At the cost of roasting myself on a stake, I honestly have mixed feelings on this.
The aesthetics look and feel really dumbed down. For a Nickelodeon game, you would think there would be popping visuals and dynamic movement but things feel - subdued and silenced. I would have much rather had it in a 2.3D environment with more comical visuals rather than the 3D models they went with. The expressions and interaction just isn’t there. The same could be said with Ultimate but, it’s like if you took Ultimate and made it look like Brawlout with expressions and animation from PSASBR. The characters are there but they don’t look like it.
Also like PSASBR, the Gravity feels wonky. Everyone looks fairly floaty. That was one aspect I hated about the game. Likewise, it feels there’s no impact to the moves. That’s one thing that Ultimate and Smash excels at is showing the hits hit hard. I never got the feeling of that in PSASBR and I’m getting that same feeling in this game.
The roster is pretty amazing though. Again, to further risk getting loading onto a catapult full of cow **** and getting launched out, I’m not a fan of the cartoon medium. I grew up not watching cartoons save for a few such as Hanana-Barbara and that’s cause my parents screened them as a kid. They watched Ren & Stimpy at my behest and we’re shocked. They assumed Nick was more or less the same throughout. It wasn’t until I was old enough to bypass that and I became more interested in things like Toonami. Even then, I only watched a few shows. As a grown up, I tend to avoid these mediums as they do nothing for me and I have zero interest in investing my time to watching them. I am not really open to watching acrtoons but if you want to suggest a few to me, I am all ears.
Now, with that being said, even I know characters in this roster. Obviously the Sponge Bob gang, TMNT, Zim, Reptar, and yes, even Helga, Nigel, and …. Hmmm…. That’s about it. I was allowed to see a collect few of the Nick shows so perhaps I drawing into some potential territory. I would like to see perhaps Quail Man, the boy and his fairy godparents (forgot the name), and Jimmy Neutron.
As for Gate keeping, I don’t see Nick Jr getting in as, by nature, that programming would be against violence of any kind. I’m kind of in a Nick Jr phase as my kids are that age so shows like Paw Patrol, Blaze, Blue Clues Reboot, Bubbleguppies, some show whose name I forgot but has a robot, and Santiago is constantly on. Even that, I don’t expect and would prefer not seeing these added. Wouldn’t make much sense (but still be pretty funny to see Blue square up against Sandy or something.)