I mean no disrespect when I say this, because I believe your sonic is awesome. But you do realize that just because YOU know sonic's flaws, and how to beat him, doesn't mean that others do. And most people at this point will claim that " if you can't beat sonic you're an idiot" well what does that then say about beating them?
Just because other people aren't aware about his many flaws doesn't make him good.
I've seen you beat really good people with sonic. But i'm also aware that MANY smashers simply do not know what to do vs the character. Same goes for alot of chars.
Has nothing to do with the character imo. I like to take credit for winning matches where I have to repeat the same thing over and over(spin dash) bc there is no other method of damage instead of doing a move right after a spin dash lands a hit.
Regardless of whether in some theoretical space and time sonic is the most simple character to defeat, he is difficult to deal with in REAL LIFE. He is fast, he runs away, he has spinny attacks that most people don't understand. Also, like every sonic player is willing to go 2 the timer lol.
He is not difficult to deal with. He's fast.....ok so? What options does he have with running speed thats confusing? His speed is used to run away in order to charge up yet another spin dash. People not understanding his spinny attacks makes him good? How? He has side B and down B. They are very easy to tell apart(one hops and moves back, the other doesnt and stays in place). There is barely any difference between them anyway except sheld canceling side B.
I have gone to the timer intentionally twice since I started playing brawl and once was with Diddy. It's not every sonic, only the bad ones. It happens naturally against DDD though.
Forcing the fact that he is a bad character down people's throats, doesn't change the fact that he is actually a good tournament choice in many situations because of the surprise factor he offers, with or without his strengths/ weaknesses as a character.
What is happening is rarely what should/could be happening when it comes to this game.
People can believe what they want to believe. If I beat someone they obviously aren't going to accept that hes bad and not viable. If you claim that he's a good tournament character based on surprises, then every low tier would fall under that excuse. It just means that they have to work (much)harder the moment those exploits, which dont do much anyway, wear off.
Another reason he isn't a good tournament choice is bc of the tournament characters that are often played. I'll use S tier and A tier as an example since most of them are commonly played in our region anyway. I wont bother with ratios since those vary by person of how extreme the matchup is but ill give my honest opinion in wording.
Meta Knight( sonic loses, not bad though)
Snake( Horrible)
Wario(horrible)
Falco(Sonic loses, I think 6:4 but others say worse)
Diddy Kong(loses, not badly)
King Dedede(loses, not badly)
Marth(awful)
Mr. Game & Watch(awful)
Pikachu(even imo)
Olimar( sonic can't win vs a good oli)
Ice Climbers(awful)
R.O.B.(bad, like 65:35)
Kirby(even)
right under these chracters is Lucario on the list. I'll include him bc zucco is a big threat in our area. Losses horribly to lucario too.
Little tricks and exploits only get you so far. He barely has any anyway. You see most of them first round and if someone cant adapt then tough. It's much harder to win with sonic than every other character on the roster above him and like 3 below him. Ally beats amazing people with Falcon. He wrecked my sonic in low tiers in 2 sets. He's a good player. It wasn't falcon.
Btw, I'm not johnning about my character. I'm well aware of the arguement "well if hes so bad then why use him?" I like him, know him, and use him well vs a lot of characters. Thats why.