Official Marth Stage Discussion #4 Yoshi's Island (Brawl)

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Ok here we go with Yoshi's Island!

Go! O.o

 

[Hype]

Every time you get edge hogged DI away and the platform might just come up.

ill add more later.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

I love this stage. I cp it against Pit and others who recover under the stage, and the platform is quite helpful. I say 8.5 out of 10.

 

[Nibbity]

good stuff to B up and land on the upper platform for less recovery time for sure, but we all knew that. It's a nice small stage, and the platform is definitely to your advantage, even when it tilts. The platforms that appear randomly have never helped me, because it's fairly easy to recover on this stage. I might recommend this to be a good counter stage for people who chain grab because of how short it is. The air between the stage and the end seems longer though, so just be aware of that. I think of it as a 6, maybe 7.

 

[Remzi]

Ledge drop to spike ftw here. That is all

 

[OmegaXF]

Other than the random platforms this stage is okay.

 

[Desire]

I f***ing hate this stage.


The random platform is bullsh*t.

I have no luck with this stage.

there is no need to go over stages and discuss >_>

you play brawl for couple weeks and there you go.

 

[hippiedude92]

The tilted edges are nice place to place your dtilt edgeguards there.

 

[grandmaster192]

I hate this stage with Marth, because if you hit those flying things your attack gets delayed. I also don't like the fact that the platform changes. Too many things that can mess up your rythem and spacing here, IMO.

It's an ok stage, but not as good as Battle Field, Delfino, and Halberd are for Marth IMO.

 

[Steel]

This is probably Marth's worst neutral.

 

[feardragon64]

I give it a 5.5 or a 6 for marth. Like steel said, Marth's worst neutral. Random crap going on with platforms that prevents gimping half the time, platform honestly gets in the way imo for Marth since it can tilt down to his actual body level. Also, on this stage I have trouble sweet-spotting the ledge when I'm up against the right wall and below the ledge for some reason. I always end up going above the platform....But that might just be me.

 

[Punishment Divine]

I hate this stage for almost every character, but especially for Marth. I usually ban it if I only get to ban a neutral and a CP and not two CPs.

The platform in the middle never seems to work out for me. I have real problems juggling with just a random, constantly changing platform in the way, and WHENEVER I spike someone on this stage Roger the ****ing Random *** Platform shows up to save the day. The unbalances on the stage floor and the shyguys mess my spacing up occasionally. and characters with massive/gay dtilts like MK and GnW can edgeguard you with them, although you might be able to do that too.

And those ****ing Yoshis singing, the random background switches. Ugh. Maybe it's just personal bias, but I find this stage, for both tactical reasons like shyguys and uneven stage base but also personal i.e. Roger never saving the day for me but always for my opponent, to be quite homo.

 

[Pierce7d]

The main thing to watch out for in this stage is the sliding. Perfectly spacing a Fair doesn't apply here, since you will slide towards your opponent anyway, and you will be more frequently punished. Use Dolphin Slash frame trap for mixups, and use the platform as a mindgame to help avoid punishment by mixing up your landing.

 

[3xSwords]

I hate this stage b/c Marth doesn't have the ability to effectively punish the opponent for hanging on the edge for too long, without putting yourself at risk. But I find Lylat to be worse than this, although it may be personally reasons, however the same thing can occur on Lylat when it tilits.

...... 5/10? For Yoshi's

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

I'll go with 5/10, and I'll ut up a new one, I think we have all we need for this one.

 

[Pierce7d]

hitting 4 Shy Guys in succession with a fully charged tipper fsmash will definitely mindgame your opponent, and probably result in free damage or a K.O., especially if they were standing there shielding.

 

[feardragon64]

hitting 4 Shy Guys in succession with a fully charged tipper fsmash will definitely mindgame your opponent, and probably result in free damage or a K.O., especially if they were standing there shielding.

lol, good luck timing and setting that up without making it obvious that you're planning something

 

[Desire]

I hate this stage with Marth, because if you hit those flying things your attack gets delayed. I also don't like the fact that the platform changes. Too many things that can mess up your rythem and spacing here, IMO.

It's an ok stage, but not as good as Battle Field, Delfino, and Halberd are for Marth IMO.

I dont know what your saying.

So your saying marth uses projectile?

Edit. The upper platfrom tilts, but it really doesnt matter, unless you r goin for u smash.

Besides the random platform that pops otta no where, this stage is 7/10 for me

 

[VietGeek]

I dont know what your saying.

So your saying marth uses projectile?

Edit. The upper platfrom tilts, but it really doesnt matter, unless you r goin for u smash

You're chill in real life man, but your reading comprehension is...fail. He means it throws off the spacing game for Marth due to how the platform changes. Nowhere does it hint about projectile play, more like momentum.

That, by the way, allows you to platform cancel since it's a moving platform, yay? Also, the random ghost platforms basically kill your ledgehopped Dair since it's stationed also at the end of the tip so that they get spiked into the platform at times.

Granted it can mess up juggling or something, or make it harder to kill w/ a smash due to the weird angles the platform likes to take, but eh, it's alright. The ceiling is high anyway, so your Uair/Utilt/Usmash poking through the platform won't change much.

Shy Guys regenerate moves so whacking them is fun. They also can cover for projectiles, such as PK Thunder, Gyro, whatever.

It's an okay stage. It's 7.5/10 I suppose.

 

[Desire]

flying things = shy guys

thats how i understood.

 

[Hype]

hitting 4 Shy Guys in succession with a fully charged tipper fsmash will definitely mindgame your opponent, and probably result in free damage or a K.O., especially if they were standing there shielding.

I've been killed by a falcon punch because of the hitlag on the shy guys

Btw are the side platforms and center platform random with the time of how they move.

 

[Nightshine]

eh was never really a fan of anything yoshi so i never really played on the stages but this stage is ok. personally i prefer a dangerous stage to play on like norfiar or spear pillar.

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

Lol at Spear Pillar... This is a competetive Stage Discussion, no baned stages plz.

 

[Nightshine]

Lol at Spear Pillar... This is a competetive Stage Discussion, no baned stages plz.

O my bad, sorry

 

[¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯]

It's OK, you are new, NBD.

 

[Pr0phetic]

I love this stage, visually and tactically, It has a plat for juggles, no underside for flying recoveries, and makes great place for stage spiking or DB'ing someone too their death on their last stock.

9/10

 

[chaos_]

i hate this stage the random plat form is so much bull ****.

you can't even really stall if there trying to edge hog and for me when i get hit off the edge that random platform comes up and i die

 

[BacklashMarth]

IF the platforms never save you or come in handy, then you just fail at luck and life. >.< This is is a relatively flat stage with a platform and marth does well on stages like this. You just have to alter your playstyle a little, its not all that hard.

 

[VietGeek]

IF the platforms never save you or come in handy, then you just fail at luck an life. >.< This is is a relatively flat stage with a platform and marth does well on stages like this. You just have to alter your playstyle a little, its not all that hard.

Watch your mouth.

 

[streetracr77]

Ok stage, never had any good kills on it. Just average. 6/10