out of all of the 40+ characters brawl will have, what would the point of making a big deal out of jiggly be? more importantly, you still havnt pointed out a plausible problem with jiggly.
There's no real problem with Jigglypuff. What shadenexus seems to be saying is that there are just better, more unique - yes, more unique - options than Jiggly. Personally, I think Kirby could take over Jigglypuff's aerial game (her crowning glory) without any big resistance. Shadenexus's main point is, quite simply, Jigglypuff doesn't LOOK like a smasher. At all.
A character like Mimirol could be equally unique, while also just changing things around a bit. A little bit of variety. This is all personal opinion and guesswork, of course, but I'd rather see two new Pokemon, but no Jiggly, than one new Pokemon with Jiggly still around.
Well jpuff should stay because she and pikachu represent the original ssb pokemon.And she is good.You just got to know how to play her.She's the one I used to baet lv51 with giga bowser and co.
So now the originals must be kept in at all costs? I never saw that rule anywhere. Either way, let's be honest, the only original that could conceivably be dropped - EVER - is Jigglypuff. As kaid says, her popularity outside of Smash has diminished, giving way to other, newer Pokemon. And, outside of Japan (and outside of Smash), she's never been particularly liked.
And just because she's good, is no reason to keep her. As kaid summed up, that's like saying Mewtwo... or even DK should be dropped. And Bowser. And Kirby. Oh, and it also could imply that Dr. Mario should be kept. Even if he wasn't Luigified.
eh... i doubt that sakurai would put an unpopular pokemon in just because it is recognisable...
Who said Munchlax was unpopular? According to Wikipedia, he's already appeared in 4 Pokemon games - quite a feat for a 4th generation Pokemon. Anyway, characters that are widely known tend to be more popular than the others. The only exception I can think of right now is Tingle, and he's very popular in Japan - he even has his own game.
In summary, I'd rather have that ball of fluff ^ than the current ball of fluff. Of course, I don't care very much one way or the other, to be honest.