'll pick decidueye for the losers round
Last edited:
ShinyRegice
Smash Lord
Finalists: King K. Rool
Loser round: Dixie kong
Loser round: Dixie kong
Pizza Robo
Smash Journeyman
- Joined
- Aug 23, 2007
- Messages
- 324
Championship King K Rool
Runner up Decidueye
Runner up Decidueye
Organization XIII
Smash Champion
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2015
- Messages
- 2,083
Ridley and I don't care so I guess the pokemon.Too tired to list reasonings will later.
Creo
Smash Champion
Championship Game: K. Rool
Heavyweight, villain, and most importantly, another Donkey Kong representative. . . Been wanting this animal since Melee.
Consolation Game: Dixie Kong
Female, and most importantly. . . Another Donkey Kong representative (ha ha). The thing is, while I actually love Decidueye, I know Pokemon are going to get their licks in SSBV for a fact, whereas the Donkey Kong series. . . I really don't know, so I'm pulling for the two characters that I feel have the best shot strongly.
Last edited:
Iko MattOrr
Smash Champion
Championship: Ridley
Consolation: Dixie
This time the reasons are simple, I just prefer those characters and the series they come from (Metroid vs DK -> Metroid; DK vs Pokèmon -> DK).
Consolation: Dixie
This time the reasons are simple, I just prefer those characters and the series they come from (Metroid vs DK -> Metroid; DK vs Pokèmon -> DK).
Gimj
Smash Journeyman
- Joined
- Oct 12, 2013
- Messages
- 220
Championship Game: King K. Rool
Said it before but I'll say it again. No contest because Ridley is literally impossible to implement as a playable character; maintaining both balance and faithful representation of Ridley(his enormous size) cannot be done by Sakurai. He is too big.
King K Rool also is near Ridley levels in terms of an interesting classic villain, despite the fact it would be pretty cool to play as Ridley.
Consolation Game: Decidueye
I want Decidueye more as a fighter and think he will be overall more interesting so I picked him. Dixie probably takes precedent over him in a sense, but is less "unique."
Said it before but I'll say it again. No contest because Ridley is literally impossible to implement as a playable character; maintaining both balance and faithful representation of Ridley(his enormous size) cannot be done by Sakurai. He is too big.
King K Rool also is near Ridley levels in terms of an interesting classic villain, despite the fact it would be pretty cool to play as Ridley.
Consolation Game: Decidueye
I want Decidueye more as a fighter and think he will be overall more interesting so I picked him. Dixie probably takes precedent over him in a sense, but is less "unique."
Angelglory
Smash Ace
Championship Game: Ridley
Consolation Game: Decidueye
Consolation Game: Decidueye
TheLegendOfLaser
Smash Rookie
Championship: Ridley
Consolation: Dixie Kong
Consolation: Dixie Kong
Bootortle
Smash Apprentice
- Joined
- Apr 5, 2014
- Messages
- 105
- Location
- Cornfields (aka the Midwest)
- 3DS FC
- 0259-0284-1711
- Switch FC
- SW-4554-3900-0616
K. Rool vs. Ridley is ridiculously tough
I think I'm gonna go K. Rool for that moveset potential with the blunderbuss as well as nostalgia
also Decidueye would be way more unique than Dixie
not that Dixie would be completely similar to Diddy, but there would be similarities
honestly I wish they would have just been like the Ice Climbers from the start
so
Championship: K. Rool
Consolation: Decidueye
I think I'm gonna go K. Rool for that moveset potential with the blunderbuss as well as nostalgia
also Decidueye would be way more unique than Dixie
not that Dixie would be completely similar to Diddy, but there would be similarities
honestly I wish they would have just been like the Ice Climbers from the start
so
Championship: K. Rool
Consolation: Decidueye
Nimbostratus
Smash Journeyman
- Joined
- Apr 14, 2014
- Messages
- 429
Well, I'd like to end the round and reveal the results soon, but...
Based on my current calculations, one of these games is a TIE, and the other is separated by ONE VOTE.
I'm going to extend this until noon tomorrow in hopes of getting more votes to break the tie. If not, I might have to make an external poll or something to get the lurkers involved. I don't know.
If you haven't done so, please vote, vote, vote!
Based on my current calculations, one of these games is a TIE, and the other is separated by ONE VOTE.
I'm going to extend this until noon tomorrow in hopes of getting more votes to break the tie. If not, I might have to make an external poll or something to get the lurkers involved. I don't know.
If you haven't done so, please vote, vote, vote!