Ridrool64
Smash Lord
On one hand, Ezio is infinitely more popular than Rayman amongst the general audience, on the other Rayman's the one where people have been asking for him more often...
Lloyd vs. Yuri 2.
Lloyd vs. Yuri 2.
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
More like Steve vs Banjo 2On one hand, Ezio is infinitely more popular than Rayman amongst the general audience, on the other Rayman's the one where people have been asking for him more often...
Lloyd vs. Yuri 2.
On the other hand, you have Geno vs Hero.More like Steve vs Banjo 2
And in that case, the character Smash fans have been asking for beat the more popular character among the general audience.
Cool. So now we know you think animation springs to life the day that it airs in Japan. It takes a long time to get a whole series up and running. If an episode aired 6 months before the character was announced in Smash, then that anime was in production for at least a year before that episode even aired, in fact it was probably being made alongside the development of the relevant game.Greninja was chosen way before that. Did you even read the interview? Greninja was chosen based upon concept art before X/Y and the Anime premiered. You're looking at it entirely wrong. Development happened way beforehand. The only other possibility is that Greninja was chosen for Ash regardless of the Smash thing, being a coincidence. Sakurai did not choose Greninja in any way related to the anime at all. There's absolutely zero evidence to suggest that.
https://www.siliconera.com/2014/06/10/super-smash-bros-characters-decided-upon-early-development/ Here's the interview. All it notes is concept art at best. I'll find the Incineroar one later. But yeah, it's Pokemon. Of course it got a new character. People expect one for a reason.
Likewise with Incineroar. He was chosen based upon concept art, which while it did show the Pokemon with Ash as well, it's notable that Sakurai specified he wanted the cat because of Wrestling. It had, again, nothing to do with the anime. He'd have mentioned it if it was related, but it wasn't. What you said was absolutely incorrect and has no actual basis when actually researched. Sure, it's remotely possible Sakurai was told they were going to be in the anime, but zero evidence suggests that. In addition, all the statements suggest it was an irrelevant factor and he's already aware Starters show up in the anime all the time, so it's not like it even matters. Both are purely concept art and "I liked this moveset" more, along with "Pokemon should have a new entry due to its legacy". There's zero evidence to suggest otherwise at this time.
Except he does. Gamefreak literally outright said that Sakurai chooses the character. They chose to have it that way, and it's stayed that way since development of every game.Cool. So now we know you think animation springs to life the day that it airs in Japan. It takes a long time to get a whole series up and running. If an episode aired 6 months before the character was announced in Smash, then that anime was in production for at least a year before that episode even aired, in fact it was probably being made alongside the development of the relevant game.
These decisions were 100% made in tandem. And to say otherwise ignores just how much work The Pokemon Company does to make sure each generation hits with all its content at the same time
Sakurai doesnt get to walk into GameFreak and chose whatever Pokemon he wants. He's given a short list of stuff that TPC would want to see there. I'm sure the list for Gen 8 was Incineroar, Decidueye, Mimikyu and Lycanroc. He chose Incineroar cus of moveset. No debate there. But he does not have free reign to pick whoever he wants.
“Well first of all, we talk with the Pokemon company,” explained designer Masahiro Sakurai when we put the question to him. “What’s the hot Pokemon? What Pokemon are in the movies right now? And really do a lot of research on that front. “For example, X and Y are coming out – of course, we haven’t done any market research because they’re not out yet, but we look at the animated series or movies and anything like that and again, find out which ones are going to be central to any of conversations in Pokemon going forward. “But it’s not just that – going back to just what we talked about, what’s unique about them? Where do they fit in with the rest of everything else? What do they have? It’s a combination of those things.Except he does. Gamefreak literally outright said that Sakurai chooses the character. They chose to have it that way, and it's stayed that way since development of every game.
I’ve been playing a ton of Smash Bros. lately, as I’m sure everybody has. How involved are you are in the selection of the Pokémon who make it in the game? How did Greninja get into the game? Even since the very first Smash Bros., it’s been Mr. Sakurai coming to us with ideas saying, “If we put this Pokemon in this game – in Smash Bros. – we’d be able to show it off in a really cool way and do something really cool with it.” The origin comes from Mr. Sakurai. We typically go with what he wants to do because he’s really thinking of not just showing off the character in a cool way, but making sure it makes sense and works really well from a gameplay perspective. We leave it up to him.
Now where they actually do stuff is things like costumes. And that's more TPC, since Gamefreak really doesn't take initiative at all with the Pokemon stuff in Smash. TPC, on the other hand, does. But it wasn't them who chose Greninja. At most, they provide the specific concept arts, so there's a small illusion that they somewhat help with the choices made. But it's still Sakurai in the end.
You also seem to be under the impression Sakurai goes to TPC to get a Pokemon character. There's literally only evidence he goes to Gamefreak specifically. TPC is really more that they control some of the actual final representation, I.E. costumes. It's unknown how exactly they are involved, but we know from this interview they aren't the ones remotely choosing any playable Pokemon at all. It's always been Sakurai from the start, as noted here. Is it possible they chose a few? Maybe. But there's a serious lack of evidence to suggest that could possibly be the case.
You missed a huge amount of context of timing. Again, the fact that Greninja and Incineroar were the only ones chosen based upon concept art, not from stuff already out. Cherrypicking while ignoring this still shows you're completely wrong about why they were chosen. There was nothing anime-related for those two. Did you 100% ignore the concept art factor? Did you entirely ignore that Sakurai only chose Incineroar over Decidueye because of the Wrestler archtype. The statements are extremely clear on why they were chosen. In fact, there's a bit more to Greninja than what I linked;
I'm not saying they were chosen for the anime? I'm saying the anime is a key promotional part of any Pokemon generation where you can see the marketing arm of TPC working at full force. Pokemon is a symbiotic entity made up of more than just the games. In fact the games aren't even the main money maker for the franchise at this point, it's just where the designs come from.You missed a huge amount of context of timing. Again, the fact that Greninja and Incineroar were the only ones chosen based upon concept art, not from stuff already out. Cherrypicking while ignoring this still shows you're completely wrong about why they were chosen. There was nothing anime-related for those two. Did you 100% ignore the concept art factor? Did you entirely ignore that Sakurai only chose Incineroar over Decidueye because of the Wrestler archtype. The statements are extremely clear on why they were chosen. In fact, there's a bit more to Greninja than what I linked;
https://mynintendonews.com/2014/12/...he-inclusion-of-greninja-in-super-smash-bros/ This is a bit more clear. He literally had nothing but concept art to go off of. The quote you linked is entirely misleading. There was no marketing for X/Y to go off of at that point. It didn't exist yet.
The Pokemon chosen due to the anime were not even remotely Greninja nor Incineroar. They were chosen because a slot was put aside. The only one close to a promotional pick due to the anime soon coming out was Lucario only. That was directly due to the movie releasing at the right time. That's why the time entirely based it upon the movie/anime design, with the full Aura-based abilities. The rest of the Pokemon are far closer to the games, though many clearly have anime influences, as well as are hugely popular in them. Sakurai wanted to include Mewtwo in the first game too, especially when the movie was hot. The second movie helped. Pichu's addition was perfect timing for a clone due to the movies. Jigglypuff was hugely popular in the anime. Charizard as a whole too(Squirtle and Ivysaur, just like Incineroar and Greninja, were not influenced at all by the anime, as the reasons that were given were entirely unrelated. Though I imagine they went for Squirtle over Bulbasaur likely due to the anime, but there's no evidence at all beyond Smash referencing Ash here and there at best. And that's just correlation, not causation).
And on Incineroar;
When planning began around December of 2015, I had resolved that I had to have all kinds of fighters in the game. Generally, though, I can’t really add a character from a game that hasn’t come out yet to the roster… So, I left one character frame open for Pokémon, and after Pokémon: Ultra Sun and Ultra Moon came out I took another look at it. That resulted in Incineroar being chosen. I wanted to try making a pro-wrestler type character at least once! Incineroar is voiced by the late Mr. Unshō Ishizuka – of Professor. Oak fame – who passed away back in August; he had recorded new lines just for this game. May he rest in peace.
I'll just keep it short and sweet; they were chosen by Sakurai before any actual marketing took place. It's impossible they were chosen for marketing reasons. Timing doesn't match up. It's hard proven(as well) by the fact that Sakurai chose Greninja based upon illustrations only, and that he directly said his influence was Wrestling, not "marketing". Correlation is not causation, as they say.Right and I'm 100% done.
To be honest, there's really no one from Gen 2 I honestly would like over Pichu. I love the guy. 3 is hard to say now. At one point, I liked the idea of Deoxys. Gen 5 is Genesect for me easily.Can we actually talk about newcomers? Man I would love it if we got an actual Gen 2, 3 and 5 reps. My personal choices would be Scizor, Sceptile/Blaziken or Reuniclus.
One of the big new things Three Houses introduces is something Edelgard has proficiency in, the Authority skill. This allows her to bring a battalion of generic NPCs into battle alongside her for use in Gambit attacks.Edelgard's my safest bet at the moment. I just wonder how much can be done to stand her apart from the sword collective.
I'm not so sure that Rayman v Ezio is that similar. We have no idea if Ubisoft buying out Brawlhalla and getting Rayman into that game - before Sakurai had finalized the Fighter Pass roster IIRC - hurts his chances or not. While I've brought up Ezio's VA, Roger Craig Smith, before: we have no idea if he has to be credited in-game as Ezio (like Steve Burton must be for Cloud) which would really hurt the Assassin's chances. Alongside other potential factors, like if Banjo being chosen impacts Rayman's chances or Joker being chosen affecting Ezio's.More like Steve vs Banjo 2
And in that case, the character Smash fans have been asking for beat the more popular character among the general audience.
Given that, I wouldn't be too shocked if we get a Gen 8 Pokémon in this pass or later on, despite recency factors seemingly getting in the way.I'll just keep it short and sweet; they were chosen by Sakurai before any actual marketing took place. It's impossible they were chosen for marketing reasons. Timing doesn't match up. It's hard proven(as well) by the fact that Sakurai chose Greninja based upon illustrations only, and that he directly said his influence was Wrestling, not "marketing". Correlation is not causation, as they say.
To be honest, there's really no one from Gen 2 I honestly would like over Pichu. I love the guy. 3 is hard to say now. At one point, I liked the idea of Deoxys. Gen 5 is Genesect for me easily.
It still bugs me that his friends have been ignored this time. And the Rabbid spirits in here are more strongly related to the Mario series than their own property. What the bleeding hell is even going on?(Also, Rayman's Spirit baffles me to no end. Not because of any difficulty, no: He's just an Ace level spirit, it's Sukapon that's Legend.)
Out of three revealed characters, only one of them use a sword. The scenario you're proposing is simply impossible.I know I'm going to be chewed out for this because I always do. But 3 out if the 5 slots being dedicated to JRPG anime inspired Humans that primarily use a sword like object would annoy the hell out of me. I know I know the first thing people are going to say to me is that they will play differently. But still. I would like some variety in genre choices and weapon choices.
Also Joker technically uses a daggerOut of three revealed characters, only one of them use a sword. The scenario you're proposing is simply impossible.
I'm talking about with the possibility of Lloyd. And I knew people would act like Joker doesn't use a sword so that's why I put Sword like object because it basically looks and acts like one. I guess it just being a super long dagger somehow makes it different? :VOut of three revealed characters, only one of them use a sword. The scenario you're proposing is simply impossible.
It definitely doesn't act like one. Swords are known for extended range. Joker's dagger doesn't have much range at all.I'm talking about with the possibility of Lloyd. And I knew people would act like Joker doesn't use a sword so that's why I put Sword like object because it basically looks and acts like one. I guess it just being a super long dagger somehow makes it different? :V
This is how Style Savvy Rep can still winHmm... I'm wondering, what if Joker isn't the only "You never see it comiiiiiiing~" character in the fighter pass.
Not as in no leaks but if they were to appear in a leak we'd all dismiss it as being poppycock and random.
Banjo has been on a lot of wanted lists even if we thought it was impossible
and Dragon Quest is the official state religion of Japan
Things like, say, the car from Daytona USA or Dysentery from Oregon Trail
Given Sakurai likes to surprise us I think that's definitely in the realm of possibility. Only question is what character would be up in Joker's rally of "You never saw it coming"?Hmm... I'm wondering, what if Joker isn't the only "You never see it comiiiiiiing~" character in the fighter pass.
Hmm... I'm wondering, what if Joker isn't the only "You never see it comiiiiiiing~" character in the fighter pass.
Not as in no leaks but if they were to appear in a leak we'd all dismiss it as being poppycock and random.
Banjo has been on a lot of wanted lists even if we thought it was impossible
and Dragon Quest is the official state religion of Japan
Things like, say, the car from Daytona USA or Dysentery from Oregon Trail
I didn't know they nerfed Ike's weight.-Also would be an unique sword fighter with an interesting moveset compared from others and first heavy weight one to boot.
Ike's an heavy weight? Didn't seem like so. When I think of heavy weights I think of hefty looking characters like Bowser and King K. Rool.I didn't know they nerfed Ike's weight.
I one hundred percent agree with you. The Tales series is pretty much the last long standing JRPG yet in the game, if we exclude Megami Tensei because of Joker(although they may double back for that series in the next game... possibly). The only remaining JRPG of the same caliber (if we use Tales as the bar) is Kingdom Hearts if we are going by the best selling JRPGs.Getting Lloyd in would solidify ALL of the great jrpgs in smash, so I’m in favor of it.
You are talking about super heavy weights.Ike's an heavy weight? Didn't seem like so. When I think of heavy weights I think of hefty looking characters like Bowser and King K. Rool.
My bad then. Still it'd be nice to get another heavy weight sword user added to the roster never the less.
I mean it's similar in the sense that you have a fan favorite with demand (Banjo = Rayman) vs a less demanded character who people say is likely soley cause of series sales (steve=Ezio) *although I will say Steve actually has some demand where Ezio has none*I'm not so sure that Rayman v Ezio is that similar. We have no idea if Ubisoft buying out Brawlhalla and getting Rayman into that game - before Sakurai had finalized the Fighter Pass roster IIRC - hurts his chances or not. While I've brought up Ezio's VA, Roger Craig Smith, before: we have no idea if he has to be credited in-game as Ezio (like Steve Burton must be for Cloud) which would really hurt the Assassin's chances. Alongside other potential factors, like if Banjo being chosen impacts Rayman's chances or Joker being chosen affecting Ezio's.
(Also, Rayman's Spirit baffles me to no end. Not because of any difficulty, no: He's just an Ace level spirit, it's Sukapon that's Legend.)
However, Rayman is not demanded in the same way BK was.I mean it's similar in the sense that you have a fan favorite with demand (Banjo = Rayman) vs a less demanded character who people say is likely soley cause of series sales (steve=Ezio) *although I will say Steve actually has some demand where Ezio has none*
I don't think we're getting a Ubisoft rep on this pass. But if we get one in a future pass, then I'd say we'd most likely get Rayman if Banjo is anything to go by that fan demand matters.
Also I don't think the grade of a spirit really means anything for future chances lol
I feel like a broken record, but we literally got Hero in the same direct over more speculated characters like Geno, along with Banjo.I mean it's similar in the sense that you have a fan favorite with demand (Banjo = Rayman) vs a less demanded character who people say is likely soley cause of series sales (steve=Ezio) *although I will say Steve actually has some demand where Ezio has none*
I don't think we're getting a Ubisoft rep on this pass. But if we get one in a future pass, then I'd say we'd most likely get Rayman if Banjo is anything to go by that fan demand matters.
Also I don't think the grade of a spirit really means anything for future chances lol
Imagine that.This is how Style Savvy Rep can still win