Honestly I just think Dr. Mario is funny because if he hadn't gotten in Melee, he'd be seen as an utterly deranged choice. Like in the alternate timeline where he does not get in Smash, if you suggested him, you'd get your **** kicked in and be called a madman. But due to specific circumstances he's just been grandfathered into the Smash roster. It's hilarious
We're so used to the Melee characters, but I can only imagine when the game was coming out/had recently dropped. What a weird cluster**** of new additions.
Peach and Bowser make sense. But then thinking your new Zelda character was just Sheik. The one-off transformation who didn't really do much, over Zelda or Ganon/dorf. Then you do get Zelda, and, it's not like her own arsenal was that deep then, but she just uses non-faithful versions of things Link does. Which is nothing to say of Ganondorf, who everyone was psyched on, and then he's just a Captain Falcon clone.
And then Ice Climbers, who are ok? But... very very random. Like, there's no Wario, there's no Diddy, there's no Dedede... but there's Ice Climbers. Even Pit was more popular. Little Mac too, probably, in the west.
Then there are these two randos named Marth and Roy and I have no ****ing clue where they're from. I mean they're cool and all but it's harder to by hyped when you've no idea who they are. But they're cool. Still trying to figure out if Marth is a girl, can someone who speaks Japanese clarify?
But it's cool they added Mewtwo, people like him. Wait... this dude is no fun at all to play. Dang, they ruined Mewtwo. Yeah, cut this guy (seriously, there was a notable contingent who wanted Mewtwo cut... until he was cut). Oh, and there's Pichu. Yay.... wait, he hurts himself, and he dies at like 50%? Sakurai!
Also what the **** is a Mr. Game and Watch? What does that mean?!? WHO IS THIS??
And why on earth would they add Dr. Mario when they could've added Wario?! He's just... another Mario... (Obviously good they didn't, but I don't doubt this was a take back then). And speaking of just another: Young Link? We already have Link? Why do we need
Young Link? Why are there so many clones?! Falco is cool though.
This game is really fun and all but a lot of these new characters choices are kinda [insert outdated c. 2001 insult here]. Also why are there so many Zelda characters when Metroid and Kirby and DK only have one?
Don't worry, next time they'll add Ridley. He was already in the opening trailer.
Not saying everyone would've been like this, but I can only imagine there was a bit of whiplash to what is, to be fair, very much not the strongest lineup of newcomers Smash has had.