What would your reaction be if we got 10 more DLC characters after the Fighter's Pass but they were Waluigi, Geno, Bomberman, Crash, Lloyd Irving, Phoenix Wright, Isaac, Bandana Dee, Skull Kid and Sora?
Okay, so my take:
Waluigi: 10 / 5 Mastahpiece. Time for Anarchy!
Geno: Eh, neutral on him. Could be a very interesting moveset, but if I'm being perfectly honest he seems to be more fitting as a base roster pick, pardon my Greek.
Bomberman: Also neutral. Could have more potential then expected, but never grew up on the character.
Crash: 8 / 10. Not my favorite Activision-Blizzard pick (I grew up on Blizzards, see), but damn he'd be one of the prime characters if Sakurai wanted to say "Screw console wars". Support.
Lloyd: Neutral, if only because I'm leaning heavily on Yuri "Learnt from the GLSoSaGT*" Lowell for my Tales pick. Double swords could be cool I guess.
Phoenix Wright: 8 / 10 see you in court. While not my favorite Capcom pick (that goes to Amaterasu) his UMVC3 portrayal won me over. Bonus points if they somehow manage to get
Hong Kong / Chinese actor Aaron Kwok to do his mo-cap.
Isaac: Neutral but overall leaning towards positive. Unrepresented series, moveset potential and something unique to call his own.
Bandada Dee: Sorry but screams "Base Roster" IMHO. Otherwise I'm fine with him honestly.
Skull Kid: "Base Roster", again. Could be interesting (hey, fairies could be a unique thing for attacks), but I'm really struggling to see him as DLC.
Sora: 9 / 10. Not my absolute favorite S-E rep (Lara Croft and 2B duke it out for that slot), but I love Kingdom Hearts' ridicolous story, combo system out of this world etc. Extra points if Balloonga's included. Because I want to see the combos get even more ridicolous.
I'm buying any announced DLC characters (as I did with the FP) Day 1 because I trust Sakurai and Sora Ltd. to develop great characters and I trust Furukawa and the other Nintendo execs to help pick them. That fact wouldn't change with this lineup, regardless of my opinions.
*(George Lucas' School of Spinning and Good Tricks)