I guess I'll post my opinions from my rough tiers I drew up at work. I might change em, I was a little unsure of some things.
Also, I am lucky enough to know almost everyone in the crew lol. The only unranked I have is Dapuff in Melee.
Melee
Top - GOTM, UltimaScout, ChiboSempai, Vex Kasrani
High - MexiMadnez, Talwind, UltimoDragon, AztecKing, SQKIsiggy
Mid - Xzax, .com, TerrV, WingZero, Bean
Low - Kyuu, Rogue Pit, Ponchoman, Flizzz
Brawl (this list was so freicken hard to make... i dont have a low tier, we're all simply too good lolz)
Top - ChiboSempai, Rogue Pit, Vex Kasrani, UltimoDragon, Dapuffster
High - MexiMadnez, Kyuu, Xzax, .com, Ultimascout, SQKIsiggy
Mid - AztecKing, Ponchoman, TerrV, Talwind, Flizzz, GOTM
there is no order of players within the tiers
Ranks I was real split between:
Melee .com - low or mid?
Brawl SQKIsiggy - high or mid?
Brawl Kyuu - top or high?
As for other comments on this: I would originally have mexi as top in Brawl, but he's been really rusty lately from not playing much due to school and work. Once he gets back into the game though he's top. TerrV plays inconsistently, like in random bursts lol. Whenever he settles on a game (like playing straight melee for a week or brawl), he can achieve high tier. Kyuu and Poncho would be mid in melee (they used to be pretty nice), but they've gone pretty much 100% brawl now so like.... yea. Neither of them even wanna touch melee lol.
its actually quite similar to ultimas list, but my bound for the tiers were a bit wider considering how many players i ranked (the entire crew lol)
For the people that ultima ranked, I completely agree with the melee, but the brawl needs a lil work. Dapuff and rogue are easily on me and vex's level, xzax is definitely high tier material.
on a side note, i think id challenge my top tier brawl team against any other crew in the atl north for like $10-$15 each member lol. except maybe h2yl. thats it. lol. its tooooo ****