I think anyone who doesn't play Meta Knight has negative feelings towards the character. lol.
Your opinion of the character is as skewed as Xyro's though dude. You're more open minded to what people have to say about things, but you're definitely outspoken about it.
And oi, focker, why haven't I seen you since like MLG Dallas? Come to more tournaments!
Although MK is not running tournaments in Texas it's the idea behind banning him.
If we start running MK banned tournaments, others will soon start following because we were able to take the initiative.
That's what I think.
We've tried it before. Xyro was only holding MK banned tournaments for a few months a while back and Dallas had the character banned for quite a while too, but it never caught on. The idea behind what you say is sound, but the actual execution cannot be obtained unless the BBR-RC says to ban the character in the Unity Ruleset.
Okay, look at Europe. What if they were to ban MK, where Marth all but dominates already. Makes no sense. You can't fix problems you don't have.
European playstyle is so different from ours that there's no way to make this a fair comparison. I haven't seen very many games go to time on the Smash Turnoi channel on YouTube and those guys are so aggressive that it makes the game actually fun to watch. Besides, most of their tournament top 3s are Wario, Marth and then Metaknight, so he does have a fair bit of influence
Unfortunately, we can't really use European information any more than we can Japanese information. The Japanese actually had Snake banned for quite a while. While I agree with you that Metaknight is not an issue on a local or statewide scale in Texas, I do have to concede that he is, statistically speaking, a problem on a nationwide scale.
------------------------------------------------------------------
I was talking to Zac the other day at the last Phase and I expressed to him that after I saw some of the tricks Metaknight players were using that I'm actually back on the fence about Metaknight. I've been considering whether or not he should be kept around and right now I think the game is still healthy with him legal. The same people are winning national level tournaments right now that were winning them at the early stages of the game; the only spots that have really fluctuated are 3rd through 8th. If you remove Ally and Mew2King from the statistics we actually have a fairly balanced and healthy game; though Metaknight is still the clear front-runner in earnings and character usage. (from what I remember from the statistics I saw)
I really enjoy playing the character and I think that any banning is a detriment to the health of a game overall, but I also know that the game may very well be healthier without him around. I don't support the idea of banning him right now, but given additional time to consider the outcome I could see my opinion (and vote, if that happens) go in either direction.