1. Marth is a guarentee. He's staring 3 games, and is the future of Fire Emblem. IF Sakurai wants to help the series sell and rep the most recent game's main character, Marth is in. And Marth and Roy are no longer Japan-only characters (FE11 going worldwide, and FE7 having a Roy cameo apperance), so Lucas is the last remaining despised Japan-only character.
I cannot express how much I do not care. No insult to people who do care, but I honestly do not care if Marth gets back in, in fact I think that his chances are around fifty-fifty, he has as much stuf againt him as for him, and personally, I don't care for the diferecne between Marth or Machiah. It wouldn't even cause me to blink if Marth was confirmed or deconfirmed tomorrow. I cannot say anything about my stance on this, because I honestly do not have one, but I can really see the logic in this.
And I dispise Lucas too.
Ike using a two-handed moveset more similar to Link's power based moveset in Melee, in which Link is now more balanced, like in smash 64 (minus sucking). Ike is all power, okay speed, while Marth is all speed attacks, and is quite agile. They are bipolar opposites, and honestly Mario is closer to Ike then Marth! Another thing I can mark as "I was right!"
Too bad about Goroh (despite being 5 month old news! XD). >_<
Yeah, the Goroh thing got me, as I was an advocate for at least having two characters for every rep spot (except third party). It really bummed me out.
2. No Falco? NO FALCO!? FALCO!!!! Seriously, Falco is popular, and shall be in Brawl. If some nobody obscure character named Takamaru from a Japan-only failed game gets in over a smash fan's favorite character like Falco, Smash fans in general will be pissed. Hell, I'll raise a storm, because Falco is the s***, and is a Melee fan favorite.
Woah! I didn't notice that on the new list, but now that you mention it, I'm at a deep conflict with that decision. Falco was a popular character, he was like Fox's right hand man, but I really don't want to have another saxrifice in roster... Oh, wait! Wisey, if you remove the rediculously improbable characters like Geno you can make more room for Falco! I mean, if on your list Sheik is returning, you might as well have the more likely canidates return too.
3. Claus is probably going to be a alternate outfit, and Miciah won't make it, ever. Her game will not be the most recent, and that is a fact. MOTHER has sold less then F-Zero, and won't get another rep after Ness being pretty much deconfirmed. Why the crap give one game two reps in a series when there are three to work from=??? Doesn't make sense to me! XD
Amen to that! If anyone's getting in with Lucas, it's going to be Ness. Why? Because Ness was in the Original Twelve and has been there ever since, replacing him with Lucas and then replacing the second spot with Claus is like pouring lemon juice soaked salt onto an open wound. And I think your right, even if Sakurai's getting more into the Japan only MOTHER that doesn't mean that that's the only thing that he's going to be drawing from. Pulling from all games in the franchise just makes more sense than focusing on one, particularly if Ness had become a fairly popular character since then.
4. Takamaru comes from a Japan-only game that flopped, and he's never reappeared. Replace him with Balloon Fighter, if you must! XD
Man, you're right on the ball here! Iv'e been calling for this for a long long time. Wisey, I have no idea what made you put Takkey on the list, but you seriously need to take him/her out!
5. Issac: Hasn't appeared in a game as of late. Unless the Golden Sun 3 rumors are real, he is a big "NO!"
You make a fine point here, when I heard about this third party thing images of powerful icons sprung to mind, like Bomberman, Megaman, or Cloud duking it out. These third party slots are too costly to use trying to ressurect old characters. This goes for Geno too. Now, some people will say that there have been retro characters like the Ice Climbers who have gotten in, but Nintendo was able to do that because Nintendo owned those characters, and thusly, didn't spend any money trying to get them, with third party characters however, you need to finagle with another company and dice up the profit of the game with them, then give them commitment to the character,and in the end, it's just a waste of money and time because half of the people don't even recognize the character. Heck, I didn't even recognize the character when you put him up, and I play a pretty good sum of video games.
6. If it's one character on the Dojo, it's one character in character predictions. If it's two characters on the Dojo, it's two characters in character predictions. Yes, that is the rule. Now stick to it.
Yep, dem's the rules.
7. Lack of international retro characters. Balloon Fighter, Mach Rider, and so on.
Well, with Wario's bike moves it seems that Nintendo isn't really looking much into Mach Rider being original, as they gave the only move he could have to Wario, however, with the new idea of humans getting multiple jumps, gliding, and the fact that he was nearly in Melee raises his chances a crapload I say. However, there is the matter of the Baloon Fighter fish on an Ice Climber stage. Why would they put that there unless they weren't planning on a Balloon Fighter stage? Personally, I'm affled at the dicisions right now, so currently I'm at standstill.
8. Sora has no chance. Two out of Five of his games are on Nintendo systems, only. Plus Sora is like Disney based, and I'm not sure if we want Mickey Mouse in Brawl. Let alone Donald Duck, and Goofey!
Actually, here is where I need to intervene, as Nintendo already has a Kingdom Hearts lined up for the Wii, in my book that skyrockets Sora's chances amazingly as Nintendo would definitely want to publicize Sora then. And, believe it or not, you can have a character in the game without needing the whole cast. It doesn't quite stretch the mind to imagine Sora alone, fighting, and not mentioning any Disney character. He isn't Disney, in fact, he's a fish ou of water with Disney, actually more of a FF like character than anything.
9. Belmont has no chance for the reason no Final Fantasy character has no chance....LACK OF MOST IMPORTANT CHARACTER! Still, I guess being on the secondary 3rd party character lists suits him, though if it's in order, Bomberman is above him. About time the Bomberman series sells 10 million units, after more games then Megaman!
I can only see Belmont getting in if Nintendo has failed at getting a character from an outside source, then, and only then, would they go back to Konami and say "Gimme another one.", which I find pretty unlikely.
10. Pacman is too random. Try Rayman as a potential 3rd party character. Also, don't be afraid to try other random ones. Put Master Chief as #5 and say how much you want him, and how awsome he'd be. Followed by "jk, guys" just to rile people up!
I don't find Pac-Man random, if Nintendo wants iconic, definitely go with Pac-Man. But I agree, Rayman is just such a good, underrated character, and I would love to see him Brawl.
To the Master Cheif thing: HEy, Bungie's left Microsoft, and is now second party, maybe we will see him, but perhaps only in SSB4.
'Nuff said.