Project M Social Thread

[L/A/W]

SHeLL stated that Mario's Melee and Brawl Dair both serve similar purposes. However, Melee Dair has a far wider range of percentages that it is effective in. I think it also has a larger hitbox, but it might be the aesthetics throwing me off.

they are pretty different, I actually think brawl dair would be better on this one

 

[GP&B]

Well, I had asked him about it a while back on the discrepancies between the two and why Melee Dair was chosen. That was most of what I remembered.

 

[kaizo13]

That looks completely pointless from a grounded up b and just another wavedash from an up b while landing.

lol pointless?? this is an awesome tech. You can juggle heavies (ala falco shine)
and it's a great combo starter (since u can follow up right away due to canceling ur up b)
The only reason you don't see it in Melee is because it's way too difficult to execute consistently

so if P:M can make it easier to input, it could be a fairly decent tech.

 

[L/A/W]

Well, I had asked him about it a while back on the discrepancies between the two and why Melee Dair was chosen. That was most of what I remembered.

ok fair enough mario's other changes sound great, especially fludd related ones

 

[Sora-kun]

Sora-Kun and why should we try to please those "idiots" you speak about?

so what if we clone stuff back to melee? that's what half of this project is about....i'd rather have a cloned move that looks and works good than a crap animation just for the sake of "variety" and pleasing noobs

point taken.
and with that my entire argument is gone.

i agree. if idiots wont play such an amazing work of art because of that then at least the project M community will be spared a little bit of stupidity right?
so meh.
i like sparta kick. meme kick ftw.
i personally like melee down tilt better it looks kewl.<_> but brawl one looks more powerful and it's original.

so either way i won't rly care lol

 

[kaizo13]

we should give Captain Falcon the sparta kick instead

that would be soo manly i wouldn't mind it *lulz

 

[Sora-kun]

we should give Captain Falcon the sparta kick instead

that would be soo manly i wouldn't mind it *lulz

brilliant. that's all i can say.

 

[L/A/W]

we should give Captain Falcon the sparta kick instead

that would be soo manly i wouldn't mind it *lulz

with sparta kick falcon couldn't DAFT
It would be a great injustice to falcons everywhere and sparta kick only works for ganon anyway but just barely

 

[I R MarF]

lol pointless?? this is an awesome tech. You can juggle heavies (ala falco shine)
and it's a great combo starter (since u can follow up right away due to canceling ur up b)
The only reason you don't see it in Melee is because it's way too difficult to execute consistently

so if P:M can make it easier to input, it could be a fairly decent tech.

I agree; it sets up for a lot of aerial follow ups/combos. If the window for execution was extended by 3 or so frames it would actually be a very accessible AT for mario users and help expand his meta game. Not to mention the ability to fiddle with controller options such as B-sticking.

However, if it is too difficult to code then there is no point wasting time on it now; but it would be cool to see implemented sometime down the road.

 

[Sneak8288]

Sorry about no stream.. i was up all nite playin sc2 and overslept.. ima try to get armada to play PM tomorrow tho. If i do vids will be up asap

 

[Sterowent]

hah, i forgot to factor SC2 into everything now. i'm surprised the world hasn't stopped.

in fact, i bet that's all shanus is doing right now too.

 

[Sora-kun]

Sorry about no stream.. i was up all nite playin sc2 and overslept.. ima try to get armada to play PM tomorrow tho. If i do vids will be up asap

the European peach main? @__@ isn't he.. you know.. in Europe?

 

[L/A/W]

the European peach main? @__@ isn't he.. you know.. in Europe?

he came to america for apex
and yes, the peach main from sweden haha

 

[Sneak8288]

yea he's gonna be in nj tomorrow. he's staying in philly with cactuar and is going to the tourney in nj im going to

 

[Sora-kun]

he came to america for apex
and yes, the peach main from sweden haha

ahh apex.. i should know what that is shouldn't i..

i'm jk it's a type of cereal! <_< i'm not stupid!
cereal = tourney
anyway i'd love to watch him play =o

 

[Sterowent]

i dunno, is the game really ready to be played by the likes of one of the top 5 players in the world? in this case, unlike with M2K, SS, Vanz, it's not like there'll be someone back home for him explaining the progress of PM. i get so worried

 

[Sora-kun]

i dunno, is the game really ready to be played by the likes of one of the top 5 players in the world? in this case, unlike with M2K, SS, Vanz, it's not like there'll be someone back home for him explaining the progress of PM. i get so worried

who are the top 5 exactly?

mango
isai
ken
me
---

i know i'm way off. and i refuse to include m2k <_<
>_>

yes i know isai and ken are retired.
so now we have

me
mango
--
--
--

 

[bleyva]

i dunno, is the game really ready to be played by the likes of one of the top 5 players in the world? in this case, unlike with M2K, SS, Vanz, it's not like there'll be someone back home for him explaining the progress of PM. i get so worried

well then just get one of Armada's Swedish cronies to explain to him that its still in its early stages and that few things are set in stone.



not a big deal imo.

 

[L/A/W]

who are the top 5 exactly?

lets not derail this to a top 5 thread
besides we all know it's scorpion master

 

[Anth0ny]

top 5 is mango, m2k, hungrybox, armada, amsah probably. shiz and pp are close too. and scorpion master

im probably missing someone >_>

 

[Magus420]

You go into up-b landing lag when you up-b cancel. It mostly only has novelty in that it's his fastest OoS option. Now, the lag after a cancel could probably be sped up if it were somehow able to be put in PM, but it definitely was not a 'great combo starter' in melee since it lags for half a second.


Btw, there are some issues with Peach that need working on (landing detection for ground float aerials, dashing behind out of crouch which messes up ground float aerials, IASAs on aerials temporarily removed since they were causing the fall out of float bug). Peach is one of my mains in Melee and I personally can't stand using her in PM atm mostly for the issues with ground floated aerials. I would not be surprised if he hates using her as well.

 

[L/A/W]

top 5 is mango, m2k, hungrybox, armada, amsah probably. Shiz and pp are close too. And scorpion master

im probably missing someone >_>

isaaaaaaaaiiiiiiiiiii!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

EDIT: about the stages, will they all be tournament legal? If not, what will the remaining stages consist of?

 

[Sora-kun]

lets not derail this to a top 5 thread
besides we all know it's scorpion master

wasn't planning on that. just a question out of curiousity


that mario guy? i omgwtf'd when i saw that one combo that ended with a clouded fsmash.
that was too **** pro <_>

 

[L/A/W]

wasn't planning on that. just a question out of curiousity


that mario guy? i omgwtf'd when i saw that one combo that ended with a clouded fsmash.
that was too **** pro <_>

please tell me you know that "that mario guy" is more than meets the eye

 

[Sora-kun]

please tell me you know that "that mario guy" is more than he appears to be

well i don't rly know a lot of pro melee players
i said "that mario guy" to make sure i was thinking of the same person.
i know the basic melee pros tho <_<
amsah, lucian (prolly spelled wrong), isai, ken, neo, the germ, m2k, mango, shiz, taj, dr pp, shiz, zhu, SS, HMW, bob$, shroomed, armada, kage, boss, some more that i forget

but no i've never heard of scorpion until today. sorry =/
i'm a melee rookie lol i was good in brawl but who gives a **** about brawl?<_< i started playing melee when i heard about this project so ya.. i know very little. ;_;
so.. enlighten me plz

 

[Grim Tuesday]

well i don't rly know a lot of pro melee players
i said "that mario guy" to make sure i was thinking of the same person.
i know the basic melee pros tho <_<
amsah, lucian (prolly spelled wrong), isai, ken, neo, the germ, m2k, mango, shiz, taj, dr pp, shiz, zhu, SS, HMW, bob$, shroomed, armada, kage, boss, some more that i forget

but no i've never heard of scorpion until today. sorry =/
i'm a melee rookie lol i was good in brawl but who gives a **** about brawl?<_< i started playing melee when i heard about this project so ya.. i know very little. ;_;
so.. enlighten me plz

It is general consensus that Scorpion Master = Mango.

 

[kaizo13]

Scorpion backwards, spells out Mango....believe it or not

 

[Sora-kun]

Scorpion backwards, spells out Mango....believe it or not

*facepalm* e.e how the hell was i supposed to know that? lmao

 

[Grim Tuesday]

*facepalm* e.e how the hell was i supposed to know that? lmao

Just need to keep up with the game mate, there were like, 3 threads about it. And in the comments section of all of his videos.

 

[kaizo13]

yea so Mango takes up like 2-3 spots on the top 5

 

[Sora-kun]

Just need to keep up with the game mate, there were like, 3 threads about it. And in the comments section of all of his videos.

as long as it's clear that it's because i'm not keeping up and not because of pure stupidity <_<

plus i don't rly read any threads except this one e.e too lazy to bother.

i thought on the comments they were bs'ing or saying he's mango as a reference to being the best. <_< but i guess i was wrong. oh well.

 

[L/A/W]

as long as it's clear that it's because i'm not keeping up and not because of pure stupidity <_<

plus i don't rly read any threads except this one e.e too lazy to bother.

i thought on the comments they were bs'ing or saying he's mango as a reference to being the best. <_< but i guess i was wrong. oh well.

just watch him play, he's clearly mango from how he plays
also look at gsg results. there's no way and unknown at like his 3rd tourney got 2nd with mario in that bracket
tldr: yah he's mango

 

[Sora-kun]

just watch him play, he's clearly mango from how he plays
also look at gsg results. there's no way and unknown at like his 3rd tourney got 2nd with mario in that bracket
tldr: yah he's mango

ah, i see. my bad.

 

[Isatis]

Guys, get back on topic >_> Take the top player discussion to Melee Discussion.

 

[Sora-kun]

Guys, get back on topic >_> Take the top player discussion to Melee Discussion.

it's not like there's anything else to discuss at 3:21 am <__< but fine w/e sorry.

back to stuff that's been discussed 40 times already:

will link get his melee down smash hitbox? you could hit people touching your hat with that thing.

also to further give reasons why i wish he could grab opponents who are in the air,
i was fighting cpu because i had no one else to fight as my brother was gone. i threw the boomerang - it came back - i grabbed - the rang hit (he was at 25%..) - my grab missed because the boomerang hit him 2 inches off the ground.

is his rang going to be the multi hit galemerang? (i heard it was that somewhere..) or are you changing it back to single hit? multi hit would be ****** but idk if it would be broken or not.


and is it possible to give link's bombs a smaller explosion like in melee? i loved being able to stand so close that i could touch elbows and still blow them up without getting hit as well.

and that's all i can think of that's on topic at this moment =/

 

[L/A/W]

Guys, get back on topic >_> Take the top player discussion to Melee Discussion.

i had a question at the top of the page and no devs have posted yet so calm down

 

[GameWatching]

the texture is a recolor

and need so much fixing :/

 

[Strong Badam]

btw guys, up-b cancel doesn't legitimately combo into anything in melee. DI and all that.
and the input was ********, you hit up-b and then you went backward like 13 degrees on the analog stick within 3 frames. so dumb.

 

[Sneak8288]

gamewatching just do fox lol.. thats the only important 1

 

[Grim Tuesday]

btw guys, up-b cancel doesn't legitimately combo into anything in melee. DI and all that.
and the input was ********, you hit up-b and then you went backward like 13 degrees on the analog stick within 3 frames. so dumb.

Seems like it has potential to be an AT to me.
Put it in, make it easier to use and better in general. Sounds fun to me.