When I say Punch-Out is perfection, I mean it literally. It's the perfect game. You play it, and it's hard. Real hard. But it plays by the rules. The controls are simple, and intuitive, so it's not hard because you're fighting the controls, like so many other NES games. It's not random, so you're not fighting the RNG. It comes down to reflexes, and memory. It's fair.
It's a hard game that can be crushed under foot, demolished like it's nothing, if you just learn the pattern. People actually play it blindfolded now.
The Wii game is fun, certainly, but it's far less rewarding.
The NES game has one flaw, and one flaw alone. Little Mac's trunks spontaneously change color when you win a match.
I feel like the Wii game is just as if not more rewarding. I understand the NES had that old-school hard mentality but the color and advancement Wii had was incredible.
Take the Minor Circuit, you fight in a small arena with maybe a hundred people and you are just getting your bearings. Then you go to the Major Circuit and you get a change of scenery in the arena and clothes, you showed that you've gotten stronger and the opposition has as well.
Title Defense is perfect that way as well, you go through the those same opponents who have now learned all of your tricks and have to outsmart them again with your fast and precise punches.
The boxers also show characteristics they didn't have in the NES game, look at Aryn Ryan and Don Flamenco. Mac's Last Stand has that progression as well, as you get older, you come to terms that tour time is up and you try to go out with a bang even beating the first member of the DK crew while at it. And after you lose 3 matches the whole profile locks you out and you can't access it because it says you've retired and shows that to you.
You underestimate the Wii game so much and others as well. Next Kevel Games did it better than Nintendo's inner development centers
Control and gameplay wise is much more defined with better options for offensive and defensive strategies like real boxing. Like for example Little Mac being able to duck and avoid punches.
The gameplay designs its self well around those mechanics and gives you a challenging run. Title Defense mode made players actually lose to Glass Joe because he learns your tricks ad brings some of his own to the table.
And what makes it better that it gets lot harder from here
That's challenge, the perfect storm of epic duels against the boxers who STILL underestimate you and you're the champ.
Plus the ability of Second wind gets me into that in the zone
ZEN MODE that the NES game will never touch.
Sorry vaanrose, while the NES game is perfect, the Wii game game is God's gift to gaming is the only reason why I still have my Wii